Bloody Mary

Swamp Witches

It's not easy being green... or living in Florida. This week Maddie and Mackenzie discuss urban legends of swamp witches! Listen to the end to hear the sisters debate what kind of witches they would classify their favorite famous women (Cher, Miss Piggy, Rupaul, etc.) as.

The NASA Gargoyle

In case you needed one more reason to not trust the government we present to you: the NASA Gargoyle! This week Maddie and Mackenzie try to uncover the truth of this myserious legend. Is he stone come to life? Mothman's redneck cousin? A misunderstood theater kid? Listen to find out!

The Loch Ness Monster

You named our 50th episode after the Loch Ness Monster????? My Cryptid's Keeper is back with a heavy hitter! These week the sisters dive into the mysterious depths of the Loch Ness and ask important questions like: why are there ancient runes depicting a mysterious sea creature nearby the lake? Can we really believe the famous 1934 photograph showing Nessie breaching the surface? Will Mackenzie successfully pull off a Scottish accent? Listen to find out!

The Yara Ma

Yet another thing in Australia that's trying to kill you... This week Maddie and Mackenzie head down under to explore the legend of the Yara Ma; an Australian bloodsucker who likes to wait under trees before sucking blood from people's feet. Stick around to the end to hear the sisters debate which vampire universes they stand a chance of surviving.

Bloody Mary

Bloody Mary... Bloody Mary... Bloody... jk we're not doing the rest it's too scary. This week Maddie and Mackenzie dive into the queen of all urban legends: Bloody Mary! The sisters cover three different historical women who may have inspired this infamous sleepover game and the different regional variations that have kept her legend alive for centuries. Listen to the end to hear some spooky travel tips!