The Burger Chef Murders: They Cleaned the Crime Scene Before Finding the Victims

The Jamison Family Mystery: $32,000 Left Behind

On October 8th, 2009, the Jamison family—Bobby, Sherilynn, and their six-year-old daughter Madyson—drove into a remote area of Oklahoma. They never came back. Days later, their truck was found abandoned. Inside, investigators discovered something that made the case even more unsettling. Their phones were still there. Their wallets were still there. Their dog was still alive. And $32,000 in cash… was left behind. The last known footage of the family shows them outside their home, moving slowly… back and forth… loading and unloading their truck for nearly an hour. Not speaking. Not rushing. Just… moving. As if something wasn’t right. Years later, their remains were found not far from where the truck had been. Which raises a question that still hasn’t been answered: Why would a family leave everything behind… and walk into the woods? In this episode of The Pine Grove Briar, we examine the Jamison Family Mystery—a case filled with contradictions, unanswered questions, and a quiet sense that something was wrong long before they disappeared. 💰 Support the show If you enjoy what I’m building and want to help keep it going, you can support directly here: 👉 paypal.me/chrissewell623 [http://paypal.me/chrissewell623] 🛒 Support the show and our sponsors: QuikCamo – 3D Leafy Camo Suits, Hats & Gloves 💰 25% OFF with code PGBPROMO 👉 https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Bear Knuckles – Premium Leather Work Gloves 💰 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO 👉 https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Old Glory – Music, Sports & Pop Culture Merch 💰 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO 👉 https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO] If this episode stayed with you, follow the show and leave a review—it helps more people discover The Pine Grove Briar.

The Setagaya Family Murders: The Night He Stayed

On the night of December 30th, 2000, in Setagaya, Tokyo, a family of four was murdered inside their home. What followed is one of the most baffling and unsettling investigations in modern criminal history. Because the killer didn’t flee. He stayed. For hours, he moved through the Miyazawa home—eating food from the kitchen, using the bathroom, accessing the family computer, and even tending to his own injuries. He left behind fingerprints. DNA. Clothing. A bag containing sand traced to the Mojave Desert in the United States. Investigators later determined his genetic profile may have included ancestry linked to regions near the Adriatic Sea. The weapon used in the attack broke during the struggle, forcing him to retrieve another knife from inside the home. By the time he finally left… He had left behind everything— except his identity. More than two decades later, the case remains unsolved. Each year, investigators publicly apologize for the lack of answers. Each year, a reward of 2 million yen is offered for information. And still… No one has been identified. In this episode of The Pine Grove Briar, we examine the Setagaya Family Murders—sometimes referred to as the “Goldilocks Murders”—a case defined not only by violence, but by what came after. 🛒 Support the show and our sponsors: QuikCamo – 3D Leafy Camo Suits, Hats & Gloves 25% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Bear Knuckles – Premium Leather Work Gloves 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Old Glory – Music, Sports & Pop Culture Merch 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO] If this episode stayed with you, follow the show and leave a review—it helps more people discover The Pine Grove Briar.

Frank Hughett: Shot, Poisoned, and Hunted in Scott County

There are some stories that feel like they were always going to end one way. This is one of them. In 1910, in the mountains of Scott County, Tennessee, former sheriff Frank Hughett became a marked man. What started as law enforcement quickly turned into something more personal—something that wouldn’t be settled in a courtroom. He was shot in broad daylight. He survived. Days later, his whiskey was poisoned. He survived that too. Most men would have left. He didn’t. Frank Hughett stayed in the same mountains, around the same people, fully aware that whatever had started… wasn’t over. And on a quiet Sunday morning, while sweeping the steps of a railroad commissary, it finally caught up with him. But even that isn’t where this story ends. Twenty years later, his son—following in his footsteps as a lawman—would meet a strikingly similar fate. In this episode of The Pine Grove Briar, we explore a story of duty, retaliation, and the kind of consequences that don’t fade with time… they echo. 🎧 The Pine Grove Briar is a single-host podcast telling true stories that feel like they’ve been sitting in the mountains… waiting to be heard. 🛒 Support the show and our sponsors: QuikCamo – 3D Leafy Camo Suits, Hats & Gloves 25% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Bear Knuckles – Premium Leather Work Gloves 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Old Glory – Music, Sports & Pop Culture Merch 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO] 📍 This episode is based on historical research compiled by Ben Garrett, editor of The Independent Herald and author of Murders in the Heartland. Additional thanks to Bob Strunk and Stephen West for pointing us toward this story. If this episode stayed with you, follow the show and leave a review—it helps more people discover The Pine Grove Briar.

