74 Egg Cream Milk Stout - Other Half Brewing Co.

74 Egg Cream Milk Stout - Other Half Brewing Co.

This week, Brian stands inside Other Half Buffalo at Seneca One Tower, looks at a tap list dominated by 20 hazy IPAs and three fruited sours, and orders... a milk stout. Reaching past the hops, Brian treats himself to Egg Cream Milk Stout that trades the tropical fruit notes for a nostalgic trip down a New York City soda fountain lane. THE FEATURED POUR * Brewery: Other Half Brewing Co. (Buffalo, NY) * Beer: Egg Cream Milk Stout * Style: Milk Stout * ABV: 6.0% * Brian’s Verdict: An absolute breakout hit amidst a sea of haze. Pours with big, decadent aromas of milk chocolate, sugar, and vanilla. Despite the rich scent, it remains incredibly light-bodied and smooth rather than cloyingly sugary. It lands right up front with massive notes of chocolate syrup, vanilla, and coffee with cream, finishing with a delicate hint of roasted malt in the background. Highly approachable and dangerously drinkable. DINER LORE & TAPROOM CONFUSION When Brian asked the bartender at Seneca One Tower what exactly an "egg cream" was, the bartender guessed it tasted like a Cadbury Cream Egg. Close, but no cigar! As Brian cleared up after doing some homework, a classic New York City egg cream is a historic soda fountain staple popularized in Jewish immigrant communities in the late 19th century. Made from seltzer, milk, and chocolate syrup, the drink famously contains neither eggs nor cream. Other Half and Junior's captured that frothy, nostalgic magic perfectly by infusing this 6.0% stout with real cocoa nibs and vanilla bean. WHERE TO FIND IT While the taproom board is heavily stacked with IPAs (including a stellar recent collaboration with Prison City), this sweet lone soldier is a must-try. It should still be flowing on draft at the Buffalo taproom, and Brian notes that you can likely still order cans shipped directly to your door through Other Half's website. CONNECT WITH THE LEAGUE * Website: BuffaloBeerLeague.com [https://buffalobeerleague.com/] — Look for the email sign-up on the right rail to join our forthcoming weekly newsletter! * Hotline: 716-486-BEER (2337) — Have you ever had a real NYC egg cream? Call the line and tell us how the beer compares! * Email: Brian@BuffaloBeerLeague.com * Socials: @BuffaloBeerLeague (IG/Untappd/Threads) | @BuffBeerLeague (X) * Dedicated Podcast IG: @thebestbeeridrankthisweek — We are marching toward 100 episodes! Follow along as we upload the archives. ---------------------------------------- Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy [https://acast.com/privacy] for more information.

73 Crazy Child - BriarBrothers Brewing Company

After another small hiatus where real life got in the way, Brian is back inside the shadow of the historic Buffalo silos to shake off the rust. This week, he is returning to BriarBrothers Brewing Company at 50 Elk Street to spotlight a brand-new release that has the local lager crowd talking: Crazy Child Vienna Lager. THE FEATURED POUR * Brewery: BriarBrothers Brewing Company (The Silos at Elk Street) * Beer: Crazy Child * Style: Vienna Lager * ABV: 5.2% * Brian’s Verdict: A brilliant execution of a classic style. Right in the 5.2% ABV wheelhouse, it pours a vibrant copper with a bright, billowy foam head. It is light-bodied, crisp, and exceptionally refreshing, delivering clean notes of toasted bread, chocolate malt, and a subtle kiss of vanilla, caramel, and molasses. It is a true "one-more-sip" kind of pint. WHY IT MATTERS BriarBrothers continues to prove that they are absolute masters of the "clear beer" movement. Following up on the massive success of their Reflections rice lager, Crazy Child was brought to life because the crew wanted a traditional style they could just sit back and slowly enjoy. The Story Behind the Mix-Pack: Brian actually stumbled onto this beer by accident. While at the taproom building a custom mix-pack, the staff let him know that pushing his order to an even eight cans unlocked a sweet discount. Looking to round things out alongside some Warpath Lager, he grabbed a single can of Crazy Child on a whim because his buddy Jesse—the ultimate BriarBrothers disciple—had been raving about it. Brian's only regret? He didn't buy a whole case. Oh, and if the Untapped description sounds like a lyrical riddle ("Where's the fire? What's the hurry about... you can get exactly what you want..."), Brian confesses he missed the reference at first, but it's a clever nod to Billy Joel’s classic track, "Vienna." --- CONNECT WITH THE LEAGUE * Website: BuffaloBeerLeague.com [https://buffalobeerleague.com/] * Hotline: 716-486-BEER (2337) — Call the answering service and leave us your review of Crazy Child! * Email: Brian@BuffaloBeerLeague.com * Main Socials: @BuffaloBeerLeague (IG/Untappd/Threads) | @BuffBeerLeague (X) * NEW Podcast Instagram: @thebestbeeridrankthisweek — Give the new page a follow as Brian back-catalogs the first 75+ episodes! ---------------------------------------- Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy [https://acast.com/privacy] for more information.

