33. "The Psychology of the Bet" (ep. 7 of the series "101 VC Core Principles")
Welcome to episode number seven of our series called “One O One VENTURE CAPITAL CORE PRINCIPLES FOR NEW LPs, WILLING TO UNDERSTAND HOW VC REALLY WORKS”…Today we’re going to explore four new core principles:Number 25. Courage is necessary to swallow one’s pride and invest in a deal at a high valuation after having passed on it previously.Number 26. Courage is also required to make an investment that nobody else supports, enduring the feeling of looking "stupid" to peers and partners.Number 27. The two primary psychological barriers preventing good decisions are the fear of missing out (FOMO) and the fear of looking stupid.Number 28. An investor’s largest decision errors typically stem from a psychological bias or emotional trap, not from calculation mistakes.Let’s dig in…First, courage is necessary to swallow one’s pride and invest in a deal at a high valuation after having passed on it previously.The hardest version of courage in VC is returning to a company you once passed on, now at a far higher price, because the renewed conviction must overcome both ego and the internal scrutiny of partners who remember the original pass. Benchmark initially declined Snap's seed round when it seemed like a niche teen messaging fad, but Mitch Lasky then led the firm into Snap's $13.5 million Series A at a $60–70 million valuation in 2013 and continued backing subsequent rounds at higher prices, a willingness to admit the initial hesitation was wrong that ultimately produced a return worth hundreds of millions when Snap went public at a $24 billion valuation in 2017.Second, courage is also required to make an investment that nobody else supports, enduring the feeling of looking “stupid” to peers and partners.Investing when nobody else will… Some of the most important investments in VC history were made by a single investor willing to write a cheque that every peer in the market considered either premature or irrational. When Fred Wilson and Union Square Ventures backed Twitter in July 2007, just four months after launch and with no discernible revenue model, they were essentially alone in their conviction that Twitter's network-effect architecture justified the bet—a position that peers found hard to defend at the time but that ultimately generated one of USV's defining returns.Third, the two primary psychological barriers preventing good decisions are the fear of missing out (FOMO) and the fear of looking stupid.NFX research identifies the two primary psychological forces distorting VC decisions as FOMO (fear of missing out) and FOLS (fear of looking stupid), and both reliably produce opposite but equally damaging errors. FOMO drives investors into crowded, late-stage rounds at consensus prices where upside is gone; FOLS prevents them from backing genuinely contrarian companies, like an Uber competitor after Uber raises billions, because the social risk of being wrong in public outweighs the financial logic of the investment.Finally, fourth, an investor’s largest decision errors typically stem from a psychological bias or emotional trap, not from calculation mistakes.Investment mistakes at the top level of VC are almost never arithmetic failures, they are failures of emotional discipline, where groupthink, overconfidence, or herd behaviour overrides rigorous underwriting. Tiger Global's 2021 venture fund deployed $12.7 billion into 315 startups in a single year, driven by FOMO-fuelled herding rather than independent conviction-based analysis, and the fund was subsequently marked down from $93 million to $65 million per unit with a negative 15% IRR, a bottom-decile outcome caused not by bad models but by the psychological trap of chasing consensus momentum at any price.
Stay tuned for our next episode, and meanwhile, you can reach out to us, Vertices Capital, on our website: vertices.vc [https://vertices.vc/]. Thank you for listening.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit verticescapital.substack.com [https://verticescapital.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1]