Talking about Gender, Like Christians with Jamie Carlson

Victorian Ghosts in the Evangelical Machine with Dr. Karen Swallow Prior

Dr. J sits down with Karen Swallow Prior for an incisive conversation about the evangelical imagination. In a moment where many seem more discipled by the trappings of a subculture and internet tribalism than by wisdom, beauty, or truth, Karen argues that the crisis facing evangelicalism is not merely theological or political, but imaginative. Drawing from history, literature, theology, and cultural criticism, Justin and Karen explore the powerful but often invisible forces that shape how evangelicals engage the world. From Victorian moralism and sentimentalism to modern consumerism and culture war reflexes, they unpack the “social imaginary” that forms contemporary faith long before believers ever articulate doctrine.  As Karen points out, our water is imbued with the Victorian era. In other words, many have inherited a cultural mood they mistake for Christianity itself. The conversation makes a case for recovering art, literature, beauty, and moral imagination as essential components of formation. Along the way, they wrestle with evangelicalism’s credibility crisis, the fallout of deconstruction, generational disillusionment, shallow conversion practices, and the difficulty of cultivating discipleship in an age increasingly allergic to nuance. The episode also explores the unique role stories play in shaping culture and belief. Rather than offering simplistic nostalgia or culture-war panic, Justin and Karen cast a hopeful vision for faithful presence in a pluralistic world. The task, they argue, is not merely to condemn culture nor mindlessly reproduce it, but to help cultivate healthier cultural ecosystems rooted in wisdom, humility, creativity, and love of neighbor.  LINKS: * Substack: @karenswallowprior [https://substack.com/@karenswallowprior] * Website: karenswallowprior.com [https://karenswallowprior.com/] * Book(s):The Evangelical Imagination: How Stories, Images, and Metaphors Created a Culture in Crisis [https://www.amazon.com/Evangelical-Imagination-Stories-Metaphors-Created/dp/1587435756] || other books [https://karenswallowprior.com/books/] & articles [https://karenswallowprior.com/articles/] * The Trinity Forum [https://ttf.org/] * Modern Social Imaginaries [https://www.amazon.com/Modern-Social-Imaginaries-Public-Planet/dp/0822332930/ref=sr_1_1?adgrpid=1330409632589600&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.07AHPYiHpdRaMCup-t6OZLCzDzg9cN256XHcTolkKltdV781aEdJw5-u9TeEvwzm9vZZ_bcbdtuEgoFyoE-homO0hif19Vr92YDyQMopHoC-zbH_FmL9lXHiDFEm7rU3REu9PGCzm6I-HTK1CpILfw.6EsOpY4qES_9Jg4j8Mh2ysnD09GOgQpYo5eID8rve7w&dib_tag=se&hvadid=83150841259058&hvbmt=be&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=104436&hvnetw=o&hvqmt=e&hvtargid=kwd-83151797258737%3Aloc-190&hydadcr=20615_13322642&keywords=charles+taylor+social+imaginary&mcid=0799887f058c375aa993a7b340361588&msclkid=2fa8dcfb05231dc1a6beb6f45928a330&qid=1779391510&sr=8-1] by Charles Taylor

Talking about Gender, Like Christians with Jamie Carlson

Dr. J chats with seminarian and writer Jamie Carlson for a candid and humanized conversation about the state of evangelical gender discourse—and why so much of it feels simultaneously overheated and unserious. In a cultural moment shaped by tribalism, suspicion, and outrage, Jamie argues that many Christian conversations about gender have become less about seeking truth together and more about protecting camps and caricatures. The result is a discourse that often forgets the humanity of the people involved. Rather than reducing the conversation to slogans or talking points, Justin and Jamie explore what it might look like to recover genuinely Christian dialogue marked by humility, charity, patience, and love in truth. Along the way, they wrestle with the emotional and spiritual cost of divisive church culture, the ways mistrust corrodes Christian community, and why so many believers feel exhausted by debates that seem designed more to win than to understand. As Jamie bluntly puts it, “Mistrust is the opposite of love.” Amen.  The episode also moves beyond abstract theology into lived experience—examining how institutional failures, personal wounds, church dynamics, and differing Christian traditions shape the way people approach questions surrounding gender, leadership, and authority. Rather than pretending these conversations are easy, the case is made for faithful dialogue without abandoning conviction or complexity. Goodwill, they argue, is not compromise. It is discipleship. Can Christians disagree meaningfully without dehumanizing one another? Can theological conviction coexist with gentleness, curiosity, and honest self-examination? And what might happen if believers became known less for outrage and more for wisdom, compassion, and spiritual maturity? For listeners weary of endlessly polarized debates, this episode offers something increasingly rare: a serious conversation about difficult issues that refuses to sacrifice either truth or love. LINKS: * Article: Why Evangelical Discourse is Unserious via Mere Orthodoxy [https://mereorthodoxy.com/why-evangelical-gender-discourse-is-unserious], on Substack [https://mereorthodoxy.substack.com/p/why-evangelical-gender-discourse]  * Substack: https://jamiecarlson.substack.com/ [https://jamiecarlson.substack.com/] * Kierkegaard, Works of Love [https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Works+of+Love+by+Soren+Kierkegaard] * The Nicene Creed [https://www.britannica.com/topic/Nicene-Creed] * The Apostles' Creed [https://www.britannica.com/topic/Apostles-Creed] * Henri Nouwen on Silence [https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Hesychia+by+Henri+Nouwen]

