The Fourteen Men Before George Washington

The Corpsewood Manor Murders

This week we step away from the corridors of presidential power and head into the North Georgia mountains, to a hand-built stone castle on Taylor's Ridge and one of the most misunderstood crimes in the state's history. On December 12, 1982, Dr. Charles Scudder, a brilliant former Loyola University pharmacology professor, and his partner Joseph "Joey" Odom were robbed and shot to death inside Corpsewood Manor, the off-grid medieval-style home they had built brick by brick after leaving Chicago behind. Their killers, 17-year-old Kenneth Avery Brock and 30-year-old Samuel Tony West, had convinced themselves the eccentric couple was hiding a fortune, and that two openly gay men, one of them a documented member of the atheistic Church of Satan, were the kind of victims nobody would mourn. They were wrong about the money, and history has proven them wrong about the men. This episode hits especially close to home, Brian grew up just a few miles away and was only eight years old the winter the murders happened, and who has spent a career learning to tell the difference between rumor and evidence.  We trace the whole arc, from Scudder and Odom's search for a simpler life and the truth about what the Church of Satan actually believed, through the rumors and the Satanic Panic that turned two kind hosts into the county's boogeymen, to the night of the killings, the murder of Navy Lieutenant Kirby Key Phelps during the fugitives' flight through Mississippi, the manhunt, the confessions, and a trial where a defense attorney argued in open court that a murdered man had bewitched his killer with a glowing golden harp. Brock remains incarcerated to this day; West died in prison. Listener discretion is strongly advised, as this episode contains descriptions of violence, murder, and the bigotry of the era. More than a true crime story, this is a study in how a frightened culture decides who deserves to be called a victim, and how easily fear becomes permission. Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation? Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com. Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past. Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets. Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.

The Fourteen Men Before George Washington

Everyone knows George Washington was the first President of the United States. Technically true. But it's also a sleight of hand, because fourteen men held the title of President before him, and almost no American today can name a single one. Tonight on Disturbing History, we walk through all fourteen, the men who chaired the Continental Congress and the Confederation Congress during the years the country was being fought into existence. This is not the marble version. This is slave traders and Tower of London prisoners. This is the general who walked an American army into the worst slaughter the United States ever suffered at the hands of Native warriors. This is the plot to throw George Washington out of command in the middle of the Revolution. This is the merchant who tried to invite a Prussian prince across the ocean to come be king. This is a major general accepting Washington's resignation after once helping scheme against him, then dying so broke the state had to bury him. These are the men the textbooks left out, and the reasons they got left out say almost as much about America as the founding itself.  Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation? Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com. Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past. Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets. Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.

Dwight Eisenhower: The Secret Coup Machine

Dwight Eisenhower is the president most Americans remember as the calm grandfather of the nineteen fifties. The general who beat Hitler. The man who built the interstate highways. The smile under the bald head. But underneath that famous reassurance, his administration ran something most Americans were never told about. A young intelligence agency, a brand-new doctrine called plausible deniability, and a willingness to overthrow elected governments halfway around the world if Washington decided they were a problem. This episode takes you inside two of the operations that built the template. Iran in nineteen fifty-three, where a CIA officer named Kermit Roosevelt, grandson of a president, ran an unauthorized coup with a million dollars in cash and a network of paid mobs in the streets of Tehran. And Guatemala in nineteen fifty-four, where a fake army, a fake radio station, and a real corporate giant called the United Fruit Company combined to take down a reform-minded president named Jacobo Árbenz. Both operations succeeded. Both were sold to the public as spontaneous popular uprisings. Neither was anything of the kind.You'll meet Mohammad Mosaddegh, the Iranian prime minister buried under his own dining room floor so the regime that hated him could never control his grave. You'll meet Árbenz, the soldier-reformer stripped to his underwear on the steps of the Mexican embassy and forced into seventeen years of wandering exile that ended in a bathtub in Mexico City. You'll meet the Dulles brothers, the two men running American foreign policy at the same time, one in daylight and one in shadow, both with corporate ties to the very interests they were defending overseas. And you'll see how a doctrine designed to win the Cold War quietly became something else entirely, a machine that kept running long after Eisenhower left office and is, in many ways, still running today. The disturbing part of this story isn't that Eisenhower was a monster. He wasn't.  The disturbing part is that he was exactly what he looked like. A decent, well-meaning man who signed off on operations that ended in dead bodies and broken countries, quietly, repeatedly, year after year. And the bill for those choices came due decades later, in the Iran hostage crisis, in the Guatemalan civil war that killed two hundred thousand people, in refugees at the southern border, in the long generational recognition that you cannot take a country apart in secret and expect the wreckage to stay buried. This is the hidden side of the smile on the postage stamp.  The shadow behind the grandfather. The story your high school history class skipped.  Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation? Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com. Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past. Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets. Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.

