25. The Bag Murders

27. The Boys of Boise Scandal

What happens when the justice system itself becomes the monster? In Episode 27, we are stepping away from our usual murder cases to uncover one of the most chilling examples of systemic corruption and moral panic in American history: the 1955 Boys of Boise scandal. At the height of the Cold War and the Lavender Scare, a single local incident in Boise, Idaho, was weaponized by police, politicians, and the Idaho Statesman newspaper into a massive, city-wide witch hunt.  We explore how a community turned against its own citizens utilizing off-the-books interrogation rooms, FBI agents, and the threat of life in prison to purge the city's LGBTQ+ community. We also delve into the dark reality of how Boise’s wealthy elite were quietly shielded while working-class men were publicly ruined and handed draconian prison sentences. This is a ghost story of institutional corruption, a terrifying look at how media hysteria shapes the law, and a stark reminder of the history that echoes into our current political climate. Episode Highlights * The Lavender Scare: How Cold War paranoia set the stage for the government to conflate homosexuality with national security threats. * The Dragnet Begins: The hiring of an anti-communist private investigator to run off-site interrogations and coerce confessions from closeted citizens. * Trial by Typewriter: How the Idaho Statesman newspaper bypassed the justice system to publicly ruin the accused on their front pages. * The Midnight Exodus: The terrifying reality for the dozens of men who fled Idaho in the middle of the night to escape the witch hunt. * Two Tiers of Justice: How Boise's elite escaped the dragnet by checking into private sanitariums while working-class men like Ralph Cooper were sentenced to life in the state penitentiary. * The 10-Year Silence: Why the investigation suddenly collapsed, and how the city of Boise buried the trauma until journalist John Gerassi forced a reckoning. Sources & Further Reading * The Boys of Boise: Furor, Vice and Folly in an American City by John Gerassi (The definitive 1966 investigative book that broke the city's silence). * The Fall of '55 (2006 Documentary directed by Seth Randal). * "Idaho Underworld," Time Magazine (December 12, 1955). * The Lavender Scare: The Cold War Persecution of Gays and Lesbians in the Federal Government by David K. Johnson. Support the Show * Binge the Back Catalog: New here? Episodes 1 through 26 are available right now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and everywhere you listen. * Leave a Review: If you enjoyed this historical true crime deep dive, please take 30 seconds to leave us a 5-star rating and written review. It is the number one way to help the podcast grow. * Follow for Visuals: See the historical photos, the Idaho Statesman newspaper clippings, and the Old Idaho State Penitentiary on our Instagram @HomocidalTendency https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency [https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency] Send us Fan Mail [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2593502/fan_mail/new]

26. Michael Peterson | The Staircase & Owl Theory

A missing two hours. A blood-soaked staircase. A medical paradox that defies the laws of blunt-force trauma. In Episode 26 of Homocidal Tendency, we strip away the sensationalism to examine the chilling death of Kathleen Peterson and the ensuing trial of her husband, Michael Peterson. Known globally as "The Staircase" case, this investigation remains one of the most polarizing mysteries in modern true crime history. How does a victim sustain seven massive scalp lacerations without a single skull fracture or defensive wound?  We break down the forensic anomalies, the prosecution's weaponization of moral panic, and the devastating impact of fraudulent blood-spatter testimony by SBI agent Duane Deaver.  Finally, we explore the infamous "Owl Theory" a heavily debated, yet forensically consistent alternative that changes the entire landscape of the crime scene. Key Topics Covered In This Episode: * The Autopsy Paradox: Examining Kathleen Peterson’s baffling injuries and the medical anomalies that contradict standard blunt-force murder theories. * The Two-Hour Void: Analyzing the "red neuron" evidence that indicates Kathleen lay dying for 45 to 120 minutes before 911 was called. * Forensic Corruption: The devastating role of SBI Agent Duane Deaver and his fabricated blood-spatter testimony that corrupted the initial 2003 conviction. * The Germany Connection: The eerie similarities to the 1985 staircase death of Elizabeth Ratliff. * Weaponizing Morality: How ADA Freda Black and the prosecution used homophobia and Michael Peterson’s private life to bias the jury. * The Owl Theory: T. Lawrence Pollard’s controversial hypothesis involving a Barred Owl attack, microscopic feathers, and cedar needles found at the scene. * The Alford Plea: Understanding the legal maneuver that finally secured Michael Peterson’s release in 2017. Binge The Archive New to the podcast? It is the perfect time to catch up. Dive into the backlog and stream all 25 previous episodes of Homocidal Tendency available right now on your favorite podcast app. Follow & Support https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency [https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency] * Socials: Join the true-crime community and follow along for case updates, visual evidence, and retro-noir podcast art. * Subscribe: Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe so you don't miss our return from the midseason break! Send us Fan Mail [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2593502/fan_mail/new]

