The Defense's Last Stand (Meggan Sundwall - Ep.4)

Three Hours of Silence (Russell Faria - Ep.3)

In Part 3 of the Russ Faria case, Christie digs into Russ’s own words from a grueling 12-hour police interview — a suspicious string of gas station stops, bloody slippers, and a phone that went quiet for three hours. Russ says he was at game night. The detective says his alibi checks out — mostly. So why do they keep asking questions? Plus: what was Betsy’s good news, and why did Russ call the insurance company four days after her death? The state rests. But the questions are just getting started.

It's Always the Husband (Russell Faria - Ep.2)

Maryn and Christie break down Russ Faria's haunting 911 call, then walk through the first responders and forensic experts who took the stand — including a medic who immediately called it homicide, suspicious bloody slippers with no matching footprints, and a "paw print" that may or may not be blood. The evidence is piling up. But is it pointing at the right person?

56 Reasons It Wasn't Suicide (Russell Faria - Ep.1)

In Part 1 of the Russ Faria case, Christie introduces Missouri v. Russ Faria — a man charged with the 2011 first-degree murder of his wife Betsy, found dead in their home in what the state says was a staged suicide. The prosecution points to brutal injuries, a contested alibi, marital turmoil, terminal cancer, and a life insurance policy. The defense says the evidence tells a different story. Christie and Maryn dig into early testimony from Betsy’s family and friends — painting a picture of a marriage, a night, and a crime scene that raises more questions than answers.

The Un-Quiet Place (Meggan Sundwall - Ep.5)

In the final episode of the Meggan Sundwall case, Maryn takes the lead as the verdict comes in — and the reaction is anything but quiet. She and Christie unpack the public response, the social media debate, and the evidence that never made it to trial. Then sentencing arrives, and Meggan speaks. Five episodes in, and this case still isn’t simple. Will this case be… Hung?

The Defense's Last Stand (Meggan Sundwall - Ep.4)

In Part 4 of the Meggan Sundwall case, Christie walks us through the defense’s last stand — a forensic psychologist dissecting Kacee’s psychology and Meggan’s motivations, and a former FBI agent taking direct aim at the investigation. Followed by closing arguments. Then Christie delivers her verdict. Four episodes in, and it all comes down to this: was it murder?