Episode 14: The Legend of Lizzie Borden

Episode 21: John Wayne Gacy

🎪 He made people laugh in public… while hiding unimaginable horror behind closed doors. This week on Coffee Meets Murder, we dive into the chilling case of John Wayne Gacy the man known as “The Killer Clown.” From his double life as a respected community member to the horrifying discoveries beneath his home, this episode explores how one of America’s most infamous serial killers evaded suspicion for years. What turned a seemingly ordinary man into a monster? And how did investigators finally uncover the truth?

Episode 20: Fred & Rose, Evil at Home

Behind the doors of 25 Cromwell Street lived a family hiding unimaginable horrors. Fred and Rose West appeared ordinary to neighbors, but beneath their home lay decades of torture, abuse, and murder. This week on Coffee Meets Murder, we uncover the chilling story of one of Britain’s most infamous killer couples and the secrets buried beneath their house.

Episode 19: Pain, Gain, and Murder: The sun gym gang

Miami, Florida. The 1990s. Inside a bodybuilding gym filled with ambition, steroids, and dreams of wealth, a group of men became obsessed with fast money and the luxury lifestyle they believed they deserved. Led by charismatic conman Daniel Lugo and ruthless enforcer Noel “Adrian” Doorbal, the Sun Gym Gang would spiral from fraud and extortion into kidnapping, torture, attempted murder, and dismemberment. Their victims included businessman Marc Schiller—who somehow survived being burned alive and run over—and wealthy couple Frank Griga and Krisztina Furton, whose disappearances exposed one of the most disturbing criminal cases in Miami history. This week on Coffee Meets Murder, we dive into the unbelievable true story that inspired Pain & Gain—a case so bizarre, brutal, and reckless it sounds like fiction… except it was all real.

Episode 18: The Murder of Christina Grimmie

She had a voice that inspired millions and a future that seemed limitless. But on a summer night in 2016, rising star Christina Grimmie was taken in an act of shocking violence that stunned the world. This episode of Coffee Meets Murder explores her life, her talent, and the tragedy that cut her story heartbreakingly short.

Episode 17: Marcus Wesson, The Vampire God of Fresno

On March 12, 2004, police responded to a child custody dispute at a modest house on West Hammond Avenue in Fresno, California. What they found inside would shock the nation.