The McCarthy Con Job & the Schotty Era: Can the Cowboys Finally Fix It? (2020–Present)

The McCarthy Con Job & the Schotty Era: Can the Cowboys Finally Fix It? (2020–Present)

They told you Mike McCarthy was the answer. He wasn't. In the final episode of our four-part series on 30 years of Cowboys failure, Fares and Caleb cover the most recent — and in some ways most frustrating — chapter of Dallas's Super Bowl drought. The McCarthy era promised a new era of Cowboys football and delivered the same January exits, the same excuses, and the same front office fingerprints all over the mess. Now the Cowboys are in yet another reset, handing the keys to Brian Schottenheimer and hoping the defense can be the foundation of something real. Can Schotty actually be the guy? Or is this just the next chapter in the same 30-year story? We close out the series with the full picture — and some real talk about whether this franchise is ever going to figure it out.

Eight and Eight Forever: How Jason Garrett Wasted a Decade (2011–2019)

8-8. 8-8. 8-8. If you're a Cowboys fan, those numbers should haunt your dreams. Part 3 of our series on why Dallas hasn't won a Super Bowl in 30 years covers what might be the most maddening stretch of football in franchise history. Jason Garrett — the man, the myth, the clap — somehow kept his job for nearly a decade while delivering the most perfectly mediocre football imaginable. Fares and Caleb break down how a team with Dez Bryant, Dak Prescott, Ezekiel Elliott, and a historically dominant offensive line somehow never made it out of January. The 2014 season. The DeSean Jackson non-call. The endless "this is our year" energy followed by the same result. Garrett didn't lose the Cowboys the Super Bowl. He just made sure they'd never get close enough to have a chance.

How the Cowboys Dynasty Died: Parcells Nearly Fixed It But Wade Phillips Happened (2003–2010) | GFBR

For a minute there, it actually looked like the Cowboys were back. In Part 2 of our series on 30 years of Cowboys futility, Fares and Caleb cover the two most maddening eras of the post-dynasty drought. Bill Parcells walked in and actually stabilized the franchise — brought in talent, restored some toughness, and made Dallas relevant again. And then he left. What followed was the Wade Phillips era, a.k.a. Mr. Cream Puff. Tony Romo was electric. The roster was loaded. In 2007, the Cowboys went 13-3 and looked like legitimate Super Bowl contenders. Then January happened. And it kept happening. Talented enough to get your hopes up, soft enough to break your heart — that was the Cowboys from 2007 to 2010. And Fares and Caleb are not letting it slide.

How the Cowboys Dynasty Died: The Fall & Rock Bottom (1996–2002) | Good Friends, Better Rivals

Three Super Bowls. Back-to-back-to-back dominance. And then… nothing. In Part 1 of our four-part series on why the Dallas Cowboys haven't won a Super Bowl in 30 years, Fares and Caleb go all the way back to where it started to unravel. The dynasty didn't just fade — it collapsed. Jerry Jones fired the coach who built it, the locker room fell apart, and by the time the dust settled, the Cowboys were one of the worst teams in the NFL. From the chaotic final years of Barry Switzer to the Chan Gailey and Dave Campo eras, this is the story of how a franchise that had everything lost it all — and why the decisions made in this window set the tone for the next three decades of failure. How does a dynasty turn into a disaster in under five years? We're breaking it all down.

Good Friends, Better Rivals | OBJ Is Back! + Abdul Carter Speaks Out & Cowboys OTA Updates

OBJ is home. The New York Giants made a massive splash on June 1st, signing wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr. — and they didn't stop there, also adding JuJu Smith-Schuster and Braxton Berrios all in one day. The emergency moves come in response to a wave of injuries that has hit the receiver room, with Malik Nabers (knee), Darius Slayton (sports hernia), and Gunner Olszewski (Achilles) all sidelined — and now all three veterans are signed to the veteran minimum and will be competing for roster spots through training camp. Fares and Caleb break down what each signing means for Jaxson Dart and the Giants' offense heading into 2026. Then, the drama that rocked Big Blue before the signings even happened. Abdul Carter addressed the media following OTA No. 6, speaking out about the controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart's decision to introduce President Trump at a rally — a situation that prompted Dart to open his own press conference with a prepared statement, and drew veterans like Jameis Winston to the podium as well. The guys react to everything that was said and what it means for the Giants' locker room going forward. Plus, what's going on in Dallas? The Cowboys kicked off OTAs on June 1st as they begin what they hope is a bounce-back season after back-to-back playoff misses, with George Pickens reportedly not in the building for the voluntary portion and all eyes on first-round pick Caleb Downs and the revamped defense under new coordinator Christian Parker. We've got the latest on where Dallas stands — and what they still need to figure out. All that and more on this episode of Good Friends, Better Rivals.