Not All Who Wander Are Lost
This whole series on James I’ve been wrestling with this question. “But what about the person who is disillusioned with this whole thing?”
I know, I know, such a response feels a little burned out. I know there are some who get all revved up and excited by James’ hard hitting truths and calls for faith.
But what if it’s not connecting? What if the challenges of James fall flat?
It’s kind of like a coach who has an athlete that just doesn’t seem to love the game any more. They keep encouraging, correcting, trying to point out small tweaks and subtle shifts to get them back on track.
But what if they’ve lost their love for the game?
I think I was surprised to hear in James 5 that James ultimately has the same concern. For as challenging and hard hitting as James can be as a coach of the faithful, James closes his work with this wonderfully gentle call,
19 My brothers and sisters, if one of you should wander from the truth and someone should bring that person back, 20 remember this: Whoever turns a sinner from the error of their way will save them from death and cover over a multitude of sins. (James 5:19-20)
That’s it. James’ closing vision is the need to restore those who have wandered. And with that same fire-y intensity, James concludes, “If you do this, they will be saved from death.” But notice how ambiguously that last phrase is worded, “and cover over a multitude of sins.”
A scholar I was reading on this pointed out the Greek is unclear - is it the sinner whose sins are covered over or the one who is rescuing the sinner?
It reminds me of the story where a paralyzed man is lowered through a ceiling to Jesus. It’s a desperate act. One of utter dependency. Yet for those of us who have been tracking the stories about Jesus, we know what Jesus will do. Jesus is kind. He will pause and take pity on this man, and likely will heal him. And this of course is what Jesus does. But there is a twist that is easy to miss if you’re not paying attention. As the man is lowered down and Jesus sees him, Jesus pauses his teaching. And presumably Jesus looks up, and as he looks up he sees the heads of the friends poking through the thatch. Incredibly, to the shock of the reader, Luke tells us that
when Jesus saw their faith, he said to the man, “Friend, your sins are forgiven.” (Luke 5:20)
James of course knew this Jesus. He also knew Jesus taught that loving shepherd will leave a flock of 99 to seek out the 1. He knew that Jesus told the story of a woman who dropped everything and upended her house in order to find the one coin that had been lost. And James surely also knew the story about a certain prodigal son, who after wandering far away, is restored home to the Father’s love.
The Christian story has always been about those who are wandering and has always contained a summons not just to beckon them home but to seek them out and if possible restore them to the Father’s love.
There is this line by J.R.R. Tolkien that he gives to Strider, that shrouded figure in exile who is long in waiting on evil to be defeated and the throne to be restored. It reads: “Not all who wander are lost [https://youtu.be/H7JvHxgVvbw].”
My prayer for you if you have been following this series, is that you would find a faith that actually works. Not one engulfed in hypocrisy. Not one mired in self-doubt. Not one cloaked as righteousness but in reality is self-righteous rage. But rather that you would find a faith that works.
James and Jesus want to remind us, there is always a way back for those who have wandered. There is always a feast waiting upon your return [https://youtu.be/H7JvHxgVvbw].
May we learn to seek out those who have wandered. And may we ourselves meet Jesus on the road any time we stray from the faith.
With hope,
John
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit theburningword.substack.com [https://theburningword.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1]