How to Evaluate a Site Selection RFI: An Economic Developer's Scoring Framework

How to Evaluate a Site Selection RFI: An Economic Developer's Scoring Framework

It’s Friday at 4:00 PM. Your weekend is perfectly planned. Then... ding. A 60-page Request for Information (RFI) hits your inbox, and it’s due on Tuesday. We've all been there, and we all know the "EDO guilt" that follows when you even consider passing on a massive project. In this episode of Site Selectors Are People Too, host Devin Hillsdon-Smith dives deep into the human impact of the RFI process and gives economic developers the ultimate permission slip: It is okay to say no. A win isn't a win if it breaks the team who landed it. To help you navigate the pressure, Devin breaks down the Hyphen Strategies RFI Gut Check Scorecard, a 4-phase decision matrix designed to help your Economic Development Organization (EDO) protect its people and its community: * Phase 1: The Internal Human Audit – Checking your team's emotional runway, capacity, and the hidden opportunity costs of a high-intensity response. * Phase 2: The Consultant & Relationship Context – How to spot a "fishing expedition," why you need to pick up the phone for a clarity call, and the importance of an honesty check. * Phase 3: Community & Culture – Applying the "Good Neighbor Test" to ensure a company's ethos, wages, and strategic alignment actually fit your 10-year vision. * Phase 4: The Technical Reality – A hard stop for utility realism, labor truth, and site readiness. (If it's gently rolling, don't call it flat!) 📚 Resources Mentioned in This Episode: * Access [https://sites.google.com/hyphenstrategiesllc.com/rfi-scorecard/home] the FREE interactive Hyphen Strategies RFI Gut Check Scorecard. Remember: Take care of your sites, but take care of your people first! #EconomicDevelopment #SiteSelection #EDO #Leadership #WorkplaceWellbeing #CorporateRealEstate #Essentialism

Community Champions: Jim Plump on Long-Term Economic Development

In the Season 3 finale of Site Selectors are People Too, host Devin Hillsdon-Smith sits down with a true titan of the economic development industry: Jim Plump. Having served as the Executive Director of the Jackson County Industrial Development Corporation since its inception in 1984, Jim brings 40 years of unparalleled wisdom to this special Stories from the Road installment. Tune in as Jim details the incredible transformation of rural Jackson County, Indiana, into a booming global manufacturing hub. He shares the fascinating behind-the-scenes story of how a seamless, team-first effort helped Seymour land tier-one Toyota supplier Aisin in 1986, paving the way for dozens of international investments in the region. Devin and Jim also explore how the role of a "Community Champion" has drastically evolved over the decades. Moving beyond the old days of "chasing smokestacks," modern economic development now requires navigating AI, championing local housing, and building robust, innovative workforce pipelines. You'll hear about Jackson County's unique, 26-year-old Workforce Partnership—including their brilliant strategy of paying for substitute teachers so educators can tour local industries and bring real-world manufacturing knowledge back to their students. Whether it's deploying the "shield" to protect the community from bad-fit projects, or using the "sword" to bring high-quality employers like Guardian Bikes to town, Jim’s humble and collaborative approach is a masterclass in economic development. Note: This is our final episode of Season 3! We will be taking a short break to tee up new guests and will return with fresh episodes in July. Enjoy the show! #EconomicDevelopment #EconDev #SiteSelection #SiteSelectors #FDI #ForeignDirectInvestment #BusinessRetention #CommunityChampions