B2. The Drowning of Dr. George Duncan [Bonus Episode]

We just wrapped our mid-season finale with Episode 25, and while I am taking a brief hiatus to recharge the batteries, the feed isn't going dark.  In this special, fast-paced bonus episode of Homocidal Tendency, we plunge into a chilling 1972 cold case that permanently altered the course of history in Australia. The drowning of Dr. George Duncan in Adelaide's River Torrens wasn't merely a tragic loss of life; it exposed a terrifying reality of systemic police corruption and violence directed at the LGBTQ+ community.  When the local Vice Squad treats hunting marginalized men as a sport, and the people sworn to protect the public are the ones lurking in the shadows, who do you call for help?  In This Episode, We Discuss: * The Hunting Ground: The oppressive, dangerous atmosphere of Adelaide in 1972 and the hidden "beats" along the River Torrens. * The Target: The quiet life and hidden medical vulnerabilities of Dr. George Duncan, a brilliant 41-year-old law professor who could not swim. * The Attack: The brazen events of May 10th, the Vice Squad's horrific "game," and the miraculous survival of Roger James. * The Cover-Up: The staggering "Blue Wall of Silence" that protected the killers and ultimately thwarted detectives from New Scotland Yard. * The Catalyst: How the sheer public outrage over an unsolved murder ignited a revolution, making South Australia the first state to fully decriminalize homosexuality in 1975. Stay Connected: Make sure you are subscribed so you don't miss the premiere of Episode 26 when we return from our mid-season break! https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency [https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency] Send us Fan Mail [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2593502/fan_mail/new]

25. The Bag Murders

In Episode 25, Matt takes you back to the gritty, neon-lit streets of 1970s New York City to investigate one of the most chilling and frustrating unsolved mysteries in true crime history: The Bag Murders. Between 1975 and 1977, the dark waters of the Hudson River surrendered a terrifying secret. Six unidentified victims were discovered along the Greenwich Village waterfront. But how does a serial killer dismantle six victims in the heart of Manhattan without leaving a trace? And why did the authorities completely look the other way? Today, we are stripping away the Hollywood urban legends to examine the cold, historical facts, the dangerous geography of the underground club scene, and the institutional apathy that allowed a monster to hunt in the shadows. Episode Highlights: * The Geography of Risk: Exploring the underground nightlife of 1970s Greenwich Village and the dangerous isolation of the abandoned Hudson River piers. * Institutional Apathy: How the NYPD's hostility toward the LGBTQ+ community created a massive blind spot that serial killers exploited. * The M.O. and The Clues: Breaking down the terrifying forensic profile of the killer and the custom leather clothing that served as the investigation's only lead. * Theories and Suspects: Was it an organized Mafia hit? A hunting ground for multiple predators? Or the early, undiscovered work of the infamous "Last Call Killer," Richard Rogers? * The Paul Bateson Connection: Unpacking the arrest of the X-ray technician, the unverified jailhouse confession, and the Hollywood trivia connecting the case to The Exorcist and Cruising. Housekeeping & Announcements: This episode marks the Homocidal Tendency midseason finale! The show will be taking a short 1-2 week break to recharge and research for the second half of the season. Keep an eye on your feed, because a special bonus mini-episode will drop during the hiatus. If you are a new listener, there are 24 other binge-worthy episodes of the season waiting for you right now! Support the Show: * Rate & Review: Please take a second to rate, review, and subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. It is the best way to help other true crime fans find the show! * Visual Aids: Follow us on social media to see all the archival photography for this case, including the rotting piers, the Village clubs, and Arthur Bell's original Village Voice reporting. https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency [https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency] Stay safe, keep your doors locked, and thank you for riding out the first half of the season. From Matt, Benson, and Toulouse thanks for listening! Send us Fan Mail [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2593502/fan_mail/new]

