A Local Swim League Banned Trans Athletes. Parents are Protesting.
Welcome back to another episode of the Round the Triangle podcast, where we are diving into a recent controversial decision made by the Virginia Peninsula Swim Union (VPSU) [https://www.facebook.com/swim.vpsu/] in February to reject USA Swimming's inclusive policies and instead require student athletes to compete based on sex assigned at birth, rather than their chosen gender. This decision has sparked debate and concern among parents and community members.
According to the VPSU February meeting minutes [https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24638065-vpsu_minutes_for_february_8__2024], President Corinne Picataggi [https://www.wm.edu/offices/it/about/staff/picataggi_c.php], who is also the Chief Technology Officer at the College of William & Mary, made the motion to vote on this amendment but later voted "no" and expressed concerns about potential discrimination. In her response to an email, Corinne stated that as president, she does not make motions or vote per the union’s bylaws. There were other contradictions in the minutes, so it’s possible the notes regarding her actions were also inaccurate.
One parent I corresponded with from Queens Lake, who wished to remain anonymous, said that the idea to require students to compete based on sex assigned at birth was initially raised in her community. While some families supported the rule change, many others, including the anonymous parent, chose to boycott the swim team in protest. However, that parent said she regrets that decision, wishing she would have stayed with the team, so she could have continued to talk with other parents about the decision from within the organization.
Our guest on this week’s podcast, Melissa, a parent of a swimmer from the Kingspoint Dolphins team, told me how this amendment came about and shared her opinion on how this decision goes against the league's spirit of openness and fun. While the policy most directly impacts transgender children, it also imposes more emphasis on competitive edge, which contradicts what the league was supposed to be about.
Melissa also speculates that this effort to ban trans athletes is tied to a broader conservative movement in York County, which has a school board with a right-wing majority. [https://www.roundthetriangle.com/p/the-rightwing-takeover-of-the-york]
If you are concerned about this decision and its impact on inclusivity and equality in youth sports, consider reaching out to the VPSU on Facebook [https://www.facebook.com/swim.vpsu/] to express your thoughts.
Additional Resources:
* The Rightwing Takeover of the York County School Board [https://www.roundthetriangle.com/p/the-rightwing-takeover-of-the-york]
* VPSU Facebook Page [https://www.facebook.com/swim.vpsu/]
* VPSU February Meeting Minutes [https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24638065-vpsu_minutes_for_february_8__2024]
Cover photo from Kingspoint Dolphins Swim Team page. [https://kingspoint.swimtopia.com/]
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.roundthetriangle.com [https://www.roundthetriangle.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1]
