While I've Got You
Here are the SEO-optimized show notes for this episode: Every time a creator fumbles on a red carpet, the comments fill up with the same voice — journalists and media traditionalists reminding everyone why trained professionals should be the ones getting hired for these moments. And on the surface, it's hard to argue with. Traditional journalism is a real craft. It requires preparation, accountability, and the willingness to ask the uncomfortable question without needing the guest to like you after. But in this episode of While I've Got You, Gabby Turner sits with both sides of the journalist versus creator debate and starts pulling on a thread that changes the whole conversation. Because creators are clearly offering something too. When guests have editorial control — when they know that if something doesn't feel right it gets cut, no questions asked — they show up differently. More human, more unfiltered, more vulnerable in ways that audiences are responding to. The creator brings connection where journalism brings clarity, and depending on what you're looking for, that distinction matters. What really shifts the conversation is the third example Gabby brings up. Not a creator fumbling on a carpet — a credentialed Associated Press journalist interrupting BabyFace mid-sentence to call out for Chappell Roan. She had the training. She had the credentials. And in that moment, she didn't do the job she was hired to do. Which raises the question this episode keeps coming back to: if traditional journalism training were the guarantee, how does that moment happen? And if it's not actually about training — what is it about? Gabby also gets into who is getting the institutional co-sign in this industry and who is absorbing the consequences when things go wrong. Hannah Berner and Jake Shane were both hired to host Vanity Fair's Oscar after-party coverage. Drew Afualo — a creator who has never had a moment like the ones being used as ammunition in this debate — has never been given that room. And when Jake Shane's miss with Julia Fox dominated the conversation, his co-host Quenlin Blackwell, a Black creator who did her job, watched her entire moment get swallowed by someone else's fumble. This episode doesn't resolve the debate. It asks whether the debate is even about what we think it's about. The real question might not be training versus no training. It might be competency — and those are not the same thing. While I've Got You is a short-form podcast about culture, identity, and the moments worth noticing, hosted by Gabby Turner. New episodes monthly.
5 episodios
Comentarios
0Sé la primera persona en comentar
¡Regístrate ahora y únete a la comunidad de While I've Got You!