Episode 58: Can you vacate a stipulation of settlement that you entered into in Housing Court if you later regret making the deal?
Description: Can you vacate a stipulation of settlement that you entered into in Housing Court if you later regret making the deal?
A court can undo/vacate a stipulation of settlement:
• to promote justice and prevent wrong. Foote v. Adams, 232 AD 60 [2d Dept 1931]
• when the stipulation of settlement is unjust or harsh, even when fully understood and authorized. Bond v Bond, 260 AD 781, 782 [1940].
• if a stipulation rested on an assumption, which was subsequently proven false. Horodeckyi v Horodniak, 9 AD2d 732 [1st Dept 1959].
• if a stipulation runs contrary to public policy, it may also be vacated. In Re Willie L.C., 65 AD3d 683 [2d Dept 2009].
• in the Rent Stabilization context, where a tenant makes a decision to give up a forever home for not a lot of benefit. 45-48 47th St. Corp. v Murphy, 45 Misc.3d 23 [Appellate Term 2d Dept 2014].
• in the Rent Stabilized context, where a tenant agrees to something that violated Rent Stabilization, such as the tenant agreeing to pay an illegally high rent. Samson Management, LLC v. Cordero, 62 Misc 3d 129(A) [Appellate Term 2018].
• or in the free- market context, where it turns out that the apartment might be Rent Stabilized. 270 Glenmore Ave., LLC v Blondet, 55 Misc 3d 133(A) [Appellate Term 2d Dept 2017].
Links:
• Learn to Live Better, website [https://tenantlearningplatform.com/blog/]
• Today’s Case: Clarke v. Haliman, 2025 WL 4036703 [NYC Civ Ct, Bronx Cty 2025] [https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2974&context=housing_court_all]
• New York State Unified Court System 2025 Annual Report [\\STARSHIP\vol4\docs\9_s55I\NYS unified court system 2025 annual report]
• NYC Office of Civil Justice FY25 Annual Report [https://www.nyc.gov/assets/hra/downloads/pdf/services/civiljustice/OCJ_Annual_Report_2025.pdf]
• Suggest future topics at questions@tenantlearningplatform.com [questions@tenantlearningplatform.com]
Attribution:
Music licensed through Soundstripe. Code: MJ4F8RUB1P9WUDKU
Comentarios
0Sé la primera persona en comentar
¡Regístrate ahora y únete a la comunidad de Tenant Law Podcast!