Episode 23: Schelling's Early Philosophy of Nature

Episode 23: Schelling's Early Philosophy of Nature

In this episode, Anatarah, Bile, and Crane discuss the introduction to Schelling’s 1797 Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature and the introduction to Schelling’s 1799 First Outline. Working up to Schelling’s ambitious declaration that philosophy is a “natural history of our mind,” the hosts discuss some of the fundamental concepts—like force, equilibrium, and organism—in Schelling’s philosophy of nature, the difference between Schelling’s earlier philosophy of nature and his “identity system,” and the relationship between Schelling’s project and those of his contemporaries in philosophy and natural science. In conclusion, we debate whether and, if so, how Schelling’s early philosophy of nature might provide us with a basis for a critical theory of nature and natural science. Recommend readings: * Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature as Introduction to the Study of This Science, 1797. Cambridge University Press, 2001. * First Outline of a System of the Philosophy of Nature. State University of New York Press, 2004. * The Schelling Reader. 1st ed. Bloomsbury Academic, 2020. * The Palgrave Schelling Handbook. Palgrave Handbooks in German Idealism. Palgrave Macmillan, 2026.

Episode 22: Everybody Female

Imogen, Helen, and Nora kvetch about "The Logic of Gender" from Endnotes 3. Topics include whether capital is a totality (it is), whether Butler reduces gender to the value-form (they don't), and whether this article gets into enough detail regarding the history of the family (absolutely not.) Texts: The Logic of Gender in Endnotes Vol 3: https://www.endnotes.org.uk/issues/issue-3/endnotes-the-logic-of-gender [https://www.endnotes.org.uk/issues/issue-3/endnotes-the-logic-of-gender]

Episode 21: A Critical Theory of Christianity? (Ft. Julian Assele)

In this episode, Crane is joined by Julian Assele to discuss Max Horkheimer’s long-running critical engagement with contemporary Neo-Thomism, the history of Catholic thought, and the social content of theological controversies dating back to the early Christian church. Starting from Horkheimer’s 1930s short-form polemics on the church and fascism, the hosts turn to his extensive criticism of Neo-Thomism in “Conflicting Panaceas” from Eclipse of Reason (1947)—as well as the earlier version of the text, the unpublished “The Revival of Dogmatism” (1943)—and conclude with a critical look at the late Horkheimer’s neo-conservative instrumentalization of religion in “Theism and Atheism” (1963), posing the question: what might a “critical theory of religion” look like today? Texts: “On the Concept of God” [or: “Thoughts on Religion”] (1935): https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-horkheimers-fragments [https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-horkheimers-fragments] “On Theodor Haecker’s Der Christ und die Geschichte [The Christian and History]” (1936): https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-the-materialist-as-polemicist [https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-the-materialist-as-polemicist] “The Revival of Dogmatism” (1943): https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-society-and-reason-1944 [https://jamescrane.substack.com/p/collection-society-and-reason-1944] “Conflicting Panaceas,” in Eclipse of Reason (1947) “Theism and Atheism” (1963), in Critique of Instrumental Reason (1974) Follow Julian on Substack https://substack.com/@julesnotes [https://substack.com/@julesnotes] If you want to support the show donate to us on Patreon [https://www.patreon.com/c/crittheoryworkgroup] Visit our website for writing and updates [https://ctwgwebsite.github.io/] Follow our socials: Twitter [https://x.com/crit_theory_grp] Bluesky [https://bsky.app/profile/crittheoryworkgrp.bsky.social] Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/criticaltheoryworkinggroup]

Episode 20: Inside the Manesar Labor Movement

Mac and Re are joined by Shreya from the Center for Struggling Trade Unions (CSTU) to discuss the recent workers strikes in various industries of North India. Since March, workers in the automobile and garment industry were joined by domestic service workers to mobilize against low wages, unpaid overtime and deteriorating labor conditions. We also discuss the history of the workers mobilization in North India and raise some questions of the problems of labor organizing today. History of the Manesar automobile workers struggle: https://class-notes.org/2025/06/04/maruti-story-book/ [https://class-notes.org/2025/06/04/maruti-story-book/] If you want to support the show donate to us on Patreon [https://www.patreon.com/c/crittheoryworkgroup] Visit our website for writing and updates [https://ctwgwebsite.github.io/] Follow our socials: Twitter [https://x.com/crit_theory_grp] Bluesky [https://bsky.app/profile/crittheoryworkgrp.bsky.social] Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/criticaltheoryworkinggroup]

Episode 19: Peter Damerow and the Ontogeny of Thinking

Anatarah, Mac, and Re return once more to the realm of science studies. This time it is to discuss the indomitable Peter Damerow and the Max Planck history of science’s program of historical epistemology via their book Abstraction and Representation: Essays on the Cultural Evolution of Thinking. We discuss the usage and development of (reflective) abstractions, the similarities between Piaget and Hegel, and finally the genesis of the number concept. Along the way, we discuss Damerow's theory of writing and language as well as his concept of historiogenesis. Recommend readings: The new Damerow translation by the Marxism & Science Journal The Creation of Numbers from Clay by McLaughlin & Schlaudt Eye of the Master by Pasquinelli Material Engagement Theory by Malafouris