Calm during Crisis: What Horses Can Teach Us About Leading through Uncertainty
The strongest leaders are the ones who can stay grounded long enough to notice what matters, regulate themselves under pressure, and create enough trust that others are willing to move with them through uncertainty. When a crisis comes, panic can follow. And if leaders lose trust, chaos will ensue.
In this conversation on the Leading with Instinct podcast, Katie Navarra-Bradley, Professional Facilitator and Leadership Coach with Katie the Coach [https://katiethecoach.com/], and Ginny Telego, President of Collaboration Partners [https://www.thecollaborationpartners.com/], share a personal conversation centered around a real wildfire evacuation experience in Colorado. Ginny walks listeners through the emotional reality of seeing smoke near her home, the memories it triggered from previously losing her home in a fire, and the leadership lessons that surfaced as she prepared to evacuate her horses before an official order was ever given.
Together, they connect the experience to business leadership, emotional regulation, trust, decision-making, and how leaders navigate uncertainty in real time. These are real leadership situations businesses face every day, including crises, emergencies, organizational uncertainty, and moments where teams take emotional cues from the leader before they ever hear the words being spoken.
This episode challenges leaders to think about where uncertainty currently exists in their own leadership, how they communicate during pressure, and whether they are creating trust or simply demanding compliance.
Takeaways
– Leadership under pressure begins with regulating yourself before trying to lead others
– Trust built before a crisis determines how people respond during one
– Horses respond to energy before commands. People often do too
– “Notice, decide, move, lead” creates clarity during uncertainty
– Presence and emotional awareness help leaders avoid panic-driven decisions
– Calm direction creates trust far more effectively than forced compliance
– Leaders need a “North Star” they can return to during uncertainty
– Pausing before communicating during a crisis can completely change outcomes
– Emotional congruence matters as people sense what leaders are truly feeling
– Small moments of intentional leadership practice prepare us for bigger challenges later
The Leading With Instinct Podcast is brought to you by Collaboration Partners [https://www.thecollaborationpartners.com] and KatieTheCoach.com [https://katiethecoach.com].
Chapters
00:57 Introduction
01:27 Stories from a Colorado Wildfire
07:39 Past Experiences with Loss from Fire
10:18 Presence during Crisis
18:38 Navigating Our Emotions
29:07 Forced Compliance vs Earning Trust
38:29 Closing Thoughts/Channeling Your Inner Ginny
Helpful Links:
Katie Navarra-Bradley, Katie The Coach: https://katiethecoach.com/ [https://katiethecoach.com/]
Ginny Telego, Collaboration Partners: https://www.thecollaborationpartners.com/