Beyond the Locked Door: The Story of Kathleen Folbigg

The Silent Feud of New London

The story unfolds in New London, Connecticut, revolving around a tragic family conflict over child custody. Anson Clinton III, who worked various jobs including as a locksmith and a male dancer, struggled with substance abuse and had a son from a previous marriage he had lost contact with. In 1992, he met Kim Carpenter at a bar, and the two quickly fell in love. Kim was a single mother to a young girl named Rebecca, who suffered from a metabolic disorder called phenylketonuria (PKU) and required special care.Kim's parents, Richard and Cynthia, along with her ambitious lawyer sister, Beth Carpenter, deeply disapproved of Anson. The Carpenter family had essentially been raising Rebecca due to Kim's struggles and lack of stability. However, with Anson's support, Kim wanted to take an active role in raising her daughter, and the couple planned to create a stable home together. This sparked a bitter custody battle between Kim and her own family.The Carpenters, represented by Beth, filed for legal custody of Rebecca and went as far as falsely accusing Anson of having inappropriate inclinations towards the child to ruin his reputation. Despite these malicious tactics, Anson and Kim got married in 1993. Unable to afford an attorney, Anson represented himself in court and successfully defeated his sister-in-law Beth, securing full custody of Rebecca for him and Kim. Following this legal victory, Anson and Kim planned to move to Arizona to start a new life away from the toxic family dynamics.Furious over losing the case to her brother-in-law and desperate to prevent Rebecca from moving away, Beth decided to have Anson eliminated. On March 10, 1994, Anson was lured to a meeting on Interstate 95 under the pretense of selling a tow truck. There, he was fatally shot.The case went cold until 1995 when an anonymous informant contacted the police, leading to the arrest of Mark Despres and Joseph Fremount. The men confessed that they were hired hitmen, paid by a local lawyer named Klein. Klein, who was dating Beth Carpenter at the time, admitted that he orchestrated the hit on Beth's orders to prove his love for her. As a result, Beth Carpenter was arrested in 1999 and ultimately sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole in 2002. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support [https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss].

Beyond the Locked Door: The Story of Kathleen Folbigg

Caitlyn was born into a tragic situation; her father, a violent man with criminal ties, killed her mother when Caitlyn was only 18 months old. She spent time in an orphanage and was eventually adopted by the Marlborough family. Seeking stability and a loving environment, she married Craig Folbigg at a young age, and the couple hoped to build a happy family together.However, tragedy struck the couple repeatedly as all four of their children died unexpectedly during infancy or early childhood. Their first son, Caleb, was born in 1989 and died at just 19 days old, an event initially attributed to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Their second son, Patrick, born in 1990, suffered from severe epilepsy that caused blindness and brain damage before passing away at eight months old. The couple's third child, a daughter named Sarah born in 1992, died at 10 months old, again attributed to SIDS. Finally, their fourth child, Laura, was born in 1997 but tragically passed away at 19 months old.Following Laura's death, an investigation was opened, as the child was over a year old, making SIDS an unlikely medical explanation. Suspicions turned toward Caitlyn, particularly after her husband found her personal diary and handed it over to the police. In her diary, Caitlyn wrote entries filled with grief and self-blame, expressing fear that she was the "worst mother" and making ambiguous statements, such as saying she was "hasty and cruel" to Sarah, which caused the child to leave "with a bit of help". The prosecution interpreted these diary entries as a literal confession that she had suffocated her children, arguing that four sudden infant deaths in one family could not possibly be a coincidence. Despite the complete lack of physical evidence, Caitlyn was convicted in 2003 and sentenced to 40 years in prison, which was later reduced to 30 years upon appeal.Years later, major advancements in medicine and genetics dramatically changed the understanding of the case. In 2018, an inquiry was launched, and top geneticists were brought in to closely examine the DNA of the Folbigg children. They discovered that the two daughters, Sarah and Laura, had inherited a highly rare genetic mutation in the CALM2 gene from their mother. This mutation disrupts calcium flow in cells and can cause fatal cardiac arrhythmias, such as long QT syndrome, directly leading to sudden cardiac death. Additionally, genetic testing of the two sons, Caleb and Patrick, revealed a mutation in the BSN gene. Scientific studies have shown that this specific mutation causes lethal epilepsy and blindness in mice, which perfectly matched the severe neurological symptoms Patrick had experienced before his death. Furthermore, medical records showed that Laura had been suffering from myocarditis (heart inflammation) and a cold just before she died, which, combined with her CALM2 mutation, pointed heavily toward a natural cause of death.Armed with this new scientific evidence proving that all four children possessed fatal genetic mutations, the legal system finally re-evaluated the case. It became clear that the children likely died from natural, genetic causes rather than foul play. Consequently, in December 2023, the court officially overturned Caitlyn's conviction, and she was released from prison after spending over two decades behind bars. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support [https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss].

