You're Measuring Author Success All Wrong

You're Measuring Author Success All Wrong

Are you measuring author success by the wrong standard? Too many writers compare themselves to bestselling authors, viral success stories, and household names. But what if that's exactly what's making you miserable? In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, Troy Lambert and Stacey Smekofske tackle the uncomfortable truth about author success, the publishing industry's "power law," and why so many writers burn themselves out chasing goals they can't control. We discuss why building a sustainable author career matters more than chasing fame, how to stop comparing yourself to the biggest names in publishing, and what successful authors actually spend their time doing. If you've ever felt behind, frustrated, overwhelmed, or like everyone else is succeeding faster than you, this conversation is for you. Success doesn't have to mean becoming Stephen King. Sometimes success means building a loyal readership, creating books you're proud of, and designing an author career that actually fits your life. In this episode: • Why most authors are measuring success incorrectly • The publishing industry's "power law" explained • Why comparison is killing your motivation • The difference between fame and a sustainable writing career • How to build your own author micro-community • What productive authors focus on (and what they ignore) • Why burnout is more dangerous than failure • The three assets every author should be building • Why writing a great book is necessary—but not enough • How to define success on your own terms Resources Mentioned: Author AI Sentiment Survey Quietly Into the Night by Vincent Zandri Alibi Syndicate Press Plot Dude's Guide to Story P2P Author Business Harbor Community If you enjoy honest conversations about writing, publishing, author business, and building a long-term career, make sure to subscribe and join us each week. #WritingCommunity #AuthorLife #IndieAuthor #SelfPublishing #WritingTips #PublishingIndustry #AuthorBusiness #WritingCareer #BookMarketing #AmWriting #AuthorsHelpingAuthors #CreativeEntrepreneur #WritingPodcast #BookTube #AuthorSuccess

Your Book Is NOT for Everyone (That's Why It Sells)

Is your book really for everyone? One of the biggest mistakes authors make is trying to write, market, and sell their books to everyone. In reality, the most successful authors understand that books succeed when they connect deeply with the right readers, not all readers. In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, Stacey Smekofske and Troy Lambert discuss why trying to appeal to everyone can actually hurt your book marketing, weaken your author brand, and make it harder to build a loyal readership. We explore audience targeting for authors, reader expectations, genre positioning, reader trust, author platforms, and why building a micro community of dedicated fans is more powerful than chasing a massive audience. Whether you're self-published, traditionally published, or somewhere in between, understanding who your book is truly for can dramatically improve your marketing strategy and long-term author career. In This Episode: • Why "my book is for everyone" is a dangerous mindset • How reader expectations affect book sales and reviews • The difference between a mass audience and a micro community • Building superfans instead of chasing followers • Why genre positioning matters • How authors accidentally betray reader trust • Creating an author platform readers actually want to join • The role of authenticity in building a sustainable author business AI Sentiment Survey: https://printtopro.com/author-a-i-sentiment-survey/ P2P Author Business Harbor: Join our community for free https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor/about   Resources Mentioned: • Story Genius by Lisa Cron If you found this discussion helpful, please like, subscribe, and share it with another author who may be trying to market their book to everyone. #WritingCommunity #BookMarketing #AuthorPlatform #SelfPublishing #IndieAuthor #WritingTips #PublishingIndustry #AuthorBusiness #BookPromotion #ReaderEngagement #WritingLife #Authors #BookMarketingStrategy #AuthorBrand #ProsTalkingProse