72 Hayburner - Big Ditch Brewing Company

THE WARM BLANKET OF BUFFALO BEER: BIG DITCH HAYBURNER This week, Brian slows down to pay tribute to a true "Mount Rushmore" beer of the Western New York craft scene. While the quest for the newest, haziest, or rarest brew never ends, sometimes the best beer you drank is the one that’s been a reliable friend for years. We’re talking about the flagship of Big Ditch Brewing Company: Hayburner. THE FEATURED POUR * Brewery: Big Ditch Brewing Company (Buffalo & Lockport, NY) * * Beer: Hayburner * Style: American IPA * ABV: 7.2% * Brian’s Verdict: A luscious, citrusy classic that remains as consistent today as it was years ago. It’s packed with notes of orange, melon, and grapefruit, balanced by a soft malt base and a firm, earthy bitterness on the finish. It’s "Buffalo’s IPA" for a reason—it’s the warm blanket of local beer. WHY IT MATTERS Brian chose Hayburner this week because of a simple, memorable night putting together furniture with his wife. Amidst the chaos of sleeper sofas and ottoman assembly, he cracked open a Burner Relief Kit—a budget-friendly four-pack featuring two cans of Hayburner and two cans of Dayburner for just $8.99. The "Same Beer Twice" Philosophy: As a wise man once told Brian, "It doesn’t hurt to drink the same beer twice." In a world where we are constantly "chasing the new," we often overlook the flagships that built the scene. Hayburner is the beer you can find everywhere—from the high-end taprooms to your neighborhood dive bar—and it never fails to deliver. It’s a testament to the technical skill of Matt Kahn, Corey Catalano, and the entire Big Ditch team. DEEP DIVE INTO THE ARCHIVES If you want to know everything there is to know about this beer, check out the WNY Brews archives. Brian and Scott hosted a "Deep Dive" episode with Matt and Corey specifically about Hayburner. It covers everything from the Idaho 7 and Falconer’s Flight hop profile to the history of how this beer became a Buffalo staple. CONNECT WITH THE LEAGUE * Website: BuffaloBeerLeague.com [https://BuffaloBeerLeague.com] * Hotline: 716-486-BEER (2337) — Call in and tell us your favorite "flagship" Buffalo beer! * Email: Brian@BuffaloBeerLeague.com * Socials: @BuffaloBeerLeague (IG/Untappd/Threads) | @BuffBeerLeague (X) * Podcast: New episodes of The Best Beer I Drank This Week drop every Tuesday! ---------------------------------------- Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy [https://acast.com/privacy] for more information.

