Still Asking the Questions: Ellen Belcher on Local Journalism, Editorial Pages, and Accountability
What happens to a community when no one's left watching?
Host Nan Whaley sits down with veteran Ohio journalist Ellen Belcher for a conversation about the collapse of local journalism, the shrinking role of editorial boards, and what communities lose when accountability reporting disappears.
After more than three decades helping shape public conversation in Ohio, Belcher reflects on the changing media landscape, the decline of civic trust, and why local news still matters deeply to democracy. Together, she and Nan explore how editorial pages once pushed elected officials to answer hard questions, what’s changed in political coverage over time, and whether sustainable local journalism can still exist.
Their conversation also covers:
* Memorable editorial board moments from decades covering Ohio politics, including the Strickland–Cremeans gun debate that produced Martin Gottlieb's now-famous "let's see how far this will go" line of questioning
* Why The New York Times has become "a national treasure" and the still-unanswered question of how to make local journalism work
* How losing local news erodes community identity, from Pittsburgh to Urbana to Dayton
* Reflections on what journalism missed about Ohio's de-industrialization
* Mentoring younger talent — and learning from the next generation in return
Resources Mentioned:
* Dayton Daily News [https://www.daytondailynews.com/]
* The New York Times [https://www.nytimes.com/]
* The Atlantic [https://www.theatlantic.com/]
* Ohio Capital Journal [https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/]
* Sinclair Community College [https://www.sinclair.edu/]
* Paper Girl by Beth Macy [https://bookshop.org/p/books/paper-girl-a-memoir-of-home-and-family-in-a-fractured-america-beth-macy/c76ba4d877fa1c53?ean=9780593656730&next=t]
* B2 Studios [https://www.b2studiosdayton.com/]
About Our Guest: Ellen Belcher is an award-winning journalist who spent 33 years at the Dayton Daily News, most of them on the editorial page, where she became a fixture in Ohio political journalism. A graduate of Ohio State's journalism school, she began her career at the Akron Beacon Journal's Columbus bureau before joining the Dayton Daily News as one of three editorial writers, eventually serving as the paper's editorial page editor. After leaving the paper, Ellen co-founded https://www.b2studiosdayton.com/B2 Studios [https://www.b2studiosdayton.com/], where she partners with video producers to tell stories about communities, families, and issues that don't always make headlines. She continues to write, mentor, and pay close attention to the people and places that shape Ohio.
About the Host: Nan Whaley is a longtime community leader and public servant. She’s currently the CEO of Planned Parenthood of Southwest Ohio. She served as Mayor of Dayton, Ohio from 2014 - 2022. Nan has also presided over the United Conference of Mayors. She’s a feminist, daughter, aunt, sister and friend.
About the Show: Carry As You Climb is focused on elevating the voices of women in leadership from Ohio and the rest of the United States. The podcast features guests who give special attention to not only busting through doors to lead but also hold the door open for more women behind them. In other words, they carry as they climb. We focus on leadership development and leadership lessons. Plus, we share personal experiences to inspire the inclusion of more diverse leaders in business, government and the
nonprofit sector.
Connect with Carry As You Climb
Socials
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/nanwhaley/] | [https://www.instagram.com/nanwhaley/]Facebook [https://www.facebook.com/carryasyouclimbpod/] | Tiktok [https://www.tiktok.com/@nanwhaley] | Twitter [https://x.com/nanwhaley] | LinkedIn [https://www.linkedin.com/in/nanwhaley/]
Stay up to date with Nan’s Substack: https://substack.com/@nanwhaley [https://substack.com/@nanwhaley]
Join the Climb
If this conversation moved you, share it with a friend, subscribe so that you never miss an episode, and rate and review Carry As You Climb wherever you listen to podcasts.
Produced by: Collective Change Communications - Kelly Sakalas & Jeni Keeler
Note: The opinions expressed by host Nan Whaley on this podcast are hers alone, and not that of any organization with which she is affiliated.