Good Christians, Bad Art with Nicholas McDonald

Justin talks with author and cultural sage Nicholas McDonald for a theologically rich and aesthetically grounded conversation about what it looks like to create—and engage—art that tells the truth. Rather than treating art as a delivery system for simplistic messages, Nicholas resists the impulse to reduce creativity to propaganda. From the failures of Christian film to what he provocatively calls “Godsploitation,” the conversation explores how much of what passes for “Christian art” trades honesty for certainty. The result? Stories are thin, forced, and disconnected from the texture of real life.  Viewing art not as explanation but as revelation, the conversation draws on Scripture, theology, and examples (such as The Tree of Life [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tree_of_Life_(film)]) to explore how good art embraces ambiguity, beauty, and even discomfort—not to confuse, but to illuminate. Because if the biblical story is complex, embodied, and often mysterious, why wouldn’t faithful art be the same? Along the way, they tackle the danger of “anti-creational” theology that downplays the physical world. They also make the case that engaging so-called “secular” art isn’t a compromise—it’s often where truth breaks through in unexpected ways. At the center of it all is a distinctly Christian claim: creation matters. The incarnation matters. And because God meets us in the material, messy reality, art that is honest about how that reality can become a site of encounter—convicting, clarifying, and even drawing us to worship or repentance. For anyone tired of clichés, suspicious of easy answers, or longing for a faith that can withstand the full weight of reality, this episode offers both a critique and an invitation: recover a vision of art that is as truthful, complex, and beautiful as the Gospel itself. LINKS: * Book: The Light in Our Eyes: Rediscovering the Love, Beauty, and Freedom of Jesus in an Age of Disillusionment [https://www.amazon.com/Light-Our-Eyes-Rediscovering-Disillusionment/dp/0593601521] by Nicholas McDonald * Nicholas McDonald on Substack: @TheBardOwl [https://substack.com/@thebardowl] * The Music of Nathan Partain [https://music.youtube.com/channel/UC-XQaHgVDbVZrgGdHfob2Hg]; new album, Phroneo [https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_mKBWa8etOQy64t9cwMLnRKxeYIRs1TPQg]