The Fatal Prescription: The Case of Michele and Martin MacNeil

Michelle Somers was born on January 15, 1957, in Concord, California, into a family with seven children. Despite having an absent father, her mother maintained a happy home, and Michelle grew up to be an empathetic, popular student, a cheerleader, and a prom queen. She became highly involved in the Mormon church in her late teens, worked as a model to support herself, and won the title of Miss Concord in 1976.At a young adult church meeting, she met Martin MacNeil, a man from a troubled background in New York who received a military pension due to emotional issues. Despite Martin's history of financial fraud and the disapproval of Michelle's family, the two secretly married in February 1978. The couple eventually had four biological children, adopted three girls from Ukraine, and adopted their teenage daughter's baby. Martin became a doctor and a lay Mormon bishop, though he had actually falsified documents to gain admission into both medical and law schools.Their seemingly perfect life concealed Martin's infidelities, including a long-term affair with a woman named Gypsy Willis that began in 2005. Martin heavily pressured Michelle to undergo a facelift in April 2007, despite her suffering from hypertension. Following the surgery, Martin took charge of her recovery and prescribed a dangerous combination of medications, including diazepam and oxycodone. On April 11, 2007, Martin claimed to have found Michelle unresponsive in a bathtub full of water.Immediately after her death, Martin ordered his son to flush the remaining medications down the toilet and quickly moved Gypsy Willis into the family home under the guise of being a nanny. He also attempted to steal one of his adopted daughters' identities to help Gypsy avoid her financial debts, which eventually resulted in a fraud conviction for both of them. Suspecting foul play, Michelle's daughter Alexis, a medical student, alongside her aunt, pushed for an investigation to challenge the initial ruling of cardiovascular disease. Medical experts determined the prescribed drug mix was highly dangerous, witnesses reported Martin had previously fabricated terminal illnesses to explain Michelle's weakened state, and an inmate testified that Martin confessed to drugging and drowning his wife.In September 2014, Martin was sentenced to a minimum of 16 years to life in prison for his actions and for obstructing justice. The tragic story ultimately concluded with the suicides of their son Damien in 2010 and Martin himself while incarcerated in 2017. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support [https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss].