The Foo Fighters of World War Two

The story of the Foo Fighters of World War Two is one of the strangest, best-documented, and least-resolved cases in the history of military aviation. In the late autumn of nineteen forty-four, pilots of the United States Army Air Forces, flying night fighter and bomber missions over Europe, began returning to their bases with reports of glowing objects that paced their aircraft, performed seemingly impossible maneuvers, and then vanished into the dark. The reports were taken seriously by intelligence officers. They were corroborated by multiple witnesses across multiple squadrons. They reached the press in early nineteen forty-five, when Time magazine ran a feature on the phenomenon. And they continued through the end of the war, in both the European and Pacific theaters, with no satisfactory official explanation. This episode follows the story from its earliest documented appearances over the Rhine Valley, with the Four Hundred Fifteenth Night Fighter Squadron and pilots like Lieutenant Edward Schlueter, through the coining of the term foo fighter by radar observer Donald Meiers, who borrowed the word from the cult-favorite Smokey Stover comic strip by Bill Holman. From there, the episode traces the spread of the phenomenon to Pacific theater bomber crews, examines the postwar theories offered to explain it, and follows its tangled relationship to the modern UFO era, including its treatment by Project Blue Book and the Robertson Panel. The candidate explanations are examined honestly and at length. Natural atmospheric phenomena like St. Elmo's fire and ball lightning are considered and weighed against the actual content of the witness reports. Theories about Nazi secret weapons, including Renato Vesco's controversial claims about the Feuerball program, are discussed and contextualized. The psychological strain of combat aviation, including the role of Benzedrine and chronic fatigue, is given serious treatment. And the awkward, persistent residue of unexplained cases is examined for what it tells us about the limits of historical knowledge and the gaps in our collective record. The episode closes by drawing a careful, non-sensational line between the wartime foo fighter cases and the modern Unidentified Aerial Phenomena conversation, noting the similarities in witness language across more than eighty years, and the implications that has for how we treat phenomena that resist neat explanation. The men of the Four Hundred Fifteenth, and the bomber crews of the Pacific, and even the Luftwaffe pilots who reported the same kinds of objects over their own skies, deserve to have their experience taken seriously. This episode is one small contribution to that ongoing effort. For listeners following along with the Disturbing History series on presidential politics, regular programming on that subject will resume in the next episode. Tonight's installment is a deliberate detour into one of the most haunting, well-witnessed, and least-explained chapters of twentieth-century history.  Sometimes the disturbing thing isn't a man in a suit making a terrible decision. Sometimes it's a question that history hands us and then walks away from, leaving us to live with the silence. Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation? Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com. Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past. Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets. Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.

Richard Nixon: Watergate Was Only the Doorway

Most people think they know Watergate. They don't. They know the headline. The break-in, the tapes, the resignation, the wave from the helicopter on the South Lawn. They know the word. They've seen the photograph. What they don't know is that the burglary was never the story. It was the doorway.In this episode of Disturbing History, we walk back into the White House for another stop on our tour of presidential history you wish we'd forgotten. onight, we open the door at 1:30 in the morning on 6/17/1972, where a young security guard named Frank Wills pulls a piece of tape off a stairwell latch for the second time and decides it's worth a phone call. Five men in surgical gloves are arrested inside the Democratic National Committee headquarters. Across the street, two of their handlers watch through binoculars and run. The story has begun, but only by accident. Richard Nixon had already been building the machine that produced it for years.We pull the camera back from the burglars and walk you through the building behind them. A White House that wiretapped journalists without warrants after the Cambodia bombing leaked in 1969. A secret unit called the Plumbers that broke into a psychiatrist's office in Beverly Hills on 9/3/1971 to dig through the medical files of Daniel Ellsberg. A Committee to Re-Elect the President that ran a nationwide campaign of political sabotage they called, in their own words, ratfucking. A formal list of American citizens marked for harassment by the IRS, journalists and actors and senators and labor leaders whose only crime was disagreeing with the man at the desk. Hush money carried in cash. Tape machines hidden inside the walls of the Oval Office that the staff didn't know about. An 18 and a half minute gap on a tape that nobody to this day can explain.We sit with John Dean's testimony, the Sam Ervin hearings that stopped the country for a summer, Alexander Butterfield's quiet answer that revealed the recording system on 7/16/1973, the Saturday Night Massacre on 10/20/1973, the unanimous Supreme Court decision on 7/24/1974, the smoking gun tape that ended it all on 8/5/1974, and the helicopter that lifted off the South Lawn on 8/9/1974. Brian closes the episode where he started it. With the question that Watergate forces us to live with for the rest of American history. Was Nixon uniquely paranoid, or did the office itself produce a man who couldn't sit in it without breaking something.  Was the scandal the disease, or just the diagnosis. Public trust in the federal government collapsed during the Watergate years and has never returned to where it was before. That's the deeper damage. Not the resignation. The belief. This is the kind of story we built Disturbing History to tell. The headline you think you know, taken apart slowly, until you see the architecture underneath. Settle in, and walk through the doorway with us. Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation? Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com. Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past. Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets. Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.