The Architects of Prosperity: The Groundwork for Modern Development

In Part 10, the grand finale of our special mini-series, The Architects of Prosperity, we pull the camera all the way back to look at the entire 300-year tapestry of global economic development. The genesis of modern economic growth is not a clean, straight line from the steam engine to the smartphone—it is a messy, violent, and deeply contingent evolution of statecraft, ideas, and institutions. This episode explores how the grand macroeconomic strategies of warring empires were eventually downloaded directly to the local zip code. We unpack how early state-building, catastrophic financial bubbles, and the clash between free trade and nationalist survival birthed the exact toolkit used by modern site selectors today, proving that modern development economics is just the academic rediscovery of what 19th-century architects learned the hard way. In This Episode, We Cover: * The Genesis of Modern Finance: We look at the absolute power of early mercantilism and how the catastrophic Mississippi and South Sea Bubbles of 1720 forced nations to figure out sovereign debt, granting the British state the ultimate competitive advantage. * The Enabling State: The clash between the British gospel of laissez-faire free trade and the challenger nations (the US, Germany, and Japan) who explicitly rejected it, using the iron fist of state survival to protect infant industries, build infrastructure, and engineer human capital. * The Birth of Smokestack Chasing: How the Great Depression, the New Deal, and the eventual retreat of federal industrial policy in the 1970s and 80s forced local mayors, counties, and EDCs to fight for capital on their own, localizing the mercantilist battlefield. * The Nobel-Winning Secret: We hit the "Nerd Section" to unpack the 2024 Nobel Prize in Economics, revealing the ultimate mathematical truth of our profession: why the success or failure of a region always comes down to the difference between extractive and inclusive institutions. #EconomicDevelopment #TheArchitectsOfProsperity #EconomicHistory #Institutions #NobelPrize2024 #SiteSelection #Podcast #SiteSelectorsArePeopleToo

The Architects of Prosperity: The Intellectual Reckoning

In Part 9 of our special mini-series, The Architects of Prosperity, we look at what happens when the unprecedented wealth of the Industrial Revolution collides with staggering, crushing poverty. By the late 1800s, the global capitalist machine was running at maximum capacity, but the internal contradictions of the 19th-century economic model were tearing society apart at the seams. This episode explores the intellectual reckoning that followed. We unpack how three brilliant, radically different thinkers—a radical philosopher, a fiercely conservative Chancellor, and an economic heretic—diagnosed the structural diseases of global capitalism and wrote the foundational DNA for the entire 20th century. In This Episode, We Cover: * The Socialist Earthquake: We strip away Cold War rhetoric to examine Karl Marx’s purely mathematical critique of capitalism, the "extraction of surplus value," and his chilling prediction that the system was structurally doomed to eat its own tail. * The Pragmatic Pivot: How Otto von Bismarck, a fiercely conservative Prussian nationalist, invented the modern welfare state—not out of benevolence, but as a calculated state bribe to crush a socialist revolution and keep the German military-industrial complex running. * The Imperial Bailout: John A. Hobson's heretical critique that exposed 19th-century global imperialism as a desperate, violent corporate bailout driven by domestic inequality, "oversaving," and toxic jingoistic propaganda. * The Modern Legacy: How these 150-year-old theories still dictate modern economic development, from capital-labor tensions in incentive negotiations to why social safety nets are economic infrastructure, and how underconsumption mirrors the dangerous hollowing out of today's middle class. #EconomicDevelopment #TheArchitectsOfProsperity #KarlMarx #Bismarck #EconomicHistory #WealthInequality #Podcast #SiteSelectorsArePeopleToo

The Architects of Prosperity: The Colonial Model

In Part 8 of our special mini-series, The Architects of Prosperity, we look at what happens when fully industrialized nations run out of room to grow at home. Once the factories are built, the railroads are laid, and the workforces are trained, the great industrial machines of the 19th century needed two things to survive: an endless supply of cheap raw materials, and massive new markets to buy their surplus goods. This episode explores the dark, outward turn of economic development: The Colonial Model. We unpack how the newly industrialized, hyper-connected powers (like Britain, France, Germany, and later Japan) looked across the oceans and collided on the global stage, using their state power to carve up the world into extractive resource hubs and captive consumer markets. In This Episode, We Cover: * The Outward Turn: Why the incredible success of domestic industrialization and massive economies of scale mathematically forced nations to seek out foreign resources and new consumer bases. * Extractive vs. Inclusive: How the great powers set up purely extractive institutions in the Global South—mining copper, harvesting rubber, and growing cotton—to feed the factories back home. * The Captive Market: How colonial powers intentionally de-industrialized their territories (like the intentional destruction of India's textile industry) to force colonies to buy finished goods exclusively from the empire. * The Global Collision: The scramble for territory that redrew the map of the world and set the stage for the geopolitical and economic power dynamics we are still untangling today. * The Modern Legacy: How the historical scars of the Colonial Model continue to impact global supply chains, international trade negotiations, and emerging market development in the 21st century. #EconomicDevelopment #TheArchitectsOfProsperity #ColonialModel #EconomicHistory #GlobalSupplyChains #IndustrialRevolution #Podcast #SiteSelectorsArePeopleToo