The Inheritance Murders: The Case of the Ewell Family

The story revolves around the Ewell family from Sunnyside, California. Dale Ewell, a self-made millionaire who built an airplane company called Western Piper Sales, and his wife Lee, a former teacher and civic activist, provided a wealthy but grounded life for their two children, Tiffany and Dana.While Tiffany was ambitious and hardworking, Dana developed into a pathological liar and a severe materialist from a young age. Despite having an IQ of 180, he was highly manipulative and preferred to use others to achieve his goals. Dana fabricated a grandiose public persona, claiming to be a self-made young millionaire who had made a fortune on the stock market and owned his own airplane manufacturing company earning $3 million annually. He even convinced a college newspaper to publish a glowing article about his fictitious success. When his parents discovered this article, they confronted Dana, threatened to cut off his financial support after he finished college, and altered their wills to leave larger shares of the company to Tiffany.In college, Dana befriended Joel Radovcich, a socially awkward student who became entirely enamored with Dana's perceived wealth and popularity. Dana heavily manipulated Joel, promising him a life of luxury and treating him to expensive gifts.On Easter weekend, April 19, 1992, the Ewell family returned to their Sunnyside home from a trip to their beach house in Pajaro Dunes. Dana stayed behind with his girlfriend's family—whose father happened to be an FBI agent—which provided him with a perfect alibi. An intruder waiting inside the home shot and killed Lee and Tiffany upon their arrival, and then murdered Dale when he arrived thirty minutes later. The crime scene was staged to look like a robbery, but nothing was stolen, the alarm did not sound, and there were no signs of forced entry, indicating the killer had a key and the alarm code.Dana's behavior after the murders immediately raised suspicions. He showed little grief and was obsessed with inheriting the family's $8 million estate. However, he was visibly enraged upon learning that his parents' will restricted his full access to the fortune until he turned 35, only granting him an allowance for basic needs in the meantime. To maintain his lavish lifestyle, Dana ruthlessly drained $400,000 from his sick grandmother's trust fund, leaving her with a mere $2,000. He used these stolen funds to finance a luxurious life for himself and Joel, buying cars, paying for flying lessons, and purchasing a small airplane.The investigation progressed when police traced the murder weapon to Joel's high school friend, Ernest. Facing potential prosecution, Ernest confessed the entire plot: Dana had masterminded the murders, promising Joel $4 million—half of the inheritance—to execute the killings. Ernest and Joel's brother, Peter, had helped dispose of the murder weapon and the clothes worn during the crime.Police set up wiretaps, and in 1995, they successfully recorded Dana and Joel implicitly discussing the murders. Both men were arrested, and on July 20, 1998, Dana and Joel were sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, while Ernest and Peter received immunity in exchange for their testimonies. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support [https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss].

Fatal Attraction Online: The Case of Sharee Miller

Cheri was born on October 13, 1971, in Flint, Michigan. After a difficult upbringing, she was left to fend for herself by the age of sixteen. Following a brief marriage at age 19 that produced her first child, she spent roughly nine years leading a party-centric lifestyle. During this time, she had two more children and likely went through two more short-lived marriages, ultimately finding herself as a nearly bankrupt single mother of three by the age of 28.Seeking stability, Cheri changed her lifestyle and found a job in 1997 as an accountant at a scrapyard owned by Bruce Miller, a successful but solitary man twenty years her senior. She seduced Bruce, moved into his house with her three children, and the couple married in 1999. Although they initially wanted children, Cheri had previously undergone a medical procedure that prevented her from getting pregnant.While married, Cheri spent a lot of time in online chat rooms, where she met Jerry Cassaday, a former law enforcement officer working in Nevada. Their online friendship quickly turned romantic, and they eventually met in person. To manipulate Jerry, Cheri concocted an elaborate web of lies. She falsely claimed that Bruce was an abusive mafia member, sending Jerry photos of herself with fake bruises created using makeup. She also fabricated two pregnancies with Jerry's children—even using an old 1994 ultrasound photo—and lied that Bruce had caused her to miscarry them in a fit of rage. Furthermore, she sent threatening emails to Jerry from a fake account while posing as Bruce.Believing he was protecting the woman he loved, Jerry conspired with Cheri to eliminate Bruce. On November 8, 1999, Jerry traveled to the scrapyard and shot Bruce, staging the scene as a robbery by taking a small amount of cash on Cheri's instruction. Following the murder, Cheri played the role of a grieving widow, collected approximately $80,000 in life insurance payouts, sold the business, and quickly moved another man into her home. She completely severed contact with Jerry.Realizing he had been manipulated into killing an innocent man, a devastated Jerry took his own life on February 11, 2000. Before his death, he left behind a detailed suicide note and printed chat logs from the day of the murder, fully exposing the plot and Cheri's instructions.Cheri was arrested and went to trial in December 2000. Her defense argued that the evidence was forged by a rejected, vengeful lover, but she was ultimately sentenced to life in prison in 2001. After a complex legal battle—which included her forming a relationship with a man who saw her on television, and a temporary release upon appeal in 2009—she was permanently sent back to prison in 2012. In 2016, a four-page letter emerged in which Cheri finally confessed to the entire plot, admitting she had manipulated Jerry to get rid of her husband for financial gain. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support [https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss].