154 - Did God’s Plan Fail? Walking Through the Covenants of Scripture
If you’ve ever read through the Bible from beginning to end, you’ve probably noticed it: the arrangements keep changing. A garden. A flood. A promise to a wandering man. A law given at a mountain. A shepherd made king. And then a prophet speaking about something entirely new, written not on stone but on the heart. It can look, from the outside, like God is improvising — or worse, like one plan failed and another had to be invented. Today we’re going to walk through the major covenants of Scripture and show why that reading misses everything.
What a Covenant Is — and Why They’re Not All Doing the Same Thing
Some covenants are unconditional promises from God regardless of human response. Others are designed to expose what’s already in the human heart. Some are given to a nation, others to all humanity. If we assume they’re all trying to accomplish the same thing in the same way, we tie ourselves in knots. When we ask what each one is revealing, the whole story opens up.
The Garden and the Flood: The Problem Established
The Edenic arrangement shows us what the human condition actually is — not a flaw in God’s design, but a flaw in ours. The prohibition wasn’t arbitrary; it was an invitation to trust. And we chose otherwise. We chose, and still choose, “I know better.” The Noahic covenant follows a flood not with requirements for a reformed humanity, but with an unconditional promise. God says “never again” to a world He knows is still bent the wrong way. God’s faithfulness does not depend on human consistency — and that becomes one of the great recurring themes of the entire Bible.
Abraham: The Method Revealed
In Genesis 15, God seals a covenant with Abraham using an ancient Near Eastern ritual — animals split in two, parties walking between them. But Abram falls asleep. God alone passes through. The covenant doesn’t rest on Abraham’s performance; it rests entirely on God’s. And Genesis 15:6 gives us one of the most important sentences in all of Scripture: Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him as righteousness. Paul returns to this in Romans and Galatians to argue that the method of salvation has never changed. It was always this: trust in God’s promise, received as a gift.
Moses: The Law as Diagnostic Tool
The law at Sinai wasn’t a replacement for the promise — it serves the promise. Paul explains exactly what it was designed to do: expose the depth of our problem. The law is like a perfectly straight edge held against a crooked wall. It shows you exactly where things are off. But it doesn’t fix the wall. Israel’s repeated failures aren’t evidence that God’s plan went wrong — they’re evidence the law was working as designed. Romans 3:20 says it plainly: through the law comes the knowledge of sin, not relief from it. You can’t seek a cure unless you know you’re sick.
David and the New Covenant: The Promise Narrows, Then Arrives
The Davidic covenant pointed toward a king unlike any human king — one who would bear the sin the law exposed and establish a kingdom no human ambition could build or destroy. When the kings fail, as they all do, it’s not a collapse. It’s a confirmation that the hope was never in them. Then Jeremiah 31 arrives: a new covenant, not written on stone tablets, but on hearts. Not requiring human compliance to function — requiring a transformation of the person from the inside. Everything the other covenants revealed as broken, the New Covenant promises to restore. Jesus, on the night before His crucifixion, took the cup and said: this is the new covenant in my blood. He knew exactly what He was saying.
The Word That Holds It All Together: Hesed
There is a Hebrew word that appears over 200 times in the Old Testament, running through the covenant story like a thread: hesed — often translated as steadfast love or covenant faithfulness. It’s not affection. It’s a committed, loyal bond that does not release its hold even when the other party has failed. Jeremiah writes about it in the middle of the rubble of a destroyed Jerusalem: “The steadfast love of the Lord never ceases.” Not from a comfortable place. From the ash.
Did God’s plan fail? No. The covenants are not a series of escalating attempts with an uncertain outcome. They are the careful, patient unfolding of a story God already knew the ending of — a story that ends not in judgment, but with a man on a cross saying, It is finished.
Jill’s Links
https://jillfromthenorthwoods.com/ [https://jillfromthenorthwoods.com/]
https://www.youtube.com/@smallstepswithgod [https://www.youtube.com/@smallstepswithgod]
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/smallstepspod [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/smallstepspod]
https://twitter.com/schmern [https://twitter.com/schmern]
Email the podcast at [jill@startwithsmallsteps.com] jill@startwithsmallsteps.com [jill@startwithsmallsteps.com]
“Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language.”
Scripture quotations marked CSB have been taken from the Christian Standard Bible®, Copyright © 2017 by Holman Bible Publishers. Used by permission. Christian Standard Bible® and CSB® are federally registered trademarks of Holman Bible Publishers.
“The Scriptures quoted are from the NET Bible® http://netbible.com [http://netbible.com/] copyright ©1996, 2019 used with permission from Biblical Studies Press, L.L.C. All rights reserved”.
Bible Maps and images used with permission from https://www.bible.ca/maps/ [https://www.bible.ca/maps/] or https://www.freebibleimages.org/illustrations/bj-ot-world/ [https://www.freebibleimages.org/illustrations/bj-ot-world/]
Copyright 2014 Faithlife / Logos Bible Software. Free for non-commercial use by individuals or organizations. May be presented before live audiences; may be posted on social media; may be re-distributed. May not be used commercially. May not be modified or included in published works without permission; contact permissions@faithlife.com [permissions@faithlife.com]. Attribute as: “Copyright 2014 Faithlife / Logos Bible Software ()”.
By choosing to watch this video or listen to this podcast, you acknowledge that you are doing so of your own free will. The content shared here reflects personal experiences, faith journey, and opinions and is intended for informational and inspirational purposes only. I am not a licensed pastor, theologian, or counselor. Any spiritual reflections, devotional thoughts, or suggestions offered should not be considered a substitute for guidance from your own pastor, faith community, or professional mental health provider. You are solely responsible for any decisions or actions you take based on this content.