24. The Monster of Montmartre | Thierry Paulin

Behind the blinding neon lights, free-flowing champagne, and pulsing techno of the 1980s Paris underground, a predator was using high fashion as camouflage to hunt in plain sight.  This week on Homocidal Tendency, we step off the dance floor of Le Palace and into the quiet, winding stone stairwells of the 18th arrondissement to track one of the most anomalous and terrifying true crime cases in modern French history. We break down the lethal folie à deux of Thierry Paulin and Jean-Thierry Mathurin a toxic partnership fueled by extreme narcissism, heavy cocaine addiction, and an insatiable lust for social status. We explore how they weaponized Parisian architecture, bypassed criminal profiling, and ultimately funded their glamorous nightlife by brutally terrorizing the city's most vulnerable demographic: elderly women living alone. This isn't a story of a brilliant mastermind. It's the story of a shallow illusion, a devastating police blindspot, and a final, infuriating cheat of the justice system. In This Episode We Cover: * The socio-economic clash of 1980s Paris and the underground club scene. * The psychological anatomy of Paulin and Mathurin's predator/prey partnership. * The "Urban Architecture Trap" and how the killers bypassed the Digicode systems. * The massive investigation failures and the miraculous survivor who cracked the case. * The chillingly anti-climactic arrest and Paulin's final escape from justice. In Memoriam: Honoring the Victims True crime too often remembers the names of the monsters while forgetting the people they took from us. Thierry Paulin viewed these women as nothing more than walking vaults to fund his luxury lifestyle, but they were mothers, grandmothers, and lifelong Parisians whose lives mattered. We honor the known, documented victims of the 1984–1987 Montmartre attacks: * Germaine Petitot (91) – Survived * Anna Barbier-Ponthus (83) * Suzanne Foucault (89) * Ioana Sechero (71) * Alice Cadot (84) * Marie Chiffard (86) * Jeanne Vautrin (83) * Jeanne Estournel (82) * Paule Vuillemin (79) * Estella Foucher (89) * Rachel Cohen (79) * Berthe Finalteri (87) – Survived * Geneviève Pinard (90) And to the women whose names remain sealed in the French courts or whose cases were never officially closed: you are not forgotten. A Quick Apology from Matt 🇫🇷 Bonjour, je m'appelle Matt et je suis désolé. To all of my beautiful French and Francophone listeners.  Please accept apologies for my tragic, heavily Americanized pronunciation of your historic streets, designers, and legendary nightclubs. I promise I practiced, but my tongue got in the way. Connect with Homocidal Tendency If this case got under your skin, head over to our social media! We are posting the composite sketches, photos of Paulin from his club days, and the stark visual contrast of the 80s Parisian architecture we discussed today. * Instagram: [@HomocidalTendency] * Bluesky: [@HomocidalTendency] https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency [https://linktr.ee/HomocidalTendency] Love the show? Don't forget to hit subscribe, leave a 5-star rating, and share this episode with your fellow true crime addicts! Want more right now? All 23 previous episodes are fully binge-worthy and waiting in your feed. Stay safe out there, and keep an eye on who's standing on your doorstep. Send us Fan Mail [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2593502/fan_mail/new]