The Outlaw Who Refused To Stay Dead: The Elmer McCurdy Story

The Gates of Hell- New Jersey's Tunnel to the Underworld

On this weeks episode we are talking about the Gates of Hell in Clifton  New Jersey.  This is a real creepy locaion, mixed with local folklore, questionable history, and people who swear they experienced something they can't explain.  Be sure to check out all our other episodes that are available wherever you listen podcast! Support the show [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/twoscaredycats] Thanks for listening and  follow us on Instagram and YouTube @twoscaredycatspodcast

Dack: The Adirondack Bigfoot Mystery

On this episode of the podcast we are talking about how in 2024 a man going by the name Snake the Bigfoot Hunter supposedly found a dead Bigfoot body in New York's Adirondack Mountains.  The body he claims was eight feet tall and weighed in at 300 pounds. He then had the whole body taxidermied and ended up putting it on display at the New York Worlds Fair.  Join us as we talk abut this crazy story and other strange, unusual and paranormal things. Support the show [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/twoscaredycats] Thanks for listening and  follow us on Instagram and YouTube @twoscaredycatspodcast

"The week something was walking through Ohio"

In this weeks episode of the Two Scaredy Cats, we dive into a mystery from early 2026 from the foothills of Ohio.  Multiple witness reported seeing giant footprints and a dark, hair covered figure moving thru the woods- that is until it vanished without a trace.  Was this a hoax, a misidentification, or something more sinister lurking in the Appalachian nigh?  Support the show [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/twoscaredycats] Thanks for listening and  follow us on Instagram and YouTube @twoscaredycatspodcast

The Outlaw Who Refused To Stay Dead: The Elmer McCurdy Story

Imagine walking into a haunted house expecting to see fake skeletons, rubber monsters, and cheap jump scares.......  Only to discover that of the corpses/ dummy hanging from the ceiling is completely real! Elmer McCurdy's story is one of the strangest true crime/paranormal tales in American history because it combines train robbery, mummification, carnival sideshows, mistaken ideas and a corpse hanging in a fun house for decades. Join us on the newest episode of the Two Scaredy Cats Podcast! Support the show [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/twoscaredycats] Thanks for listening and  follow us on Instagram and YouTube @twoscaredycatspodcast

The Flesh Feast of Gatlinburg

Deep in the Smokey Mountains near Gatlinburg Tennessee, locals whisper about a local family so terrifying that even today people refuse to say their name after dark...  The Craft Family Led by Simon Craft a Confederate officer, the family allegedly survived a brutal winter by murdering and eating stranded guest trapped inside their mountain mansion.  But according to legend, the cannibalism didn't stop there! Were the Craft family simply desperate survivors.....or did something evil take root inside the family?  Make sure to listen to one of the darkest Appalachian legends ever told! Support the show [https://www.buymeacoffee.com/twoscaredycats] Thanks for listening and  follow us on Instagram and YouTube @twoscaredycatspodcast