71 Billy's Smoking Jacket - Spotted Octopus & Brazen Brewing

This week, Brian visited a downtown Buffalo favorite for a milestone celebration and walked away with a new appreciation for a often-divisive style. We’re talking about Billy’s Smoking Jacket, a collaboration between Spotted Octopus Brewing and Brazen Brewing. THE FEATURED POUR * Brewery: Spotted Octopus Brewing (Buffalo, NY) & Brazen Brewing (Lancaster, NY) * Beer: Billy’s Smoking Jacket * Style: Smoked Spring Bock (Maibock) * ABV: 6.2% * Brian’s Verdict: This beer is proof that "sessionable smoke" isn't a myth. It’s light, smooth, and incredibly approachable. While many smoked beers (Rauchbiers) can feel like drinking liquid campfire, this one uses smoked malt as a subtle undertone that props up the doughy, crisp notes of the Maibock base. It’s the perfect "patio furniture" beer for a Buffalo spring. HAPPY 4TH ANNIVERSARY, SPOTTED OCTOPUS! Brian stopped in during the 4th Anniversary bash for Dom, Ken, and the crew. If you haven't been to their spot on Edward Street (right near the corner of Franklin and Allen), you’re missing out on one of the most creative taplists in the city. Pro Tip: Brian heard from the staff that Billy’s Smoking Jacket is moving fast. If you want to try this unique collab, get down to the Spotted Octopus taproom sooner rather than later. While you're there, Brian also recommends: * Call the Kraken: Their flagship 6.9% Hazy IPA. * Creations: A crisp, 4.8% Czech-style Amber Lager. THE SMOKE DEBATE Smoked beers are notoriously polarizing—brewers like Rudy Watkins (now at Brickyard) have often noted they’d brew more if the public bought them more consistently! Brian challenges you to give this one a shot even if you’re a "smoke skeptic." CONNECT WITH THE LEAGUE * Website: BuffaloBeerLeague.com [https://buffalobeerleague.com/] * Hotline: 716-486-BEER (2337) — Call and tell us: Are you Team Smoke or does it taste like a campfire? * Email: Brian@BuffaloBeerLeague.com * Socials: @BuffaloBeerLeague (IG/Untappd/Threads) | @BuffBeerLeague (X) * Recap: Check out our other special episode this week recapping the CollaBEERation 6 festival! ---------------------------------------- Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy [https://acast.com/privacy] for more information.

70 CollaBEERation Recap

This week, Brian isn't just picking one beer—he’s recapping the entire CollaBEERation 6 experience. This past Saturday, April 25, 2026, the Buffalo beer community descended upon The Powerhouse in Larkinville for the ultimate showcase of Western New York’s creative brewing spirit. THE CHAMPIONS & FAN FAVORITES The competition was fierce this year, with nearly 40 collaborative brews vying for the coveted Buffalo Beer Geeks Championship Belt. * 1st Place (The Winner): Eli Fish Brewing – Diddy Kong: The Reckoning * Style: Banana Root Beer Seltzer * Brian’s Take: This blew the roof off the place. It’s root beer forward with a smooth banana finish that tastes exactly like those old-school root beer barrel hard candies. A rare win for a non-beer/non-sour! * 2nd Place: Quentin (Collaboration beer) * 3rd Place (Tie): * BriarBrothers Brewing – Bananas Among Us (Banana Maple Nut Brown Ale) * Mountain Roads Brewing – Double Jump Juice (Double Dry Hopped IPA) BRIAN’S HIGHLIGHT REEL * The "Throwback" Play: Pod City Beer Labs (Pizza Plant) set up a full water-pong table for their Beer Pong Pils. In a sea of wild adjuncts, this "beer that tastes like beer" was the perfect refreshing palate cleanser. Brian admits to going back 7 or 8 times before the keg finally kicked! * The Sabres Spark: BriarBrothers tapped Warpath Lager, their new Sabres-themed brew. Brian credits this beer for the Sabres' massive 6-1 win over the Bruins in Game 4 of the playoffs the very next day. * Most Visually Stunning: New York Beer Project brought back the "glitter beer" with Rainbow Road Gummy Glitter, a pineapple blonde ale that looked incredible under the Powerhouse’s floor-to-ceiling windows. * The Cask Comeback: Hamburg Brewing & Flying Bison teamed up for a re-brew of the legendary Brindle Porter. Seeing a cask at a festival always warms Brian's heart, and the version aged on rum chips and coconut was a standout. SPECIAL SHOUT-OUTS A huge thank you to the organizers: Paul Marco, Joe Yeager, and Eric Coleman (Beer by Coleman). The VIP section was the best it’s ever been, featuring incredible guest pours like Human Robot’s 666 (a West Coast Pilsner collab with Widowmaker). CONNECT WITH THE LEAGUE * Website: BuffaloBeerLeague.com [https://buffalobeerleague.com/] * Hotline: 716-486-BEER (2337) — Call us with your favorite collab from the fest! * Watch: Look for full video recaps and interviews on the WNY Brews YouTube channel soon. * Bonus Episode: Don't miss this week's other episode featuring Spotted Octopus – Billy’s Smoking Jacket (Smoked Maibock). ---------------------------------------- Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy [https://acast.com/privacy] for more information.