When AI's Plausible Comparisons Reach the Classroom

The Group Thinks the Same Thing

In this episode we explore whether AI should be used as a starting point for student writing, especially in ELA classrooms. Topics covered: * The NCTE AI ELA Framework for grades 6–12 * Why the “blank page” is such a real challenge in writing instruction * The difference between AI as a starting point and AI as a thinking partner * What research suggests about AI, brainstorming, and idea diversity * How AI can function as a mirror for student thinking rather than a replacement for it Sources: https://ncte.org/working-ela-ai-framework/ https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-025-02173-x

When AI Reads First

In this episode we explore why sequencing matters when AI enters reading instruction. Drawing on Student Achievement Partners’ argument to “keep text at the center,” we look at a practical question for teachers and district leaders: does AI arrive before students have wrestled with a complex text, or after they have made their own first attempt? Topics covered: * Why “keeping text at the center” depends on instructional sequence * The difference between AI as a reading scaffold and AI as a reading substitute * How pre-reading summaries can short-circuit student comprehension work * What productive failure has to do with complex text instruction * Why “access support” and “pre-reading substitution” are not the same thing * The risk of designing away the productive friction that reading requires Source: https://learnwithsap.org/literacy/keep-text-at-the-center-of-a-changing-world/

What Happens to Students When the Tool Is Gone

In this episode we explore what happens when students learn with AI or other cognitive supports, and then suddenly have to work without them. We look at a recent learning science study highlighted by Carl Hendrick in The Learning Dispatch, where students who had been using a simple planning tool saw their performance drop when that tool was removed.  Topics covered: * Why introducing an AI tool also means planning for its removal * The difference between scaffolds, accommodations, and persistent AI tools * What learning science suggests about tool dependence * Why “taking the tool away” can reveal whether students have actually built skill * Why teachers need control over when AI feedback is on, limited, or turned off * Why AI implementation should be judged not only by access and efficiency, but by whether students can still think and perform when the support is gone Sources: https://carlhendrick.substack.com/p/the-monthly-dispatch-whats-new-in-a9a https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41235-026-00722-0

What a New Study Tells Us About AI and Learning

In this episode we explore a simple question for classrooms using AI: Should students think first and use ChatGPT later? We connect research to a seventh-grade poetry classroom where students drafted on paper before using AI-supported tools. Topics covered: * Why “better work with AI” is not the same as learning * The difference between performance and transferable skill * What happens when students go straight to ChatGPT for answers * Why “think first, AI later” may be a stronger classroom model * How teachers can structure AI use without banning it * Why assignment sequence matters as much as assignment policy * The risks of AI-assisted brainstorming at the very start of student work Sources: https://carlhendrick.substack.com/p/the-monthly-dispatch-whats-new-in-a9a  https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10648-026-10118-7

The Friction That Teaches

In this episode we explore how AI tools can either preserve or undermine one of the most important parts of learning: productive struggle. We look at Student Achievement Partners’ recent piece on AI in literacy and math classrooms, with a focus on the caution that students may lose essential learning opportunities when AI does the thinking too early. Topics covered: * What Student Achievement Partners warns about AI in literacy and math classrooms * Why productive struggle matters for student learning * Manu Kapur’s research on productive failure * The difference between cognitive surrender and skipped thinking * How AI can either extend or eliminate learning effort * What teachers should look for when AI enters an assignment * How instructional coaches can observe AI use in classrooms * What district leaders should ask before approving AI tools Sources: https://learnwithsap.org/cross-content/ai-is-so-hot-right-now-opportunities-and-cautions-in-literacy-and-math-classrooms/ https://arch.kuleuven.be/studeren/tall/artikels/productive-failure-kapur.pdf/@@download/file/Productive%20Failure%20Kapur.pdf https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07370000802212669 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00461520.2016.1155457 https://bellwether.org/publications/productive-struggle/?activeTab=1