We Need a Better Conversation About IVF | Nathan Guy
Click here to read the full article at RENEW.org: https://renew.org/we-need-a-better-conversation-about-ivf/ [https://renew.org/we-need-a-better-conversation-about-ivf/]
This is an audio version of a written Article from RENEW.org
* Check out other great articles on RENEW.org here: https://renew.org/articles/ [https://renew.org/articles/]
In 2005, Lewis Black was headlining the Radio and Television Correspondent’s Association Dinner, [https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4463551/user-clip-lewis-black-2005-washington-correspondents-dinner] when he decided to address the politically-oriented crowd with a bit of sardonic levity. “I’m sitting with distinguished Democrats, distinguished Republicans,” said Black, “a group of people who can’t even agree on what the facts are anymore.” It wasn’t just politicians, Black continued: “It’s difficult to figure out what the facts are now.”
Take the case of Terri Schiavo, proffered Black. The tragic case of a woman living in a persistent vegetative state involved a widely-reported dispute between Terri’s parents and her husband about whether to remove her feeding tube. The case became a political football, with arguments—and evidence—presented from widely different perspectives.
“I have never seen anything quite like [it],” bellowed Black. “One set of doctors that said, ‘Well, she’s brain dead,’ and the other set of doctors said, ‘Well, she could be dancing by Thursday.’”
The dispute was about the most fundamental question in existence. “One said she was dead and the other said she was alive,” concluded Black. “If that’s where modern medicine is at…and if that’s where facts are at, we’re in trouble.”
A recent ruling [https://law.justia.com/cases/alabama/supreme-court/2024/sc-2022-0579.html] by the Alabama Supreme Court concerning the status of IVF-created embryos in a wrongful death suit lit a firestorm of emotionally-charged rhetoric highlighting a real dispute about the most basic elements of the case. IVF is a pro-life venture, said one side of the aisle; IVF inevitably leads to murder, said the other. The positions could not be more stark.
In 2005, Lewis Black was headlining the Radio and Television Correspondent’s Association Dinner, [https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4463551/user-clip-lewis-black-2005-washington-correspondents-dinner] when he decided to address the politically-oriented crowd with a bit of sardonic levity. “I’m sitting with distinguished Democrats, distinguished Republicans,” said Black, “a group of people who can’t even agree on what the facts are anymore.” It wasn’t just politicians, Black continued: “It’s difficult to figure out what the facts are now.”
Take the case of Terri Schiavo, proffered Black. The tragic case of a woman living in a persistent vegetative state involved a widely-reported dispute between Terri’s parents and her husband about whether to remove her feeding tube. The case became a political football, with arguments—and evidence—presented from widely different perspectives.
“I have never seen anything quite like [it],” bellowed Black. “One set of doctors that said, ‘Well, she’s brain dead,’ and the other set of doctors said, ‘Well, she could be dancing by Thursday.’”
The dispute was about the most fundamental question in existence. “One said she was dead and the other said she was alive,” concluded Black. “If that’s where modern medicine is at…and if that’s where facts are at, we’re in trouble.”
A recent ruling [https://law.justia.com/cases/alabama/supreme-court/2024/sc-2022-0579.html] by the Alabama Supreme Court concerning the status of IVF-created embryos in a wrongful death suit lit a firestorm of emotionally-charged rhetoric highlighting a real dispute about the most basic elements of the case. IVF is a pro-life venture, said one side of the aisle; IVF inevitably leads to murder, said the other. The positions could not be more stark.
Listen for more...
Join RENEW.org's Newsletter: https://renew.org/resources/newsletter-sign-up/ [https://renew.org/resources/newsletter-sign-up/]
Join RENEW.org at one of our upcoming events: https://renew.org/resources/events/ [https://renew.org/resources/events/]
Get the RENEW.org App -- https://renew-app-page.bolt.host/ [https://renew-app-page.bolt.host/]
Be sure to like, subscribe and follow on social media!
You can find us on:
Instagram: @the.renew.network
Facebook: Renew.org
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@RENEWnetwork [https://www.youtube.com/@RENEWnetwork]
Twitter: @therenewnetwork
TikTok: the.renew.network
Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/RENEW [https://rumble.com/c/RENEW]
Comentarios
0Sé la primera persona en comentar
¡Regístrate ahora y únete a la comunidad de RENEW.org Daily!