29. The 1904 Olympic Marathon / Mel's Hole

30. Offbeat Interview

Erin and Hailey interview hosts Ryan and Erik by asking them questions about the podcast.

29. The 1904 Olympic Marathon / Mel's Hole

Social media manager Erin discusses the crazy events of the 1904 Olympic marathon. Ryan review the funny but highly implausible story of a pit known as "Mel's Hole."

28. The Watcher House / The Boy in the Box (Revisited)

Erik explains the story of the infamous "Watcher House" that supposedly had a stalker eyeing the house. Guest star Hailey revisits her topic from Season 2, and gives an update on the newly identified "Boy in the Box."

27. Festivals / The Goldfish Challenge

Ryan reviews three funny festivals held each year in the United States. Returning guest speaker Erin discusses the odd history of swallowing goldfish.

26. Slenderman / Jack the Ripper

Ryan discusses the urban legend known as Slenderman. Erik reviews the grisly murders committed in London by the infamous Jack the Ripper.