The Big Itch

Born to Hang

Originally Aired: October 9, 1960 Gunsmoke #444, "Born to Hang," finds Matt Dillon racing against time to prevent a double murder. Joe Digger, a drifter, barely survives a lynching when ranchers Glick and Pate string him up for horse theft based on nothing more than finding their horses near his camp. Robert, the third rancher, refuses to participate in the hanging and secretly cuts Digger down after the others ride off, saving his life but earning himself dangerous enemies. When Robert brings the rope-scarred Digger into Dodge City, Matt learns the full story and recognizes the burning rage behind the survivor's calm demeanor. Despite Digger's claims that he harbors no ill will toward his would-be killers, Matt knows better. The marshal gives himself until midnight the following day to bring Glick and Pate to justice before Digger takes matters into his own hands. When Matt and Chester ride out to arrest the ranchers, they discover that Glick appears genuinely unaware that Digger survived the lynching, complicating Matt's efforts to prevent further bloodshed. The marshal must navigate between serving justice and stopping vigilante revenge before Dodge City sees more violence.

The Big Itch

Originally Aired: October 2, 1960 Gunsmoke #443, "The Big Itch," brings Marshal Matt Dillon into a troubling mystery when Samantha Church arrives in his office seeking help. Her husband George left their ranch two days earlier to pay off their bank note with money from their first big cattle sale, but he never made it to the bank and hasn't been seen since. The only lead is that rancher Hobie Price was spotted riding off with George that Monday morning, and Hobie was later seen at the Long Branch that night, spending money freely and buying drinks for everyone. When Matt questions Kitty about Hobie's behavior, she confirms he was drinking heavily and throwing cash around like there was no tomorrow. Matt and Chester search the countryside between the Church ranch and Dodge City, looking for any sign of what might have happened to George. They question Ben Stanley, the young man the Churches raised after his parents were killed in a raid, but he has no helpful information beyond confirming George's eagerness to pay off the debt. As the investigation stalls with no trace of either George or Hobie Price, Chester begins developing a mysterious rash that demands Doc's attention.

Doc Judge

Originally Aired: September 25, 1960 Gunsmoke #442, "Doc Judge," finds Doc Adams in a dangerous case of mistaken identity. When a bitter ex-convict named Bryce Hart arrives in Dodge City, he immediately confronts Doc at Delmonico's restaurant, insisting that Doc is actually Judge Kennebre from Wyoming—the man who sentenced him to seven years in prison. Despite Doc and Chester's protests that he's a physician, not a judge, Hart refuses to believe them and vows to kill Doc for revenge. Initially, Doc dismisses Hart as harmless, especially since the man isn't even wearing a gun. However, Chester grows increasingly concerned about the threat. The situation takes a deadly turn when Chester witnesses Hart in action at the Long Branch Saloon. Armed now with a gun and demonstrating professional skill with it, Hart violently runs Bob Forrest out of the establishment, proving he's far more dangerous than Doc believed. With Marshal Matt Dillon out of town on business and not expected back for another day, Chester races to Doc's office to warn him of the escalating danger. The deputy must now find a way to protect Doc from a vengeful killer who won't listen to reason.

Two Mothers

Originally Aired: September 18, 1960 Gunsmoke #441, "Two Mothers," begins at a graveside service for a young man killed in a brawl. Marshal Dillon tries to offer condolences to the victim's mother, Miss Lorenda Henshaw, while another woman, Hattie Meisner, desperately attempts to speak with her. Lorenda refuses to talk, and for good reason: it was Hattie's son Jake who pulled the trigger. Though the shooting happened during a drunken fight, Jake used his gun on an unarmed man, and now he sits in jail awaiting execution. Hattie, a respected and God-fearing woman known throughout Dodge City for her kindness and strength, is consumed by grief and desperation over her son's fate. In a shocking confrontation at the marshal's office, Hattie delivers an ultimatum to Matt Dillon: if Jake hangs on Thursday, she will kill the marshal. Matt knows she's serious and capable with a firearm, yet he also recognizes she's a good woman driven to the edge by unbearable circumstances. With no legal way to save Jake and no desire to harm Hattie, Matt faces an impossible situation, leaving Doc Adams and Kitty to wonder how he can possibly protect both himself and this grieving mother from a tragedy neither wants.

About Chester

Originally Aired: September 11, 1960 Gunsmoke #440, "About Chester," finds Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester searching for Doc Adams, who has been missing for four days. When Emmett Bowers arrives in Dodge looking for Doc—who never showed up to examine his son's broken arm—Matt and Chester split up to cover more ground, checking ranches along the trail to the Clooney place. Chester takes the route past the Pope Ranch, where he learns about recent horse thefts and discovers his own mount has picked up a stone bruise. Spotting a cabin through the trees as a rainstorm approaches, Chester seeks shelter but receives a hostile greeting from the suspicious owner, Dak, who nearly shoots him on sight. The tension eases when Chester mentions he works with Marshal Dillon, and Dak's wife Lily May insists on offering proper hospitality. As Chester accepts their invitation to supper and shelter, he learns that Dak deals in wild horses, though business hasn't been good lately. With his lame horse, the approaching storm, and Matt expecting him at the Clooney Ranch, Chester finds himself in an increasingly uncertain situation at this isolated homestead.