Roger Sherman, The Founder We Missed

Hamilton’s Moral Reckoning

Hamilton is easy to caricature: the brilliant operator, the relentless Federalist, the guy who never stops pushing. But the closer you look, the more the story bends toward something unexpected: a late-in-life moral awakening shaped by pride, collapse, and a real confrontation with faith. We sit down with Dr. Beienberg to follow Hamilton’s religious trajectory from early piety to a long stretch of indifference, then to a period in which he uses Christian language as a blunt political instrument against Jefferson and the Democratic-Republicans.  Along the way, we dig into the sharp irony historians highlight: the years when “religious slogans” are most on Hamilton’s lips may be the years when he is furthest from God. We talk through the 1800 election, Hamilton’s attempts to maneuver power behind the scenes, and the humiliations that strip away his sense of control. Then the conversation turns personal: the Reynolds affair, the loss of his son in a duel, his daughter’s breakdown, and how grief and disgrace can crack open a person who once seemed untouchable.  What follows is a different Hamilton: reading the Bible, seeking mercy, trying to do right even by political enemies, and wrestling with the idea that politics cannot be an idol. The final moment is the duel with Aaron Burr and Hamilton’s choice not to take a life because he believes it would be unchristian, followed by his urgent request for communion as he’s dying. If you care about Alexander Hamilton, American history, or the role of religion in public life, this one reframes the legend as more human and instructive.  Subscribe for more conversations like this, share the episode with a history-loving friend, and leave a review so more listeners can find the show. Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum [https://civics.asu.edu/civic-literacy-curriculum]! School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership [https://scetl.asu.edu/] Center for American Civics [https://civics.asu.edu/]

Roger Sherman, The Founder We Missed

He signed all four major American revolutionary documents, helped craft the constitutional structure we still argue about, and yet most people can’t tell you a single detail about him. We’re talking about Roger Sherman, the “forgotten founder that shouldn’t be forgotten,” and we’re making a serious case for bumping him into the Founders’ top tier based on impact, not celebrity.  We walk through Sherman’s improbable rise from shoemaker to self-taught lawyer to one of Connecticut’s most important judges, then trace why he keeps landing at the center of the founding era: the Continental Congress, the Declaration’s drafting committee, the Articles of Confederation, and the Constitutional Convention. Along the way, we unpack why he’s so easy to miss in modern history telling: he’s not a clean writer, not a magnetic speaker, deeply pious, and he dies in 1793 before later political battles make other founders famous.  The heart of the conversation is constitutional design. Sherman fights to preserve limited and enumerated powers, helps drive the Connecticut Compromise, and wins key federalism battles against broader national “plenary” power. We also dig into his skepticism of executive power, his concern about war-making authority, and his surprising role in the Bill of Rights debate, including why he insists amendments go at the end and how he helps shape the 10th Amendment. If you care about federalism, states’ rights, checks and balances, and what the Constitution actually means, this one will sharpen your view.  Subscribe for more deep dives, share this episode with a fellow civics nerd, and leave a review telling us whether Roger Sherman belongs on the Founders’ A team. Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum [https://civics.asu.edu/civic-literacy-curriculum]! School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership [https://scetl.asu.edu/] Center for American Civics [https://civics.asu.edu/]

