Winston's Podcast

The one Catholic doctrine that Protestants should care about most

This episode explores what may be the most important Catholic doctrine for Protestants to seriously consider: the Eucharist. While Catholics and Protestants share core Christian beliefs about God, Jesus, and salvation, this is a uniquely Catholic claim with extremely high stakes on both sides. If the Eucharist truly is the body and blood of Jesus Christ, as the Catholic Church teaches, then it represents the most intimate way to encounter Him and something every Christian should seek. But if it is not true, then it raises serious concerns about worshiping what would be, in that case, only bread and wine. This episode lays out the logic, the historical weight behind the belief, and why this is not a doctrine that can be ignored, but one that deserves real attention and urgency.

What Happens at Catholic Mass? And Why?

In this episode, Winston explains what happens during a typical Sunday Catholic Mass and why it happens. He walks through the structure of the Mass, from the introductory rites and Scripture readings in the Liturgy of the Word to the homily, creed, and prayers, before focusing on the heart of the Mass, the Liturgy of the Eucharist. Drawing on biblical foundations, he explains how worship has always centered on sacrifice, culminating in Jesus Christ’s one perfect and eternal sacrifice on the cross. He unpacks the Catholic belief in the Eucharist, where the bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Christ, making that same sacrifice present, not repeated, and offered to the Father. The episode also highlights the meaning of receiving Communion as true union with Christ and concludes with the mission to go forth transformed by grace, helping listeners better understand the depth and purpose of the Mass.

If not sola scriptura, then what?

In this episode, I continue the conversation that followed my discussion on why Sola Scriptura ultimately did not hold up for me and why that realization led me into the Catholic Church. After several thoughtful conversations and questions from listeners, I take on the natural follow up question. If it is not Scripture alone, then what is the system Christ actually established for knowing what to believe? We go back to the very beginning of Christianity, before the New Testament existed, to look at how the first Christians learned the faith. By examining Christ’s commissioning of the apostles, the role of the Holy Spirit, and the authority given to the Church to teach, bind, and guard the truth, we see a model rooted in apostolic authority, succession, Scripture, and Tradition working together. I also address a common and serious objection. If the Catholic Church claims infallibility, how can it account for scandals, abuses, and sinful leaders throughout history? This leads to an important distinction between infallible teachings and the moral failures of fallible men, and why one does not negate the other. Finally, I reflect on why remaining in the Church Christ founded matters, not just intellectually, but spiritually. It is about unity, holiness, intimacy with Christ, and ultimately salvation.

Why Sola Scriptura can't be true...

In this episode, Winston explores the Christian doctrine of Sola Scriptura, the belief that Scripture alone is the only infallible authority for Christian faith. Drawing from personal experience and Church history, he explains what Sola Scriptura actually means, what it does not mean, and why many Christians assume it without ever examining it closely. Winston offers three key reasons why Sola Scriptura ultimately falls short. First, it is not taught in Scripture itself. Second, it cannot account for how the biblical canon was formed. Third, it has led to widespread division rather than unity within Christianity. By looking at early Christian beliefs, the role of the Church, and the historical development of the Bible, this episode invites listeners to rethink the idea of Scripture alone and consider the Catholic understanding of Scripture and authoritative interpretation. Whether you are Catholic, Protestant, or simply curious, this episode aims to challenge assumptions and encourage deeper reflection on how Christians know what they believe and why.

Why be Catholic and not just Christian?

In this episode, Winston tackles a common and important question: Why be Catholic? Exploring the Christian desire for unity and objective truth, the episode centers on one key idea - apostolicity. Winston explains how the Catholic Church today is the same Church founded by Jesus on the apostles, preserving the same mission, teachings, and authority for over 2,000 years. Through the lens of apostolic authority, truth, and unity, the episode shows how the Catholic Church provides a living teaching authority, safeguarded by the Holy Spirit, that maintains doctrinal truth and visible unity among believers. Drawing from Scripture and early Church history, Winston argues that this apostolic foundation leads to the fullness of Christianity - offering the sacraments, unity with Christ, and a deeper intimacy with Him. Whether you’re Catholic, Protestant, or simply curious, this episode invites you to consider how authority, truth, and unity fit into Christ’s plan for His Church - and why apostolicity matters.