Rum Ration

Episode 49 - Sir Sam Hughes: Empire, Ego, and War

In this episode of The Rum Ration, hosts Colin Robinson and Rejoy Chatterjee tackle one of the most controversial, brilliant, infuriating, and undeniably influential figures in Canadian military history: Sir Sam Hughes. Teacher, newspaper editor, politician, militia fanatic, and unapologetic brawler, Hughes helped build the Canadian Expeditionary Force at breakneck speed in 1914, turning the wilderness of Valcartier into a military city in mere weeks and sending tens of thousands of volunteers overseas. His fierce belief in the “citizen-soldier” helped shape Canada’s wartime identity. But Hughes’s legacy is anything but simple. From his disastrous defence of the Ross Rifle and the infamous MacAdam shovel, to accusations of patronage, nepotism, and his bitter feud with Sir Arthur Currie, Hughes often proved as destructive as he was visionary. Was Sam Hughes a patriot, a madman, or both? This episode dives deep into the man who helped launch Canada’s army—and nearly tore it apart in the process.

Episode 48: What If Rommel Controlled the Panzers on D-Day

On the latest episode of The Rum Ration, Rejoy and Colin tackle one of military history’s most irresistible “what ifs”: what if Erwin Rommel had direct control of the German Panzer reserves on D-Day? Rather than drifting into fantasy, they ground the discussion in the hard realities of June 6, 1944: a fractured German command system, delayed decision-making, Allied air superiority, and the brutal geography of Normandy. The episode zeroes in on the British and Canadian sector around Caen and Juno, arguing that this was the likeliest place where an earlier, sharper German armoured response could have created a genuine crisis. Still, this is no cheap revisionism. Rejoy and Colin weigh Rommel’s instincts against the enormous strength and redundancy built into Overlord, and against the stubborn resistance of Allied troops already ashore. The conclusion is both sober and compelling: Rommel probably could not have repulsed the invasion, but he might have made Normandy even bloodier and more dangerous than it already was.

Episode 46 - Shot At Dawn: Canadians executed in WW1

In this episode of The Rum Ration, Rejoy and Colin explore one of the darkest and least understood chapters of Canada’s First World War: the 25 Canadian soldiers executed by their own side, “shot at dawn.” Through the story of Private Fortunat Auger of The Royal Montreal Regiment, we examine the brutal logic of military discipline in trench warfare and the impossible strain placed on ordinary volunteers. Auger was not a simple victim, nor a villain. He was a Montreal architect, an early volunteer, and a man who endured the horrors of Ypres and Festubert before repeatedly deserting the line. His execution in March 1916 became a warning to others, meant to preserve discipline in a citizen army under unbearable pressure. This episode looks beyond easy judgments to ask harder questions about fear, duty, morale, and how armies chose to enforce obedience. It is a sobering reminder that the war claimed lives in more ways than one.

Episode 47: Five in Fifteen - The Legend of Billy Bishop

On this episode of The Rum Ration, Rejoy and Colin take listeners into the life and legend of Billy Bishop, Canada’s most famous and most controversial First World War air ace. Beginning with his dramatic final patrol over the Western Front on 19 June 1918, the episode explores both the astonishing exploits that made Bishop a national hero and the lingering questions that still surround his record. From his unruly youth in Owen Sound and his gift for marksmanship to his rise in the Royal Flying Corps and Royal Air Force, Bishop emerges as a bold, complex, and deeply individualistic figure. The episode also examines the machines and tactics that shaped aerial combat, especially Bishop’s “lone wolf” style of flying, which brought spectacular success but also fuels debate among historians. Rather than offering simple hero worship or easy dismissal, Rejoy and Colin tackle the harder question: how should we understand Billy Bishop today?

Episode 45 - The Victoria Cross and the Price of Valour

On this episode of The Rum Ration, Rejoy and Colin take on one of the most revered and sobering subjects in British and Commonwealth military history: the Victoria Cross. Beginning with the astonishing story of Charles Upham, the only combat soldier to receive both a Victoria Cross and Bar in the same war, they explore what the VC is, why it was revolutionary, and why it still carries such weight. The episode traces the medal’s origins in the Crimean War, its place as an all-ranks award for conspicuous valour, and the myths and meaning wrapped up in its bronze cross. Along the way, they highlight Canadian recipients, including Alexander Roberts Dunn, William Hall, Smokey Smith, and Robert Hampton Gray, before, of course, coming home to The Royal Montreal Regiment’s own VC heroes: Francis Scrimger and George Burdon McKean. It is ultimately an episode about courage, sacrifice, and the human choices made under the worst imaginable pressure.