How The Massachusetts Constitution Shaped American Government

John Adams has a branding problem. If your mental picture comes from a musical, a miniseries, or the vague sense that he “wanted to be king,” we put that claim on trial by reading his work where it matters most: the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780, the oldest functioning written constitution and a direct ancestor of the U.S. Constitution. We’re joined by Dr. Beienberg to trace what Adams actually argues for and why the rest of the founding generation quietly treats Massachusetts as the model. We dig into the Declaration of Rights and the tradeoffs baked into the final text: stronger protections against unreasonable searches and seizures, puzzling omissions like a dropped free speech clause, and a right to arms that lands weaker than you might expect. Then we move under the hood to Adams’s signature contribution to American government: separation of powers. Two legislative chambers, an independently elected governor, an empowered judiciary, and procedural rules that get “copied and pasted” into federal practice all show how constitutional structure can restrain ambition and channel conflict. We also take on the parts that make modern readers squirm and the parts that should stop you cold. One line about being “born free and equal” helps end slavery in Massachusetts, while other sections assume state support for religion is necessary for civic virtue and a stable republic. Finally, we connect Adams’s fears about oligarchy, money in politics, and moral formation to questions we still argue about today. If this changed how you see John Adams, subscribe, share the episode with a fellow history nerd, and leave a review. What’s one Adams idea you think the U.S. still needs? Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum [https://civics.asu.edu/civic-literacy-curriculum]! School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership [https://scetl.asu.edu/] Center for American Civics [https://civics.asu.edu/]

Benjamin Franklin And The Bold Experiment Of Pennsylvania’s 1776 Constitution

Pennsylvania tried something in 1776 that still tempts us today: push democracy to the front of the line and assume the people will keep government honest. With Dr. Beienberg, we walk through the Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 and Benjamin Franklin’s surprisingly central role in a state charter that deserves way more attention in any conversation about the American founding, state constitutions, and the roots of U.S. constitutional law. We break down what Pennsylvania gets right, especially its sweeping Declaration of Rights. You’ll hear why its protections for speech, jury trials, criminal procedure, and limits on searches and seizures become so influential across the early states. We also talk through religious liberty as the founders framed it, plus early constitutional commitments that feel strikingly modern, like support for public education and constraints on debtors’ prisons. Then we turn to the part that made Pennsylvania a punching bag for the 1787 Constitutional Convention. Annual elections, a legislature with huge power, a weak executive, and weak courts add up to a system that Madison, Wilson, and the Federalist Papers repeatedly treat as a “do not copy” model. We unpack the logic Pennsylvanians believed in, including transparency and voter oversight, and why it often fails in practice without durable checks and balances and real separation of powers. We close with the Council of Censors, Pennsylvania’s later 1790 rewrite, and a quick detour into why Pennsylvania is called a “Commonwealth.” If you like constitutional history with real stakes for how we argue about democracy today, subscribe, share this with a friend, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway. Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum [https://civics.asu.edu/civic-literacy-curriculum]! School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership [https://scetl.asu.edu/] Center for American Civics [https://civics.asu.edu/]

Lore of the Founding: Cicero And The Duty To Serve

A republic doesn’t collapse all at once. It frays in public, and it frays in private, through shortcuts that feel justified, norms that stop being enforced, and citizens who decide it’s safer to sit things out. That’s why we end our Lore of the Founding series with Cicero: Rome’s sharpest talker, a brilliant lawyer, and a painfully human political figure who tried to hold the Roman Republic together while it was coming apart. We talk with Joanna Kenty about why Cicero mattered so much to the American founding, especially to John Adams. From courtroom speeches that became the backbone of rhetoric education to the personal letters that reveal doubt, ego, and fear, Cicero shows how public service really works when the stakes are high. We unpack his exile after the Catiline conspiracy, what he saw as Senate authority weakened and corruption spread, and why he turned to philosophy when politics became a maze. The centerpiece is On Duties, where Cicero argues we are not born for ourselves alone and that justice requires an active life of civic engagement. We connect that to the Founders’ habit of turning reading into action and to Adams’s post-presidency shift into local involvement and public-minded correspondence. If you’ve ever wondered what “duty” means when politics is exhausting, polarized, or disappointing, this conversation is for you. Subscribe for more civic history with teeth, share this with a friend who cares about citizenship, and leave a review with the most challenging idea you heard. Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum [https://civics.asu.edu/civic-literacy-curriculum]! School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership [https://scetl.asu.edu/] Center for American Civics [https://civics.asu.edu/]