Episode 15: The Journal, The Bonfire, The Truth — Scarlett Bentley Unfiltered

41 min · 23. apr. 2026

Description

Scarlett Bentley from Temptation Island Season 2 sits down with us for her first full tell-all. We cover her whole story — from growing up in Arkansas to Below Deck Sailing Yacht to meeting Cole, and everything that went down on the island that viewers didn't get to see. Things we cover: • How Scarlett and Cole actually met (and the state of the relationship before the show) • The small lies that became the big problem • Whose idea it really was to go on Temptation Island • Whether she was already done with Cole before she got there • Her connection with Bradley Bobbit and what the edit left out • The journal moment Cole admitted to at the final bonfire (her first reaction is a lot) • What "enough" would have actually looked like at the bonfire • Why only 1.5% of the three weeks they filmed actually aired • Responding to the online hate, the "she's just chasing clout" theories, and the "she used him" accusations • Where she and Cole actually stand today • The reunion (what to expect without spoilers) • Judge & Jury: Scarlett joins us on the bench for listener dilemmas that hit WAY too close to home Submit your dilemma: legallyfriendspodcast@gmail.com Follow us: @scarlettbentley @meglskalla @amyskalla

Comments

Be the first to comment

Get Started

All episodes

23 episodes

Episode 23: The 2021 DM Is Entered Into Evidence

Court is in session for Episode 23, and this one has everything: Amy’s horse-girl era, barrel camp with 12-year-olds, Zach’s home renovation and septic drama, Yellowstone with kids, Taylor Swift debates, and one very important Instagram message request from 2021. Amy finds an old DM from a guy she now wants to go out with and sends a reply live on the podcast. Then we get into true crime rabbit holes, what’s chapping everyone’s ass, and two Judge & Jury write-ins involving a sabotaging stepmother-in-law and a sister-in-law who crossed a brutal line after a baby. If you have ever overthought a DM, dealt with in-law drama, or needed a reminder that apologies are not optional, this episode is for you. Follow Legally Friends wherever you listen, watch the full episode on YouTube, and send your Judge & Jury stories to @legallyfriendspodcast or zach@legallyfriends.com

14. juni 20261 h 34 min

Episode 22: The Thoughts You’re Not Supposed To Say Out Loud

Everyone has thoughts they're not supposed to say out loud. This week Amy and Zach discuss dating, intrusive thoughts, social situations, family dynamics, and the things we secretly judge people for. Some of these opinions probably should have stayed private, but that's never stopped us before.

7. juni 20261 h 17 min

Episode 21: [Unfiltered] The Most Unhinged Legally Friends Episode Yet

Amy bought a horse and returned it a week later. In this episode, Amy shares the emotional story behind sending Brazil back, while Zach tries to make sense of the horse world. Then Amy reveals what happened after being put under anesthesia—including the phone calls, the tears, and the comments that Shannon will never let her forget. We also discuss: • Amy's dating update • Her Instagram account being deleted • Zach's move to Dallas • Closing on a new house • Parenting during big life transitions • Migraines and health struggles This one goes completely off the rails in the best way possible. Follow, rate, and review if you're enjoying Legally Friends—it helps us more than you know.

31. maj 20261 h 22 min

Episode 20: [Unfiltered] Amy Bought a Horse, Zach Graduated, and Family Chaos Took Over

Amy and Zach are back with a full chaos recap of Zach’s graduation weekend in Charlottesville. They talk family sleepover madness, Dean and Weston stealing the show at graduation, Amy’s Chanel flip flop injury, Black Cow dinner drama, fishing in designer shoes, and Zach feeling sentimental about leaving Darden. Amy also reveals that she bought a horse, which leads to horse name debates, barn drama, chickens, ticks, dating red flags, Snap Score stalking, phone snooping, and two new Judge & Jury submissions. Should Amy name her horse Ace? Should Zach and Megan get chickens? And who is right when someone cancels on a destination wedding three weeks out because their dog is sick?

24. maj 20261 h 21 min

Episode 19: A Celebrity Dream Expert Interpreted Our Dreams and It Got Personal

What do your dreams actually mean? This week on Legally Friends, Zach, Amy, and Emily sit down with world-renowned dream expert Lauri Loewenberg to decode the dreams they cannot stop having. Lauri has spent nearly three decades analyzing dreams and has appeared on The Today Show, Good Morning America, The View, Dr. Oz, CNN, Steve Harvey, and more. She explains why dreams are not random, what recurring dreams are trying to tell us, and how your subconscious may be trying to help you work through real life. The group gets into Emily’s recurring gum dream, Amy’s emotional dream about her Papa, a possible pregnancy prediction dream, Zach’s basketball dream where he has no pants, and what it means when you dream about exes, cheating, teeth falling out, being chased, and falling. Follow Lauri: Website: https://www.lauriloewenberg.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lauri_thedreamexpert App: Dream Chat with Lauri [https://apps.apple.com/us/app/dream-chat-with-lauri/id6753867341 Dream Chat With Lauri], available in the App Store and Google Play Follow Legally Friends on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/legallyfriendspodcast

17. maj 20261 h 21 min

Episode 15: The Journal, The Bonfire, The Truth — Scarlett Bentley Unfiltered

Description

Comments

1 month for 9 kr.

All episodes