Faith Hedgepeth: The Apartment, the Note, and the Unanswered Questions (E159)

Natalee Holloway: The Vacation That Became a Global Mystery (E166)

In May 2005, 18-year-old Natalee Holloway traveled to Aruba with classmates to celebrate her high school graduation. What began as a carefree vacation quickly became an international missing persons case after Natalee vanished following a night out at local bars and clubs. As the investigation expanded across Aruba and beyond, media attention exploded. Suspects gave conflicting stories, searches uncovered little evidence, and the case evolved into one of the most heavily discussed mysteries of the 2000s. For years, the world followed every development, hoping for answers that always seemed just out of reach. Nearly two decades later, Natalee Holloway’s disappearance remains one of the most infamous and emotionally charged true crime cases in modern history.

Timmothy Pitzen: The Note That Claimed He Was Safe (E165)

In May 2011, six-year-old Timmothy Pitzen was taken out of school by his mother for what appeared to be a spontaneous road trip filled with water parks, hotels, and family outings. But days later, the trip ended in tragedy when authorities discovered his mother dead inside a motel room alongside a handwritten note claiming Timmothy was alive, safe, and hidden away where no one would ever find him. What followed became one of the most emotionally devastating missing child cases in modern America. Investigators searched across multiple states, followed countless tips, and faced a mystery centered around one impossible question: was Timmothy truly hidden somewhere, or had the note itself concealed a darker truth? More than a decade later, the disappearance of Timmothy Pitzen continues to haunt investigators, families, and online communities searching for answers.

Raymond Roth: The Beach, the Life Insurance, and the Lie (E164)

In 2012, a father reported that his 22-year-old son had disappeared while swimming off a Long Island beach. At first, the story sounded like a tragic accident a young man caught by the ocean and lost beneath the waves. But as investigators examined the details surrounding Raymond Roth and the disappearance of his son Jonathan Roth, troubling inconsistencies began to emerge. Questions surrounding life insurance policies, financial pressure, and contradictory statements transformed the case into something far stranger than anyone initially imagined. What began as a missing persons tragedy would ultimately become a story about deception, desperation, and a lie that unraveled piece by piece.

Karina Holmer: The Night Out That Ended in a Mystery (E163)

In June 1996, 20-year-old Swedish au pair Karina Holmer went out with friends in Boston for an evening of music, dancing, and celebration. Hours later, the night would end in horror when investigators discovered partial human remains in a dumpster behind an apartment building. The shocking nature of the crime stunned Boston and quickly transformed Karina’s case into one of the city’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. Despite witnesses, forensic evidence, and years of investigation, critical questions about Karina’s final hours remain unanswered. Nearly three decades later, people still ask the same chilling question: who crossed paths with Karina Holmer that night and why has no one ever been held accountable?

Patrice Endres: The Salon Disappearance and the Man Who Waited (E162)

In April 2004, Patrice Endres vanished from her salon in Cumming, Georgia, during what should have been a routine workday. Within a remarkably small window of time, Patrice seemingly disappeared without a trace leaving behind unfinished tasks, unanswered questions, and a timeline investigators would spend years trying to reconstruct. As the investigation unfolded, attention increasingly turned toward behavior, relationships, and interviews that many viewers later found deeply unsettling. Was Patrice taken by a stranger passing through town, or was the truth hidden closer to home? Years later, Patrice’s case remains one of the most discussed and debated disappearances in modern true crime.