The Hinterkaifeck Murders

The Murder of Sherri Rasmussen

This week, we're heading to Los Angeles in the 1980s, where a shocking murder inside a quiet suburban home would remain unsolved for years. When respected nurse Sherri Rasmussen was found beaten and shot to death, detectives believed they were looking at a burglary gone wrong. But as the years passed, cracks began to appear in that theory. Evidence was overlooked. Leads were missed. And one person, hiding in plain sight, seemed to escape suspicion entirely. We'll explore the life of Sherri Rasmussen, the investigation that stalled, and the astonishing breakthrough that finally exposed a killer no one expected. So grab a drink, settle in... because this case proves that sometimes the most dangerous person isn't a stranger at all.

The Disappearance of Amy Bradley Part Two

This week, we return to the chilling mystery of The Disappearance of Amy Bradley for Part Two. After Amy vanished from the Rhapsody of the Seas, the investigation only grew stranger. As the ship docked, questions surrounding the cruise line’s response, missed opportunities, and possible sightings began to surface. We’ll dive into the theories that have haunted this case for decades from claims that Amy may have fallen overboard, to disturbing reports suggesting something far more sinister may have happened after she disappeared. Along the way, we’ll examine alleged eyewitness encounters, unanswered questions from the FBI investigation, and the haunting pieces of evidence that continue to keep this case alive nearly thirty years later. So grab a drink, settle in… because the deeper this story goes, the more unsettling it becomes.

The Disappearance of Amy Bradley Part One

This week, we’re setting sail into one of the most haunting missing persons cases ever reported: The Disappearance of Amy Bradley. In Part One, we head back to March 1998 aboard the cruise ship Rhapsody of the Seas, where a family vacation through the Caribbean took a terrifying turn. What began as a normal night onboard would soon become a mystery that has lasted for decades. We’ll explore Amy’s final known hours, the timeline leading up to her disappearance, and the strange details that immediately raised questions for investigators and her family alike. From conflicting witness accounts to the unsettling circumstances surrounding the ship itself, this case only becomes more complicated the deeper you look. So grab a drink, settle in… because this story starts with a missing woman, but it quickly drifts into far darker waters.

The Pizza Bomber

This week, we’re heading to Erie, Pennsylvania in 2003, where a bizarre bank robbery unfolded into one of the strangest and most disturbing crimes in modern history. In this episode, we explore the case of the “Pizza Bomber.” A man walks into a bank, and what follows quickly spirals into something far more complex and unsettling. We’ll touch on the key events, the people involved, and the investigation that tried to make sense of it all. So grab a drink, settle in… this one isn’t just strange, it’s downright bonkers.

The Perch Garage Murders

This week, we’re heading to a quiet road in Cornwall, England in 2003, where what should have been an ordinary night turned into a brutal and baffling crime that still raises questions decades later. In this episode, we explore the Perch Garage murders. A small, family-run petrol station. A late-night robbery that escalated into something far more sinister. When morning came, the scene told a story of violence, but not a clear one. We’ll walk through the timeline of that night, examine the evidence, and dig into the investigation that followed, including the suspects, the convictions, and the lingering doubts that continue to divide opinion. Because in this case, the most unsettling question isn’t just who did it… but whether the full truth was ever really uncovered. So grab a drink, settle in… this one might leave you questioning everything you think you know.