Case Files Ep. 2 | Major Developments, Missing Persons & Summer Tragedies

Case Files Ep. 2 | Major Developments, Missing Persons & Summer Tragedies

The files are open once again. This week we’re discussing major developments in the Nancy Guthrie investigation, heartbreaking summer tragedies, cases making headlines across the Carolinas, and the stories happening beyond the scoreboard. From missing persons to breaking developments, these are the cases everyone is talking about. Which story has stayed with you the most? #WhatsDoneInTheDark #CaseFiles #TrueCrime #MissingPersons #CrimeNews #NancyGuthrie #JaveayahHarris #XavierWells #MarleyKinney #TrueCrimeCommunity

The Truth About Bunny Man Bridge | Fact, Folklore & Fear

For more than 50 years, Bunny Man Bridge has been surrounded by terrifying stories, mysterious sightings, and one urban legend that refuses to die. But where did the legend really begin? In this episode of What’s Done in the Dark, we’re separating fact from folklore as we uncover the documented events that inspired one of America’s most famous urban legends. Join me as we explore the real history behind Bunny Man Bridge, the mysterious encounters of 1970, and why this legend continues to haunt imaginations decades later.

Shane Stewart & Sally McNelly | A Fourth of July Mystery

In July 1988, teenagers Shane Stewart and Sally McNelly disappeared after spending the Fourth of July together in San Angelo, Texas. The next morning, their abandoned car was discovered with the keys still inside. Months later, investigators made a heartbreaking discovery, launching a case filled with unanswered questions, rumors, and the fear surrounding the Satanic Panic of the late 1980s. More than three decades later, their murders remain unsolved. In this episode, we separate fact from fiction and revisit one of Texas’ most haunting unsolved cases.

The Gray Man of Pawleys Island | The Ghost Before the Storm

For generations, people have claimed to see a mysterious figure walking the beaches of Pawleys Island just before major hurricanes strike. Known simply as the Gray Man, this legendary apparition has become one of South Carolina’s most enduring ghost stories. Witnesses say seeing him is more than just unsettling—it may be a warning that a storm is on the way. In this episode of What’s Done in the Dark, we explore the history behind the legend, the eyewitness accounts that have kept it alive for nearly two centuries, and why so many people still believe the Gray Man walks the shoreline today.

She Did Everything Right | The Heartbreaking Murder of Johnia Berry

In December 2004, Johnia Berry was brutally attacked inside her Knoxville apartment in a case that devastated her family and left investigators searching for answers for years. In this episode, we explore Johnia’s life, the shocking attack, the twists and turns of the investigation, the DNA evidence that finally broke the case open, and how her family’s determination helped create lasting change through the Johnia Berry Law. This is a story of heartbreak, resilience, and a promise that justice would never stop being pursued. ⚠️ Listener discretion is advised. This episode contains discussions of violence, murder, and graphic injuries.