Episode 4: "Live Together, Die Alone"

Episode 6: “Daddy Issues & Locked Cases”

Jack’s past catches up with him, Kate’s secrets get messy, and the case…well, it’s anything but closed. Dive into All the Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues & Whatever the Case May Be on Not Penny’s Podcast! Are you watching along with us? Just want to drop a quick hello? Email us at NotPennysShow@gmail.com! #LostRewatch #NotPennysPodcast #LostTV

Episode 5: “You’re Not Alone (Except You Totally Are)”

The Island said: “You thought this was a survival show? Think again.” This week on Not Penny’s Podcast: Golf courses, French warnings, psychic babies… and a guy who DEFINITELY wasn’t on the plane!!

Episode 4: "Live Together, Die Alone"

This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we’re diving back into the mystery with Season 1, Episodes 5 & 6. Alliances start forming, secrets begin slipping, and the island reminds everyone that survival isn’t just physical — it’s personal. We break down the biggest character moments, early clues you might’ve missed, and how these episodes quietly set the tone for everything that comes next. 👀 Rewatch along with us as the questions grow, the tension builds, and the island gets a little harder to understand. #NotPennysPodcast #LOSTRewatch #LOSTTV #TVRewatchPodcast #Podcast

Episode 3: Island of Redemption

Not Penny’s Podcast is back on the island, rewatching Lost Season 1, Episodes 3 and 4: “Tabula Rasa” and “Walkabout.” We break down Kate’s clean slate, the secrets starting to surface among the survivors, and the John Locke reveal that changed Lost forever. This is the moment the show proves it’s more than a survival story—and why it hooked us for good. 🎧 Press play and revisit where Lost truly found its footing.

Episode 2: "Guys...where are we!?"

Not Penny’s Podcast kicks off the rewatch with Lost’s iconic pilot. We break down the crash, first impressions of the survivors, early mysteries, and the moments that made us realize this show was going to be something special. 🎧 Back to the island—where it all began