Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal Explained — Fexingo History

FDR's Court Packing Plan and the Fight for the New Deal

6 min · 3. juli 2026
episode FDR's Court Packing Plan and the Fight for the New Deal cover

Description

In 1937, at the height of his political power after winning 46 of 48 states, Franklin D. Roosevelt faced a surprising obstacle: the conservative majority on the Supreme Court, which had already struck down several New Deal programs. FDR responded with a bold and controversial proposal to expand the Court by adding up to six new justices, one for each sitting justice over age 70 who refused to retire. This episode explores the political battle that followed — the fireside chat where FDR made his case, the bipartisan backlash that united Democrats and Republicans against the plan, and the infamous 'switch in time that saved nine,' where Justice Owen Roberts changed his vote to uphold New Deal legislation. We also discuss the deeper implications: did the Court fight actually weaken FDR's momentum, and what does the episode reveal about the limits of presidential power even in a crisis? #NewDeal #FDR #SupremeCourt #CourtPacking #JudicialProceduresReformBill #FiresideChat #OwenRoberts #SwitchInTimeThatSavedNine #HueyLong #CharlesEvansHughes #History #FexingoHistory #1937 #Politics #ChecksAndBalances #NewDealCoalition #SenateDebate #ConstitutionalCrisis Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

Comments

0

Be the first to comment

Sign up now and become a member of the Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal Explained — Fexingo History community!

Get Started

1 month for 9 kr.

Then 99 kr. / month · Cancel anytime.

  • Podcasts kun på Podimo
  • 20 lydbogstimer pr. måned
  • Gratis podcasts

All episodes

140 episodes

episode FDR's 'Black Thursday' and the Supreme Court Showdown of 1937 artwork

FDR's 'Black Thursday' and the Supreme Court Showdown of 1937

In this episode of Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal Explained, Lucas and Luna dive into the untold story of FDR's 1937 economic misstep known as 'Roosevelt's Recession' and the dramatic Supreme Court shift that followed. After years of New Deal recovery, FDR slashed federal spending in 1937, plunging the nation back into depression. Industrial production fell by a third, unemployment spiked, and the administration scrambled to reverse course. Lucas explains the roles of Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau Jr., the flawed 'balanced budget' ideology, and the Keynesian revolt led by Marriner Eccles. Then the conversation turns to the 'switch in time that saved nine'—Justice Owen Roberts's pivotal vote in West Coast Hotel Co. v. Parrish, which upheld a minimum wage law and signaled the Court's acceptance of the New Deal. Lucas unpacks the internal court dynamics, Justice Hughes's savvy maneuvering, and how FDR's failed court-packing plan still achieved its goal. Special attention to Justice Louis Brandeis's behind-the-scenes role. A story of hubris, recovery, and the unwritten rules of constitutional law. #RooseveltsRecession #HenryMorgenthauJr #MarrinerEccles #OwenRoberts #WestCoastHotel #CourtPacking #SupremeCourt #NewDeal #FranklinDRoosevelt #1937Recession #KeynesianEconomics #LouisBrandeis #CharlesEvansHughes #BalancedBudget #GreatDepression #History #FexingoHistory #NorthAmericanHistory Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

7. juli 20267 min
episode FDR's Federal One: The WPA's Arts Programs and American Culture artwork

FDR's Federal One: The WPA's Arts Programs and American Culture

In Episode 139, Lucas and Luna dive into Federal One, the umbrella project within the Works Progress Administration that gave birth to the Federal Art Project, Federal Writers' Project, Federal Music Project, and Federal Theatre Project. They explore how these programs put thousands of artists, writers, musicians, and actors to work during the Great Depression, creating enduring cultural legacies like the American Guide Series, the Index of American Design, and the Living Newspaper. The conversation touches on key figures like Holger Cahill, Hallie Flanagan, and Henry Alsberg, and examines controversies, including the backlash against the Federal Theatre Project for its leftist themes and the eventual defunding of the program by Congress. Lucas and Luna discuss how Federal One redefined the relationship between government and the arts, and whether its spirit lives on today. Tune in for a rich look at how the New Deal built not just roads and bridges, but a national cultural infrastructure. #FDR #NewDeal #FederalOne #WPA #FederalArtProject #FederalWritersProject #FederalMusicProject #FederalTheatreProject #HolgerCahill #HallieFlanagan #HenryAlsberg #AmericanGuideSeries #IndexofAmericanDesign #LivingNewspaper #GreatDepression #ArtandCulture #History #FexingoHistory Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

