The American Compass Podcast

Are we all post-liberals now?  The leading voice in the debate about what comes after liberalism, Notre Dame professor Patrick Deneen, joins the podcast to discuss where American politics is headed now that the push for a globalized society has failed to survive contact with geopolitical reality. He and Oren unpack the failures of the liberal age, from free trade and open borders to foreign wars of adventure, and how a new conservatism helped deliver its demise. Finally, they make sense of where the waning liberalism of today leaves conservatives, and why young people are at the heart of this shift to something better. Further reading: * "We Are All Postliberals Now [https://firstthings.com/events/we-are-all-postliberals-now-2/]," by Patrick Deneen

The United States remains wholly dependent upon China for 95% of rare earth elements, 100% reliant on imports for 15 critical minerals, and over 80% reliant for eleven more. These minerals enable everything from batteries to semiconductors—and without domestic access, America’s technological dominance is at risk. Robert Bryce, a leading energy policy scholar, joins Oren to explore how decades of shortsighted policy let China dominate critical supply chains, what it would take to rebuild them, and whether the West can shake off its complacent belief that “the market will fix it” before it’s too late. Finally, they close with a discussion on the promising future of domestic nuclear power. Further reading: * “Restoring Leadership in Critical Minerals [https://americancompass.org/restoring-leadership-in-critical-minerals/]” by Dean Ball * Read Robert Bryce’s Substack [https://robertbryce.substack.com]

Over the last two weeks, an online battle has broken out among the New Right over the Israel-Iran conflict and the Trump administration's bombing of an Iranian nuclear facility. Regardless of whether the recent ceasefire between Iran and Israel holds, the events so far have drawn clear dividing lines within the coalition. What does "America First" mean for Middle Eastern policy? Josh Hammer, author of Israel and Civilization [https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Israel-and-Civilization/Josh-Hammer/9781635769739], and Sohrab Ahmari, U.S. editor of UnHerd, join Oren to debate the wisdom of Trump's attack, the limits of Jacksonian restrictionist foreign policy, and how to think about the U.S. relationship with Israel. The group unpacks the intricacies of what a post-hegemonic world order actually looks like in the Middle East, and how best to respond to what could come next. Further reading: * “Is Israel the Ideal 'America First' Ally? [https://www.understandingamerica.co/p/is-israel-the-ideal-america-first]” by Oren Cass

Economists have claimed for years that Americans are prospering more than ever before. So why do so few people feel that way? Philip Pilkington, author of the forthcoming The Collapse of Global Liberalism [https://www.politybooks.com/bookdetail?book_slug=the-collapse-of-global-liberalism-and-the-emergence-of-the-post-liberal-world-order--9781509566211], joins Oren to discuss how these economic metrics are obscuring real problems. The two challenge the assumption that consumption is an unalloyed good and discuss the need to think about our nation's economic health in a way that centers human flourishing. Further reading: * “The Limits of Consumption Deepening: Why Consuming More Makes Us Poorer [https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2025/05/the-limits-of-consumption-deepening-why-consuming-more-makes-us-poorer/]” by Philip Pilkington

When news broke that the local paper mill in Chillicothe, OH, was closing its doors and laying off 780 employees, one Ohio senator made it his mission to fight for those workers. Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-OH) joins Oren to talk about his efforts to put American workers and their families first. The freshman senator explains how his background led him to Congress and breaks down the forces driving the political realignment he’s helping lead. The two discuss how the Republican Party can better serve its voters on labor, trade, and beyond, as well as the need to fight against private equity firms and other forces seeking to outsource American jobs.