Big Mac LOSES IT Over Yankees Collapse & Max Fried Injury Scare | The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle

Big Mac LOSES IT Over Yankees Collapse & Max Fried Injury Scare | The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees going 1-5 on the road trip, the offense completely disappearing, Anthony Volpe struggling again, and the huge concern surrounding Max Fried’s elbow injury scare. Plus, Subway Series hype, Mets chaos, Malik Nabers injury concerns, and Craig predicts the Jets are starting 2-0!

Volpe’s Return Puts Yankees Trust to the Test | Evan & Tiki

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a fascinating split in New York baseball, with Yankees fans uneasy about Anthony Volpe’s return while Mets fans rally around the arrival of A.J. Ewing. The Yankees’ shortstop situation becomes a test of whether Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman are truly operating differently this season. The discussion centers on why Jose Caballero should keep the job when healthy, what Volpe’s role should be moving forward, and how Ewing’s debut instantly injected energy into a struggling Mets season. From patient at bats to a fan base desperate for hope, Ewing gave the Mets something worth watching.

AJ Ewing's Great Mets Debut | Boomer & Gio

AJ Ewing had 3 walks, a stolen base and an RBI triple. Plus, David Stearns refuses to address Mendoza's future with the Mets.

Mets Face 100-Loss Pace & Jazz Chisholm Jr. Maturity Concerns | The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle

Carton considers a potential studio visit from Rich Robinson before examining the tragic career of Otis Redding and the "deal with the devil" music theory. They analyze the Mets' trajectory toward a 100-loss season and debate Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s maturity following a rough performance for the Yankees. The conversation also explores humorous personal habits like whistling on the toilet to avoid family stress and a lunch review of sandwiches from Faicco's. 01:04 - Rich Robinson Studio Visit 04:13 - Otis Redding History 08:14 - Mets Relevance Crisis 11:41 - Bathroom Hiding Habits 18:24 - Jazz Chisholm Maturity Debate

Jazz Chisholm’s Slow Start Is Becoming a Yankees Problem | Evan & Tiki

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Yankees’ four game losing streak and explain why the concern is not panic, but the offense suddenly going quiet. After another frustrating one run loss, they look at how a team with strong overall numbers can still feel vulnerable when key bats stop producing. The conversation focuses on Jazz Chisholm’s rough start, his 50 50 comments, and whether he is pressing in a lineup where he does not need to be the hero. Evan and Tiki also debate whether skipping the media after a bad night matters, why Austin Wells needs to wake up, and the strange handling of Jose Caballero’s finger injury.