The Professor's Bayonet
It is likely that author Marissa McFarland was thinking of the stereotype Italians enjoy when it comes to parting ways. Her novel, When Goodbyes Begin, tells the story of Anna, the daughter of Italian immigrants who spends the first thirty years of her life doing her best to please her oftentimes overbearing parents, Maria and Tony. After taking more control over the reins of her life by quitting her nursing job at a hospital and following her dream of becoming a party planner, Anna’s life seems to look up. She even finds a romantic interest – a man who happens to be half Italian, a huge plus for her parents. The upward momentum is halted, however, when her father, Tony, begins to become forgetful. He misplaces things. He has trouble maintaining the books at the family construction business. In short order, Tony is diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, which is when Anna – indeed, the entire close-knit family – experiences the unraveling of all that had once afforded order and certainty. Anybody unfortunate enough to watch a loved one experience Alzheimer’s understands that the farewell process is cruelly prolonged. Italian families are known for long goodbyes. There is rarely a quick hug, a wave, and an escort to the door. They are loud and loving, and anybody engaged in them knows that it is a process. How fitting, then, that McFarland would couch the story of the family patriarch gradually losing his cognitive abilities in this affair. Tony is saying goodbye. The family is learning how to do the same. And while it may not be loud – to be sure, quite the opposite – it is nevertheless loving. McFarland pursues other threads in her book – other romantic tangles, the rearing up of things past – but it is Tony’s diagnosis that holds together the plot. One might even argue, dear listeners, that When Goodbyes Begin is also about how many struggle with balancing the Old World with its culture and social expectations with the New World and the values it upholds. In effect, this is an immigrant story where Anna, despite her efforts to secede from her strong-willed parents, actually embraces the very values that prompted her to try to break away to begin with. Anna is her own person, but she is also very much the daughter of Tony and Maria. They came to America to start a new life, presumably splitting with their parents and kin, and Anna is doing the very same thing. We might call this ironic. Or we might call this typical. The apple really does not fall far from the tree. How might we further interpret Tony’s Alzheimer’s disease? Is his forgetting also the erasure of a family history of rebellion – striking it out on your own? How does this reframe Anna’s own rebellion? Does it even become predictable? When Goodbyes Begin is a study in cultural baggage – yes – but it is also a study in human psychology. What had seemed to be a break with tradition was actually a perpetuation of it. Readers might even be inspired to reflect on they themselves lashed out, tried something different, attempted to go their own way only to learn that this had always been the masterplan. As one gets older, this truth becomes clearer. Perhaps had the disease not afflicted Tony, this same truth would have emerged from the depths of a lifetime of observation and been gifted to Anna as a token of peace. This could very well be the biggest tragedy in the book. With time comes great understanding, but when that time is truncated – when it is shortened – then the understanding we seek may not be found. We simply pass the ball to our children and hope that they get farther along than we did.
122 episodios
Comentarios
0Sé la primera persona en comentar
¡Regístrate ahora y únete a la comunidad de The Professor's Bayonet!