78: Ice Cream Flavors

78: Ice Cream Flavors

Caleb and Jay are scooping into their all-time favorite ice cream flavors, from Michigan staples and childhood classics to Disney treats and overloaded cookie dough creations. Along the way, they revisit local ice cream shops and family memories all packed into a waffle cone. They also hear from listeners with favorites ranging from big brand names to local favorites. Grab a cone, pick your top five, and settle in for a very cool episode.

77: Summer Songs

Summer is here, and we’re building the ultimate warm-weather soundtrack. This week, Caleb and Jay count down their favorite summer songs, from nostalgic windows-down jams to sunny feel-good tracks, late-night beach vibes, and songs that instantly transport you to a time, place, or mood. Jay’s list even takes a little unexpected turn, unfolding almost like a summer love story told through five different songs. Meanwhile, Caleb's list brings it's own mix of breezy, feel-good vibes that capture the season in a totally different way. Whether your summer song is a classic, a guilty pleasure, a road trip anthem, or something totally unexpected, throw it on and hang out with us. Listen to the playlist here: Apple Music Playlist⁠ [https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/disney-songs/pl.u-xlyNX9ktvJqJe]

76: Disney Songs

Jay and Caleb are ranking their favorite Disney songs of all time, with anything under the Disney umbrella fair game (animated classics, Pixar, Star Wars, theme parks, and beyond). From emotional showstoppers to nostalgic childhood favorites, the guys make their picks, compare surprises, read listener submissions and celebrate the songs that still get stuck in their heads years later. Apple Music Playlist [https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/disney-songs/pl.u-xlyNX9ktvJqJe]

75: Impactful American Moments

America just turned 250, and Caleb and Jay are settling the greatest American moments the only way they know how: a Top 5 showdown. Jay brings founding milestones, pop culture, and tech; Caleb counters with the political heavy-hitters. They agree on exactly one pick, go to war over number one, and nearly invent a new national holiday. What made your list?

74: World Cup Players

The 2026 FIFA World Cup is here — and it's happening right in our backyard. Jay and Caleb break down their top five players to watch at this summer's tournament, counting down from five to one before comparing lists and debating where they agree, where they don't, and who got left off. With Mbappé chasing the all-time scoring record, Messi delivering a first-career hat trick in game one, Kane tying an England record that's stood since 1990, Haaland finally making his World Cup debut, and Folarin Balogun becoming America's breakout star on home soil — there's no shortage of ammunition for the Hi-Five treatment. Leave us your top five World Cup players at speakpipe.com/thehifivepodcast [http://speakpipe.com/thehifivepodcast].