Episode 76: Michelle Schroader

Episode 79: Part One Mackenzie Shirilla

Three teenagers got into a car in the early morning hours but only 1 will come out alive. The question that still gets debated… was it a tragic accident or did Mackenzie Shirilla intend to end all their lives? The stunning verdict finds her guilty on 2 counts of murder. Listen and you decide…murder or accident?

Episode 78: Hannah Pettey

Alabama chiropractor Brian Mann was attempting to murder his wife by poisoning her with lead filled “vitamin” capsules. She survived after severe illness and hospitalization. An alleged murder plot would reveal a shocking betrayal that would shock the nation!

Episode 77: Two Truths and a Lie ROUND 2

Join us as we play two truths and a lie..Small Town True Crimes style! Tabitha tells three stories from Alabama, Deleware, Hawaii, Georgia, and California. Teresa and Angie have to guess which is the lie....

Episode 76: Michelle Schroader

This story takes place in Ohio County, Kentucky. This local case is VERY local to us. This is the story of Michelle Schroader and how sometimes even after death, your accuser still haunts you.

Episode 75: Lizzie Borden

In this episode, we dive into one of America’s most infamous true crime cases: the story of Lizzie Borden. On August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered in their Fall River, Massachusetts home—struck down with a hatchet in broad daylight. Suspicion quickly turned to Andrew’s 32-year-old daughter, Lizzie. Arrested and tried in a sensational 1893 courtroom battle, Lizzie’s case captivated the nation and helped shape the modern media frenzy around true crime. Though she was ultimately acquitted, questions have lingered for more than a century. Was she a cold-blooded killer—or a woman judged by the rigid expectations of her time? Join us as we explore the evidence, the trial, and the enduring mystery that still sparks debate today.