Yesterday7 min
episode FDR's Dust Bowl: The Great Plains and the New Deal Response artwork

FDR's Dust Bowl: The Great Plains and the New Deal Response

In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal response to the Dust Bowl, the worst environmental disaster in American history. They focus on the Shelterbelt Project, a massive tree-planting program initiated in 1934 to combat soil erosion and wind on the Great Plains. Learn about the vision of foresters like Raphael Zon and the practical challenges of planting 220 million trees across the Plains from Canada to Texas. The episode also covers the creation of the Soil Conservation Service under Hugh Hammond Bennett, the passage of the Soil Conservation and Domestic Allotment Act of 1936, and the controversial Resettlement Administration's efforts to buy out failing farms and relocate families, including the creation of the Woodlake project in Texas. Lucas and Luna discuss how the New Deal attempted to heal both the land and its people, the limitations of these programs, and the legacy of environmental conservation in federal policy. The conversation touches on the politics of conservation, the role of state and local resistance, and the long-term ecological changes that reshaped the Plains. #DustBowl #NewDeal #FDR #ShelterbeltProject #SoilConservationService #HughHammondBennett #RaphaelZon #GreatPlains #ResettlementAdministration #Woodlake #EnvironmentalHistory #SoilConservation #1930s #Farmers #Drought #History #FexingoHistory #NorthAmerica Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

Yesterday6 min
episode FDR's Battle with the Supreme Court and the New Deal's Survival artwork

FDR's Battle with the Supreme Court and the New Deal's Survival

In 1935, the Supreme Court struck down two cornerstone New Deal programs—the National Industrial Recovery Act and the Agricultural Adjustment Act—throwing Franklin Roosevelt's entire recovery agenda into jeopardy. In response, FDR proposed a controversial plan to 'pack' the Court with up to six additional justices. This episode walks through the key cases: Schechter Poultry v. United States, United States v. Butler, and the 'switch in time that saved nine.' We look at the political firestorm, the role of Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, and the eventual compromise that allowed New Deal legislation to survive. Along the way, we touch on the little-known story of Justice Owen Roberts's vote switch and the enduring legacy of this constitutional clash for American governance. If you've been following our New Deal series, this is the moment where the rubber met the road—a fight not just over policy, but over the very structure of American government. #FDR #SupremeCourt #NewDeal #CourtPacking #SchechterPoultry #ButlerCase #CharlesEvansHughes #OwenRoberts #USvButler #ALASchechter #ConstitutionalCrisis #1937 #JudicialReform #FexingoHistory #History #NorthAmerica #DepressionEra #FDRvsCourt Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

5. juli 20266 min
episode FDR's Rural Electrification Administration: Lighting Up the Countryside artwork

FDR's Rural Electrification Administration: Lighting Up the Countryside

In this episode of FDR and the New Deal Explained, Lucas and Luna explore the story of the Rural Electrification Administration — a New Deal program that brought electric power to millions of farm families who had been living in the dark. Before the REA, fewer than 10 percent of American farms had electricity. Private utility companies considered rural areas unprofitable and refused to extend power lines. The REA, created by executive order in 1935 and later strengthened by the Rural Electrification Act of 1936, provided low-cost loans for cooperatives to build their own power systems. Lucas tells the story of the struggle for rural electrification, from the early efforts of Morris Llewellyn Cooke, the REA's first administrator, to the grassroots organizing that led to the formation of thousands of electric cooperatives. Along the way, the episode examines the impact on rural life — how electricity transformed farm work, education, and leisure. It also touches on the political battles with private utilities like Commonwealth & Southern and the role of Senator George W. Norris, the 'father of the TVA'. This is a story of infrastructure, democracy, and the power of collective action. #RuralElectrificationAdministration #NewDeal #FDR #MorrisLlewellynCooke #GeorgeNorris #ElectricCooperatives #RuralAmerica #Electrification #Infrastructure #TennesseeValleyAuthority #CommonwealthAndSouthern #FarmLife #1930s #PublicPower #Cooperative #History #FexingoHistory #NorthAmerica Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo [https://buymeacoffee.com/fexingo]

5. juli 20267 min