Won’t You Be a Neighbor? With Pastor Tony Pyle

Justin sits down with his co-pastor (and relational strategist) Tony Pyle for a conversation that is deeply theological and disarmingly practical: what does it actually mean to be a neighbor in an age of distraction and relational drift? Rather than treating “neighbor” as a noun or static label, Tony reframes it as a verb—something lived out. Drawing from data, best practices, and the Parable of the Good Samaritan, the conversation presses into a simple but uncomfortable question: are we just living near people, or are we truly loving them? Think less grand gestures, more faithful consistency. The episode moves from conviction to real life, offering a range of grounded, doable practices—learning names, hosting low-stakes gatherings, borrowing tools (and yes, even dealing with mole problems)—that push back against the isolation baked into modern life. The conversation explores how neighboring requires more than proximity; it demands presence, intentionality, and a willingness to “go first” in vulnerability, even when it’s awkward or inefficient. Along the way, Justin and Tony take on the irony of our moment: we’ve never been more connected, yet loneliness continues to spike.  They discuss how neighboring habits don’t just fulfill biblical commands—they actively combat anxiety, fragmentation, and the slow erosion of community life. Neighboring isn’t just a nice add-on for extroverts; it’s central to what it means to follow Jesus. And while the vision is big—renewed communities, deeper trust, resilient local networks—the invitation is refreshingly small: start with a name, a conversation, a moment of presence. For anyone who suspects that something essential has been lost in the way we relate to the people right outside our doors, this episode offers both a challenge and a way forward: build community, one relationship at a time. LINKS: * Book: The Art of Neighborhing [https://www.amazon.com/Art-Neighboring-Building-Genuine-Relationships/dp/080101459X/ref=sr_1_1?adgrpid=1338106223687335&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.XO67Xshu5vB6ZCMy7bVYrXM3m_mH7WxMEiDVF63A1pJ47pkqwJCrWAOT67lmYOM614Qc_SVKIlaFYVdoigenRoXIoKQu0JeKVdaO_ddRJHbwga3vsBa9ox6cZzYo20YR-58wCQ4IFNk_UQmYqAfv5uFOQaQk-eUlEeMoVpSMS0_uPUrVX1DuwEMwXll-CZ7zGXucFVl9_FqMFMwNtMh6Lp2zp2Ee13Q4Ynyo_FNF16U.EgJmyUy_QCM4FkIhyOOc3O4BtpZCmHj-d9KTuu-Ryts&dib_tag=se&hvadid=83632044627733&hvbmt=be&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=104724&hvnetw=o&hvqmt=e&hvtargid=kwd-83632002651805%3Aloc-190&hydadcr=22563_13531013&keywords=the+art+of+neighboring&mcid=91cb2ef57556395c9ca3285a90c689ad&msclkid=8f357f7a40e9194217c916bff5e36f7a&qid=1774564623&sr=8-1] by Pathak & Runyon * Paul in Athens [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Acts%2017%3A16-34&version=CSB] * The Parable of the Good Samaritan [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke%2010%3A25-42&version=CSB]

Digital Mission in the Brave New World of Web3

Justin chops it up with entrepreneur and technologist John Knox about faith, technology, and the rapidly changing digital frontier. From AI to blockchain to the emerging world of Web3, the discussion explores what it might mean for Christians to cultivate a faithful presence in spaces that shape how information is disseminated, how authority is distributed, and how influence flows. Rather than treating new technology as either a savior or a threat, Knox invites listeners to think with careful and holy optimism about the moral and spiritual opportunities embedded in our tools. The conversation examines the promise and complexity of decentralization, the rise of online communities, and the generational shifts shaping how people encounter both faith and information. Along the way, they wrestle with a central question: if technology is reorganizing public life, what role do Christians have in responsibly shaping it? Knox argues that the tech sector should not be ceded to purely commercial or ideological interests. Instead, Christians working in technology—and those simply navigating it—have an opportunity to engage these spaces with imagination, ethical clarity, and a sense of mission. From practical steps for “digital missionaries” to broader reflections on how faith and vocation intersect in the modern economy, the episode offers a hopeful but clear-eyed look at the possibilities before us. For anyone curious about the forces shaping our (digital) lives, this conversation offers a thoughtful invitation: don’t just consume or avoid technology—help shape it. ~LINKS~ * Christians in Web 3 (CW3) [https://www.cw3.global/] * FaithTech.com [http://faithtech.com/] * Podcast: What Would Jesus Tech [https://www.whatwouldjesustech.com/] * Book: Debugging Discipleship: Flowing the Church out as Liquid to Bear Fruit that Lasts [https://www.amazon.com/Debugging-Discipleship-Flowing-Church-Liquid/dp/1738744957/ref=sr_1_1?adgrpid=1339207633606808&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.JFlfbltxO72EYV-mj8nDotZHm8Xd2qGokB7O69e5z_M.yGFFkZOdydFoP5r0N7mbbkE85Yria6eLtYfFE8xQw00&dib_tag=se&hvadid=83700752957276&hvbmt=bp&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=104289&hvnetw=o&hvqmt=p&hvtargid=kwd-83701598443041%3Aloc-190&hydadcr=1027_1015248620&keywords=debugging+discipleship&mcid=58bad412af1e34da8975ebd3219a5c9a&msclkid=da5383d9a8a9144b404aea6b5e38c22f&qid=1773336212&sr=8-1] by Joanna Ng * Book: Generations: The Real Differences Between Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Boomers, and Silents―and What They Mean for America's Future by [https://www.amazon.com/Generations-Differences-Millennials-Silents_and-Americas/dp/1982181613] Dr. Jean Twenge * John’s Firm: MedranoPartners.com [http://medranopartners.com]