Season 3, Episode 8: Matt Orton is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

Season 3, Episode 10: Star Magee is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

If you love stories that linger long after the lights go out, this episode is for you. This week on Unfreakingbelievable, we’re joined by Star McGee, the voice behind the Creepy Sh!t Podcast—a show devoted to the eerie, the unexplained, and the things that just don’t sit right. We dive into the stories that have stuck with her, the moments that blurred the line between skepticism and belief, and what it’s really like to spend your days immersed in the darkest corners of the paranormal. From chilling listener encounters to the question of what actually counts as “real,” this conversation is equal parts fascinating and unsettling. So if you’ve ever heard something go bump in the night… or wondered whether you should’ve looked a little closer—this is one episode you won’t want to miss.

Season 3, Episode 9: Charles Rosenay!!! is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

Step into the eerie unknown with Charles Rosenay!!!—producer, actor, author, and paranormal investigator—as he shares his chilling encounter with Connecticut’s infamous Pink Lady. From haunted legends to real-life ghost hunting, Charles brings decades of supernatural experience to this unforgettable episode. As the mastermind behind ParaConn, the Salem Paranormal & Horror Convention, and ghostly tours across the globe, he knows where the spirits linger … and he’s not afraid to tell their unfreakingbelievable stories.

Season 3, Episode 8: Matt Orton is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

Step into the strange and the spirited in this unforgettable episode of the UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE PODCAST, featuring Army veteran Matt Orton—host of the wildly entertaining Drunken Cryptids podcast. Matt brings his unique blend of military discipline and irreverent humor to the mic as he dives headfirst into the world of cryptids, the unexplained, and the downright bizarre. From shadowy creatures lurking just beyond the tree line to the camaraderie and storytelling that fuels his show, this conversation is equal parts chilling and hilarious. We talk about how his time in the Army shaped his perspective on fear and the unknown and why sometimes the best way to face the inexplicable … is with a drink in hand. If you love cryptids, ghost stories, and conversations that don’t take themselves too seriously, this is one episode you won’t want to miss.

Season 3, Episode 7: Kate White is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

From the glossy pages of top women’s magazines to the dark twists of psychological thrillers, Kate White has lived a career full of reinvention. In this episode of the UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE PODCAST, she shares her journey from leading publications like Cosmopolitan, Redbook, and Working Woman to becoming a bestselling novelist, and the uncanny story of how her thriller-writing career was foretold. Now the author of I CAME BACK FOR YOU, Kate shares how she traded headlines for plot twists, and why sometimes the most unbelievable stories are true.

Season 3, Episode 6: Wendy Walker is UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE!

Today on the Unfreakingbelievable Podcast, we sit down with bestselling thriller author Wendy Walker to talk about suspense, storytelling, and the dark twists that keep readers turning pages late into the night. Known for her gripping psychological thrillers, Wendy joins us to discuss the release of her brand-new novel, BLADES, a chilling story packed with secrets, danger, and the kind of tension that will leave you guessing until the very last page. In this episode, we dive into Wendy’s writing process, the UNFREAKINGBELIEVABLE inspiration behind BLADES, and what it takes to craft a thriller that truly gets under your skin. If you love mysteries, suspense, and behind-the-scenes looks at the world of figure skating, this is one conversation you won’t want to miss.