Don’t Make Me Watch That! - A Horror Podcast

Don't Make Me Watch Bring Her Back

Arguably the most upsetting movie from 2025, Jenna and Michelle try their best to describe the events of Bring Her Back in a way you can really sink your teeth into. Don't Make Me Watch That is a fun project from We Watch Shudder host Michelle, fellow horror lover Jenna, and their two squeamish friends, Sarah and Frisky! Each episode, Jenna and Michelle will describe in detail the entire plot of a movie they loved while Sarah and Frisky listen with apprehensive excitement. However, they are not great storytellers, and they don't remember what happens in movies very well. When one of them suddenly says, "Wait! We forgot about a thing at the beginning of the movie," your frustration will be shared with Sarah and Frisky as we all try to backpedal our way to the beginning of the plot. Don't Make Me Watch That is just a show about four friends sharing a love of horror movies, even though two of them refuse to watch them. Please note: We didn't realize there was another show that already did this same thing when we came up with the concept. They're better than us, and we acknowledge that. No hate here. We just do this for fun. #TheoryBasket #ChildVessel #ShedSnack

Don't Make Me Watch Saw (2004)

Come on... You knew it was just a matter of time until we did a Saw episode. The true surprise is that we were able to make two non-Saw episodes before being lured in. This is part one of a ten-part series. The other nine episodes don't have set release dates. There's a certain appeal in knowing that Sarah and Frisky never know when they might be subjected to more... As if the gruesome details from the 2004 film weren't exhilarating enough, Jenna and Michelle also had a lot of things to say about SAW The Musical: The Unauthorized Parody of Saw. (Spoiler alert: It's Saw but very, very horny.) Don't Make Me Watch That is a fun project from We Watch Shudder host Michelle, fellow horror lover Jenna, and their two squeamish friends, Sarah and Frisky! Each episode, Jenna and Michelle will describe in detail the entire plot of a movie they loved while Sarah and Frisky listen with apprehensive excitement. However, they are not great storytellers, and they don't remember what happens in movies very well. When one of them suddenly says, "Wait! We forgot about a thing at the beginning of the movie," your frustration will be shared with Sarah and Frisky as we all try to backpedal our way to the beginning of the plot. Don't Make Me Watch That is just a show about four friends sharing a love of horror movies, even though two of them refuse to watch them. Please note: We didn't realize there was another show that already did this same thing when we came up with the concept. They're better than us, and we acknowledge that. No hate here. We just do this for fun.

Don't Make Me Watch Weapons (2025)

Released in 2025, Weapons is told in several parts across various timelines. Jenna and Michelle try to recount the tale but wind up splitting it into even more parts and timelines. Don't Make Me Watch That is a fun project from We Watch Shudder host Michelle, fellow horror lover Jenna, and their two squeamish friends, Sarah and Frisky! Each episode, Jenna and Michelle will describe in detail the entire plot of a movie they loved while Sarah and Frisky listen with apprehensive excitement. However, they are not great storytellers, and they don't remember what happens in movies very well. When one of them suddenly says, "Wait! We forgot about a thing at the beginning of the movie," your frustration will be shared with Sarah and Frisky as we all try to backpedal our way to the beginning of the plot. Don't Make Me Watch That is just a show about four friends sharing a love of horror movies, even though two of them refuse to watch them. Please note: We didn't realize there was another show that already did this same thing when we came up with the concept. They're better than us, and we acknowledge that. No hate here. We just do this for fun.

Don't Make Me Watch Together (2025)

Body horror is Sarah's #1 "Nuh uh" film, so when Together was released, we knew it was the perfect opportunity to make the DMMWT debut. Don't Make Me Watch That is a fun project from We Watch Shudder host Michelle, fellow horror lover Jenna, and their two squeamish friends, Sarah and Frisky! Each episode, Jenna and Michelle will describe in detail the entire plot of a movie they loved while Sarah and Frisky listen with apprehensive excitement. However, they are not great storytellers, and they don't remember what happens in movies very well. When one of them suddenly says, "Wait! We forgot about a thing at the beginning of the movie," your frustration will be shared with Sarah and Frisky as we all try to backpedal our way to the beginning of the plot. Don't Make Me Watch That is just a show about four friends sharing a love of horror movies, even though two of them refuse to watch them. Please note: We didn't realize there was another show that already did this same thing when we came up with the concept. They're better than us, and we acknowledge that. No hate here. We just do this for fun.