Your Book Title is Probably Hurting Sales

Most authors think book titles are just creative decisions. They’re not. Your title is metadata. Your title is marketing. Your title is the FIRST signal readers get about your book, and if it’s confusing, generic, impossible to pronounce, or sounds like every other title in your genre… readers are already moving on. In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, Troy Lambert and Stacey Smekofske break down why so many authors struggle with titling their books, how trends like “shadow/thorn/ash” naming conventions are flooding the market, and what actually makes a title memorable, searchable, clickable, and marketable. We also talk about: • Why readers judge books almost instantly • The biggest title mistakes authors make • Why “clever” often fails • Genre expectations and title psychology • Searchability and discoverability on Amazon • Why your title is part of your metadata strategy • The problem with trendy fantasy naming conventions • Why some titles actively hurt sales • How to test your title BEFORE launch • What authors should know about AI-generated titles and covers • Why readability matters more than authors think Also, we discuss updates surrounding the Anthropic AI lawsuit, Amazon reporting/review delays, and our upcoming AI sentiment survey for authors and readers. If you’re struggling to title your novel, nonfiction book, memoir, thriller, fantasy, romance, or cozy mystery… this episode is for you. 👇 RESOURCES & LINKS MENTIONED Join the FREE P2P Author Business Harbor community on Skool https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor Print to Pro: www.printtopro.com The Plot Abides: www.theplotabides.com AI Publishing Sentiment Survey   If this episode helped you, make sure to LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and SHARE it with another author. Every share genuinely helps us reach more writers trying to navigate publishing professionally. #WritingCommunity #BookMarketing #SelfPublishing #AmWriting #AuthorTube #WritingAdvice #IndieAuthor #BookTitles #PublishingTips #Authors #WritersLife #CreativeWriting #BookMarketingTips #ThrillerBooks #AuthorBusiness #Anthropicnews #AIwriting

Some Authors Forgot How to Enjoy Writing

Some authors became so focused on “being professional” that they forgot how to actually enjoy writing. In this episode of Pros Talking Prose, Stacey Smekofske and Troy Lambert tackle burnout, doomscrolling, industry panic, AI fearmongering, and the emotional exhaustion many authors are quietly carrying right now. We talk honestly about: • treating your author career like a hobby (in a healthy way) • why disruption in publishing never lasts forever • protecting your creativity during difficult seasons • how to stop tying your self-worth to book sales • why long-term authors survive by “keeping showing up” • maintaining joy while still taking your business seriously If you’re struggling with motivation, discouraged by slow growth, overwhelmed by social media, or simply trying to reconnect with WHY you started writing in the first place, this conversation is for you. Professional doesn’t have to mean miserable. RESOURCES  Print to Pro Classes & Webinars: https://printtopro.com Fjeldheim Writers Retreat: FjeldheimWritersRetreat.com Bonus Episode with Becca Syme & Roland Denzel: https://youtu.be/CgmV7Dk9Gvc Becca Syme / Better Faster Academy: https://betterfasteracademy.com Join the FREE P2P Author Business Harbor Community on Skool: https://www.skool.com/p2p-author-business-harbor/about #WritingCommunity #AmWriting #AuthorLife #SelfPublishing #WritingTips #IndieAuthor #BookWriting #Publishing #WritersOfYouTube #CreativeBurnout #AuthorBusiness #WritersLife #WritingMotivation #ProsTalkingProse

The Healthiest Authors Think Differently About Success

In this special bonus episode of Pros Talking Prose, Troy Lambert and Stacey Smekofske sit down with powerhouse author coaches Becca Syme and Roland Denzel for an honest, funny, and surprisingly deep conversation about author burnout, publishing disruption, mental health, creativity, resilience, and what it actually means to build a sustainable writing life. From the realities of traditional publishing and indie pressure to social media overwhelm, writing retreats, productivity myths, and the importance of protecting your creative energy, this episode explores why the healthiest authors often approach success very differently than the industry expects. Whether you're a full-time author, part-time creative, or somewhere in between, this conversation is a reminder that there is no single “right” way to build a writing career. In This Episode: Why publishing feels unstable for so many writers right now The hidden mental health costs of modern author culture The truth about traditional publishing vs indie publishing Why resilience matters more than certainty How different author brains process creativity Why some writers should absolutely edit as they go The danger of comparing your process to other authors Social media burnout and protecting your creative focus Writing as a business vs writing as a lifelong creative practice Why writing retreats can reignite creativity and momentum If you’re tired of hustle culture, burnout advice, and feeling like you’re “doing publishing wrong,” this conversation might be exactly what you need.   #ProsTalkingProse #AuthorLife #WritingCommunity #IndieAuthors #PublishingIndustry #WritingRetreat #AuthorBurnout #BeccaSyme #RolandDenzel #WritingPodcast #AuthorBusiness #CreativeProcess #BookMarketing #WritingLife #SelfPublishing