The Burger Chef Murders: They Cleaned the Crime Scene Before Finding the Victims

On November 17th, 1978, four young employees reported for their shift at a Burger Chef in Speedway, Indiana. They never made it home. At first, it looked like a simple robbery—an open cash register, missing money, and no immediate signs of violence. But what investigators did next would become one of the most controversial decisions in true crime history. Before it was even clear that anything more serious had occurred… The crime scene was cleaned. Three days later, the bodies of all four teenagers were discovered in a wooded area miles away. Nearly half a century later, the case remains unsolved. In this episode of The Pine Grove Briar, we take a deep dive into the Burger Chef murders—reconstructing the timeline, examining the investigation, and exploring the theories that continue to haunt this case. Was it a robbery gone wrong? Was one of the victims targeted? Or did critical mistakes in the earliest hours cost investigators their only chance at solving it? This is a story about more than what happened that night. It’s about what may have been lost… before anyone realized it mattered. 🎧 The Pine Grove Briar is a single-host true crime podcast exploring the cases that stay with you—the ones that don’t sit right, and the ones that refuse to be forgotten. 🛒 Support the show and our sponsors: QuikCamo – 3D Leafy Camo Suits, Hats & Gloves Get 25% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Bear Knuckles – Premium Leather Work Gloves Get 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO] Old Glory – Music, Sports & Pop Culture Merch Get 15% OFF with code PGBPROMO https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO] If this episode stayed with you, consider following the show and leaving a review—it helps more people discover The Pine Grove Briar.

The Brian Shaffer Disappearance (2006) | The Man Who Walked In and Was Never Seen Again

In April of 2006, Brian Shaffer, a 27-year-old Ohio State medical student, went out for a night in Columbus, Ohio. What should have been an ordinary evening would become one of the most baffling disappearances in modern true crime. Security cameras clearly captured Brian entering a crowded building late that night. Friends, staff, and dozens of patrons moved in and out of the area throughout the evening. But Brian Shaffer was never seen leaving. Despite extensive police investigations, searches, and years of speculation, no trace of Brian has ever been found. No confirmed sightings. No body. No clear explanation. How can someone enter a busy public place… and seemingly vanish without a trace? In this episode of The Pine Grove Briar, we examine the timeline of that night, the surveillance footage investigators analyzed, the strange details that still trouble detectives, and the theories that continue to surround one of the most haunting unsolved mysteries in recent memory. More than eighteen years later, one question still lingers: What really happened to Brian Shaffer? Sponsors 🛒 QuikCamo – 3D Leafy Camo Suits, Hat/Masks & Gloves 💰 Get 25% OFF | Promo Code: PGBPROMO https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://quikcamo.com/discount/PGBPROMO] 🛒 Bear Knuckles – Best Leather Gloves Ever Made 💰 Get 15% OFF | Promo Code: PGBPROMO https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://buybearknuckles.com/discount/PGBPROMO] 🛒 Old Glory – Iconic Music and Sports Fan Merch 💰 Get 15% OFF | Promo Code: PGBPROMO https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO [https://oldglory.com/discount/PGBPROMO] I earn a commission when you use my links or promo codes, so if you purchase something, you’re helping support me and the show. Support the Show If you enjoy stories like this and want to help keep The Pine Grove Briar growing, you can support the show here: 👉 paypal.me/chrissewell623 [http://paypal.me/chrissewell623] Every contribution helps support research, production, and bringing more of these stories forward.