Kelly Evans: True Crime, Real Life, and Why She Refuses to Be Quiet
What St. Joseph's Kelly Evans has built in the last five years is incredible.
Mama Mystery is an internationally ranked, Cosmo Top 40 true crime podcast, and @TrueCrimeKel on TikTok has racked up more than 35 million views in the last year alone.
A recognized voice in the true crime space who regularly appears at major events like CrimeCon, Kelly is the author of Wicked Women, host of the new show The Motherload, and founder of the Uncool Collective - and we get into all of it.
But in this episode, we get the Kelly behind the microphone.
Kelly opens up about growing up with a mother who struggled with addiction during her most formative years, and how becoming a mother herself, especially to a daughter now approaching those same ages, has brought many of those emotions rushing back.
She shares the story of discovering through a 23andMe test in 2021 that she has a different biological father, navigating a complicated but beautiful family mosaic, and why she refuses to let any of it make her bitter.
We talk about her journey from hairstylist to true crime storyteller, how a supportive husband and strong village made it all possible, and why consistency, even when you feel stagnant, is the answer.
Kelly also shares what she’s most fired up about right now: the Uncool Collective and her mission to encourage parents to be more intentional about kids and social media access. If your child has ever told you, “everyone else has a phone,” this conversation is for you.
Plus: CrimeCon, the documentary, the Brian Entin connection, and what it actually looks like to be a one-woman show raising four kids, advocating for mental health, and building businesses alongside her husband, Austin.
Bottom line: she’s not just making TikToks.
Northwest Missouri’s story starts here.
Links & Resources:
Mama Mystery [https://www.mamamystery.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com]
The Uncool Collective [https://www.mamamystery.com/uncoolcollective?utm_source=chatgpt.com]
Kris and Kate’s Ice Cream Treats [https://www.krisandkates.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com]
Lean Kitchen Co. St. Joseph [https://leankitchenco.com/st-joseph/?utm_source=chatgpt.com]
The Motherload Podcast [https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-motherload/id1818358142]
The 39/94 Podcast is Northwest Missouri's community podcast - sharing the stories of the people, businesses, and experiences shaping our area.
🎙️ Subscribe so you never miss an episode and become a Patreon [https://www.patreon.com/posts/welcome-to-of-39-155767274?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=postshare_creator&utm_content=join_link] to support this adventure.
Give a gift on KoFi [ Ko-fi.com/the3994], support us on Venmo [https://venmo.com/The3994Podcast] of simply follow, comment and share on Facebook [https://www.facebook.com/The39.94], Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/the39.94podcast/] or TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@the.3994.podcast?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc]
🎙️ Sponsors of This Episode:
🛞 Wollenman's Family Deluxe Truck Stop [https://www.deluxetruckstop.com/]
💼 Greater Than Financial [https://greaterthanfinancial.com/]
🍗 Gina’s Café [https://ginascafemd.com/]
☕ Scooter's Coffee [https://www.scooterscoffee.com/]
🐶 Pankake's Pups & Suds [https://www.facebook.com/cpankake/]
Interested in becoming a sponsor?
Email us at The3994podcast@gmail.com [https://The3994podcast@gmail.com]