He took a bullet to save the president | Wearing the Badge S2 E3
Former Secret Service Agent Tim McCarthy (no relation to host Garry McCarthy) joins Wearing the Badge with a story that puts him in an exceptionally small club: he took a bullet protecting President Ronald Reagan during the 1981 assassination attempt.
Tim breaks down what happened in those seconds outside the Washington Hilton—how training takes over, how the team moved the president, and what stays with you for life. Then he fast-forwards to the second act of his career: leaving the federal world, stepping into local policing leadership, and eventually serving as Orland Park Police Chief—where the job becomes unions, arbitration, politics, and the everyday realities of public safety.
00:00 Cold open: the coin flip, the shooting, and the images that stay
01:36 Welcome + “Are we related?”
02:48 Ireland roots, “Black and Tans,” and family stories
05:05 Name confusion + the other Tim McCarthy (MAP union)
06:25 NY politics + fear of crime + quality-of-life policing
09:52 Chicago justice politics + Cliff Lewis case discussion
12:56 Major Crimes Task Force + murder numbers and clearance rates
15:01 Tim’s background: South Side, Leo High, Illinois football
18:44 Joining the Secret Service + the entrance test + Chicago field work
24:59 Presidential detail: Carter to Reagan to Bush
26:39 The day Reagan was shot: advance, crowd scan, six shots
32:35 Recovery, the danger of a .22, and meeting Reagan in the hospital
37:17 Back to work, body armor, and the 9/11 suit story
40:36 Leaving DC + private sector detour + path to Orland Park chief
43:36 Recertifying, training requirements, and what’s “useful” in the field
46:21 SES management training + learning a union environment fast
49:32 Command decisions, community pressure, and the “why I was sent” moment
52:23 Union arbitration war story + sanctions and settlements
54:32 Fitness standards, buy-in, and culture shifts
56:33 Final thoughts: courage, service, and closing the episode
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices [https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices]