Things That Should Be Illegal (But Somehow Aren't)

Generational Switch Up

This week on Toast That! We’re flipping the script and taking a stroll down memory lane! We’re talking about what this generation thinks is tough — and comparing it to the wild, wonderful, and sometimes ridiculous things we went through growing up. From payphones and dial-up internet to “back in my day” stories that make us sound ancient, it’s all in good fun. Expect plenty of laughs, sibling banter, and a little bit of “wow, we really survived that?” energy. This episode wraps up Season 1 of Toast That! 🥂 But don’t worry — we’re not going far. We’ve got three special holiday episodes coming your way for Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas. Then we’ll be back and better than ever in January 2026 for Season 2! So grab your glass, raise a toast, and as always… TOAST THAT!

Things That Should Be Illegal (But Somehow Aren't)

Ever looked around and thought, “Wait…how is THAT legal?” Yeah, us too. In this episode, your favorite sibling trio dives into all the everyday annoyances, quirks, and questionable habits that somehow slipped past lawmakers. From people who blast their phone on speaker in public, to drivers who don’t use turn signals (seriously, why??), we’re making a list of all the things that should land you in lifestyle jail. 🚔 Expect:     •    Unnecessary levels of dramatics 🕺     •    Sibling debates that go from “meh” to “mayhem” in seconds     •    A few confessions about habits we might be guilty of ourselves 👀 It’s all lighthearted, all ridiculous, and all sibling-approved. So buckle up—this episode is basically therapy for everyone who’s ever muttered “that should be illegal” under their breath.

Sibling Hot Seat

In this episode of Toast That, we’re cranking up the heat with a game we like to call Sibling Hot Seat! 🔥 Each of us came up with a bunch of questions, tossed them into a bowl, and now… we’re putting each other on the spot. The catch? We don’t know what questions the others wrote. From funny throwbacks to surprising confessions, no topic is off-limits when the questions are pulled at random. It’s unpredictable, it’s raw, and it’s a whole lot of sibling fun. Will we spill the tea, dodge the tough ones, or roast each other like only siblings can? You’ll have to listen to find out!

First-Day Feels & School Days We’ll Never Forget

The first day of school wasn’t just about new pencils and shiny backpacks—it was the start of a whole new chapter. In this episode of Toast That, we’re taking a trip down memory lane to relive those first-day jitters and all the school-day moments that stuck with us. From the excitement of fresh supplies to the nerves of finding your classroom, we share the funny, awkward, and unforgettable stories that made school such a big part of our lives. And of course, the sibling banter keeps it lively—because what’s a memory without a few laughs along the way?

Things That Terrified Us

Welcome back to Toast That—the sibling podcast where nothing’s off the table!  In this episode, we’re diving into the things that absolutely terrified us as kids (and let’s be real… some of them still get us as adults ). From childhood fears that kept us up at night to the grown-up anxieties we deal with now, we’re sharing it all with humor, honesty, and a sibling twist. Expect laughs, a few “oh no, me too!” moments, and maybe even some cringe-worthy confessions you can totally relate to. So grab your favorite drink, get cozy, and toast with us as we laugh about the things that spooked us then—and still give us the creeps today. What terrified you as a kid (or still does now)? Share your story with us—we’d love to hear it!