The Balance, by Dr. Catlin Tucker

Guided Notes vs. Cloze Notes: Are Your Notes Supporting or Stifling Learning?

29 min · 26. maj 2026
episode Guided Notes vs. Cloze Notes: Are Your Notes Supporting or Stifling Learning? cover

Description

In this episode of The Balance, I unpack a classroom trend I’ve been noticing across middle and high school classrooms: teachers using what they call “guided notes” that are actually closer to cloze notes. I explore the difference between guided notes, cloze notes, and completed notes, and why those distinctions matter for cognitive engagement, meaning-making, and long-term learning. I talk about how note-taking scaffolds can support students without reducing learning to task completion and compliance. I also address questions teachers are asking about fairness, accommodations, inclusion, and how to normalize differentiated supports in diverse classrooms. Finally, I share practical strategies for designing guided notes that actively engage students in thinking, processing, discussing, and making meaning during direct instruction. Related Blog: Are Your Guided Notes Supporting or Stifling Learning? Designing Notes That Promote Active Engagement [https://catlintucker.com/2026/05/guided-notes-supporting-or-stifling-learning/]

Comments

0

Be the first to comment

Sign up now and become a member of the The Balance, by Dr. Catlin Tucker community!

Get Started

1 month for 9 kr.

Then 99 kr. / month · Cancel anytime.

  • Podcasts kun på Podimo
  • 20 lydbogstimer pr. måned
  • Gratis podcasts

All episodes

161 episodes

episode Deep Dive - UDL and Station Rotation in Early Elementary: Strategies for Building Independence artwork

Deep Dive - UDL and Station Rotation in Early Elementary: Strategies for Building Independence

Can kindergarten, first grade, and second grade students really thrive in student-centered learning environments? In this episode, I explore how Universal Design for Learning (UDL) and the Station Rotation model can help teachers proactively design learning experiences that support learner variability while building growing independence. You'll learn six practical strategies for teaching routines, designing classroom environments that reduce barriers, providing meaningful choices, scaffolding new learning experiences, and helping young learners develop the confidence and skills to take increasing ownership of their learning. If you've ever wondered whether your students are "ready" for Station Rotation or UDL, this episode will challenge that assumption and provide concrete ideas you can put into practice right away. Episode Resource * Check out The Station Rotation Model & UDL [https://www.amazon.com/Station-Rotation-Model-UDL-Instruction/dp/194833481X/ref=zg_bsnr_g_10646_d_sccl_2/145-5144220-6993110?psc=1]

14. juli 202625 min
episode Ask Catlin - Can Students Really Handle Station Rotation? artwork

Ask Catlin - Can Students Really Handle Station Rotation?

Ask Catlin is back! In response to the thoughtful questions I've been getting through my website and on social media, I'm bringing back this monthly Q&A series to tackle real classroom challenges with practical strategies you can use right away. In this episode, I answer three of the most common questions I get about the Station Rotation Model: * How do you give directions without spending valuable class time explaining every station? * What should students actually be doing at the online and offline stations? * How do you manage classroom behavior and keep students engaged while you're working with a small group? Whether you're just getting started with station rotation or looking to refine your approach, you'll walk away with strategies for building student independence, designing meaningful learning experiences at every station, and creating classroom routines that set students up for success. Have a question you'd like me to answer in a future Ask Catlin episode? Submit it through my website [https://catlintucker.com/contact/] or connect with me on social media. If you're wondering about it, chances are other educators are too! Related Resource: * [Resource] The Process for Co-Creating Class Agreements [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HwF-5Vyeo-QfAxTBwqE1GB3GAJutd0PH5Nh_Ye8CYYY/edit?tab=t.0]

7. juli 202634 min
episode Beyond Coverage: Designing Learning for Understanding & Transfer with Jay McTighe artwork

Beyond Coverage: Designing Learning for Understanding & Transfer with Jay McTighe

In this episode, I chat with Jay McTighe about Stage 3 of Understanding by Design and what it really means to create learning experiences that move beyond content coverage toward understanding and transfer. We unpack the different types of learning goals related to acquisition, understanding, and transfer, and explore how those goals should shape both the teacher’s role and the student experience in the classroom. Our conversation also examines the ongoing pressure schools feel to “cover” large volumes of content in preparation for standardized exams, and why that mindset can work against deeper learning. Jay shares practical insights into formative assessment, feedback, and the use of authentic performance tasks as opportunities for learning, not simply evaluation. We also discuss how AI can support both teachers and students in designing richer learning experiences, clarifying goals, and creating more responsive pathways. Check out Jay’s Work * https://jaymctighe.com/ [https://jaymctighe.com/] * https://www.linkedin.com/in/jaymctighe [https://www.linkedin.com/in/jaymctighe] * Teaching for Deeper Learning [https://www.ascd.org/books/teaching-for-deeper-learning?variant=120022] Related Resources * 8 Quick Checks for Understanding [https://www.edutopia.org/article/8-quick-checks-understanding/] * How to Provide Better Feedback Through Rubrics [https://www.ascd.org/el/articles/how-to-provide-better-feedback-through-rubrics] * Instructional Shifts to Support Deep Learning [https://www.ascd.org/el/articles/instructional-shifts-to-support-deep-learning] * You Can Teach for Meaning [https://www.ascd.org/el/articles/you-can-teach-for-meaning] * Making the Most of Professional Learning Communities [https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BNeMXVUuwFaQe98CvZlLHIqYcMV1c1Sb/view?usp=sharing]

30. juni 20261 h 2 min
episode How to Use the Jigsaw Strategy in Your Classroom (and with Station Rotation) artwork

How to Use the Jigsaw Strategy in Your Classroom (and with Station Rotation)

In this episode, I explore the jigsaw strategy, a powerful cooperative learning structure that positions students as active participants in the learning process. I break down why the strategy is so effective for increasing engagement, deepening understanding, and helping students develop communication, collaboration, and critical thinking skills. You'll learn the step-by-step process for implementing a jigsaw lesson, including how to support learners as they develop expertise and teach their peers. I also share practical ways to adapt the jigsaw strategy for diverse learners using scaffolds, formative assessment, and AI-powered supports. Finally, I explain how teachers can integrate jigsaw experiences into a station rotation model to increase student ownership, accountability, and cognitive engagement. Episode Resources * Related Blog: https://catlintucker.com/2026/06/jigsaw-strategy [https://catlintucker.com/2026/06/jigsaw-strategy/] * Resource: Teacher's Guide — Using Jigsaws in a Station Rotation [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NZGyWvbaZSzTLUeuK3ogq8WGOv6vqK8WkXqn5eRn7y8/edit?tab=t.0] * Check out my new keynotes! [https://catlintucker.com/keynote-speaking/]

16. juni 202626 min