Replay the Glory Days

MTG The 1-Year Anniversary Special feat. Scott!

To celebrate a whole year of retro trips down memory lane, Tanner and Kyle are throwing out the usual playbook and doing something completely new. For our massive one-year anniversary episode, we are joined by the legendary Scott—who is here to guide us through our very first foray into the multiverse of Magic: The Gathering! In this super-sized, extra-long celebration, we are diving headfirst into the card-collecting addiction. We settled in for a super-long, couch-style hangout episode where Scott teaches us the ropes and shares some fascinating facts about the game's history. Plus, we indulge in the ultimate nostalgia high—ripping open booster packs and experiencing that "new card smell." Finally, we face off in our inaugural match. Whether you're an old-school Planeswalker or have never touched a deck in your life, come celebrate one year of the podcast with us! Send your game recommendations here! Include the game title and your name so we can give you a shoutout! [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2456859/fan_mail/new]

Ep.4 - Shadow of the Colossus

Tanner and Kyle finally cross "The Forbidden Lands" off their bucket list as they experience the 2005 Team Ico masterpiece for the very first time. From the breathtaking scale of the first Colossus to the moral weight of Wander’s quest, we’re breaking down our initial impressions. Is the horse control actually charming or just chaotic? Does the minimalist storytelling still hold up in 2026? Join us for a journey of giant swords, tragic falls, and a very loyal horse named Agro. Send your game recommendations here! Include the game title and your name so we can give you a shoutout! [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2456859/fan_mail/new]

Ep.3 - Uncharted 2

In this episode, Tanner and Kyle scale the heights of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, diving deep into Nathan Drake’s most cinematic adventure while veering into some hilarious tangents. Between the gunfights and betrayals, Kyle shares his experience finally playing his very first roguelike, which sparks a debate on the reckless mechanics of base jumping. From museum heists to questionable survival maths, it’s a packed deep dive into a PlayStation classic.  Send your game recommendations here! Include the game title and your name so we can give you a shoutout! [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2456859/fan_mail/new]

Ep.2 - Gears of War

Join Tanner and Kyle in the trenches as they rev up their chainsaw bayonets to fight off relentless hordes of Locusts in Gears of War! On this episode, the guys dive into the vanishing art of couch co-op and debate the merits of modern console exclusives. They also tackle a terrifying "what if": would you actually pay real money for a DLC just to be able to sprint? Whether you’re here for the hot takes or the tactical carnage, you can watch all the action on our brand-new YouTube show, First Impressions.  Send your game recommendations here! Include the game title and your name so we can give you a shoutout! [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2456859/fan_mail/new]

Ep.1 - GTA III

We’re back! To kick off the third season of the show, Tanner and Kyle are diving into the 2001 masterpiece that defined the open-world genre: Grand Theft Auto III. From the moody atmosphere of Staunton Island to the "silent but deadly" nature of our lead character, we’re breaking it all down. Plus, we settle the long-standing debate: Does the protagonist's name actually sucks? Tanner and Kyle share their theories on why "Claude" might (or might not) fit the bill. BIG ANNOUNCEMENT: We are launching a brand-new series called First Impressions! You can now head over to our YouTube channel to watch us play through these classics for the very first time. See the frustration, the awe, and the accidental car explosions on our YouTube channel! Send your game recommendations here! Include the game title and your name so we can give you a shoutout! [https://www.buzzsprout.com/2456859/fan_mail/new]