Paranormal Unsettled

Lizzie Borden | Murder (and Acquittal) on Second Street

The story of Lizzie Borden remains one of the most infamous and unsettling murder cases in American history. In the summer of 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally murdered inside their Massachusetts home, their deaths so violent that the case would grip the nation for generations. At the center of it all stood Lizzie Borden, the daughter accused of committing the unthinkable. But what really happened inside that house on Second Street? In this episode, we examine the timeline of the murders, the evidence presented during the investigation, and the questions that still surround the case more than a century later. We explore the strange behavior reported after the killings, the media frenzy that turned Lizzie into a household name, and the courtroom battle that ended in one of history’s most controversial acquittals. From historical records and witness testimony to modern theories and paranormal claims tied to the Borden house itself, we take a closer look at the truth behind the legend. Was Lizzie Borden truly innocent, or did one of America’s darkest mysteries allow a killer to walk free? ----------------------------------- New Episodes are released every Monday at 3:07am EST.  Have ghost stories of your own? Join our subreddit (r/ParanormalUnsettled [https://www.reddit.com/r/ParanormalUnsettled/]) and share your haunted memories. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the episode, wherever you listen! Follow us on social media, YouTube [https://youtube.com/@johnnyclashxp], Instagram [https://instagram.com/paranormalunsettled], TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@paranormalunsettled] and Facebook. [https://www.facebook.com/people/Paranormal-Unsettled/61586804224057/] Paranormal Unsettled is written and produced by Johnny Clash.  For gaming content, Follow along @JohnnyFNClash [http://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] on Twitch [https://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] and Social Media [https://linktr.ee/johnnyclash]. Do you believe in ghosts? Wear it with pride! Check out the Paranormal Unsettled Shop. https://shop.paranormalunsettled.comshop.paranormalunsettled.com [http://shop.paranormalunsettled.com]. I’m Johnny Clash. I’m a dad, a gamer, a former pro wrestler and a paranormal enthusiast, and I believe there is something out there, something we don’t fully understand. But I’m not here to prove it, and I’m not here to debunk it. I’m here to observe, to explore, and to look closely at what happens when expectation meets the unknown. This is Paranormal Unsettled. Johnny Clash XP * YouTube.com/@johnnyclashxp * TikTok.com/@paranormalunsettled * Instagram.com/ParanormalUnsettled Johnny FN' Clash Gaming * Twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash * YouTube.com/@johnnyclash * X.com/johnnyfnclash * Instagram.com/johnnyfnclash * TikTok.com/@johnnyfnclash Join the Discord: https://discord.gg/zbR

Bathsheba Sherman | Conjuring a Hollywood Demon

The story of Bathsheba Sherman has become one of the most chilling legends tied to American paranormal history, often linked to the events that inspired The Conjuring. Said to be a woman accused of dark practices and cursed after death, her name has been woven into the haunting of a quiet Rhode Island farmhouse. But how much of that story is actually true? Who was Bathsheba Sherman, and what really happened during her life? In this episode, we dig into the historical records surrounding Bathsheba Sherman, separating documented fact from the terrifying claims that came much later. We explore the accusations made against her, the death of a child that fueled suspicion, and whether there is any real evidence tying her to witchcraft or something more sinister. From folklore and film to firsthand accounts and historical analysis, we examine how Bathsheba’s story evolved into one of the most infamous hauntings in modern culture. Was she truly something evil, or is her legacy the result of rumor, fear, and a story that grew far beyond the truth? ----------------------------------- New Episodes are released every Monday at 3:07am EST.  Have ghost stories of your own? Join our subreddit (r/ParanormalUnsettled [https://www.reddit.com/r/ParanormalUnsettled/]) and share your haunted memories. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the episode, wherever you listen! Follow us on social media, YouTube [https://youtube.com/@johnnyclashxp], Instagram [https://instagram.com/paranormalunsettled], TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@paranormalunsettled] and Facebook. [https://www.facebook.com/people/Paranormal-Unsettled/61586804224057/] Paranormal Unsettled is written and produced by Johnny Clash.  For gaming content, Follow along @JohnnyFNClash [http://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] on Twitch [https://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] and Social Media [https://linktr.ee/johnnyclash]. Do you believe in ghosts? Wear it with pride! Check out the Paranormal Unsettled Shop. https://shop.paranormalunsettled.comshop.paranormalunsettled.com [http://shop.paranormalunsettled.com]. I’m Johnny Clash. I’m a dad, a gamer, a former pro wrestler and a paranormal enthusiast, and I believe there is something out there, something we don’t fully understand. But I’m not here to prove it, and I’m not here to debunk it. I’m here to observe, to explore, and to look closely at what happens when expectation meets the unknown. This is Paranormal Unsettled. Johnny Clash XP * YouTube.com/@johnnyclashxp * TikTok.com/@paranormalunsettled * Instagram.com/ParanormalUnsettled Johnny FN' Clash Gaming * Twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash * YouTube.com/@johnnyclash * X.com/johnnyfnclash * Instagram.com/johnnyfnclash * TikTok.com/@johnnyfnclash Join the Discord: https://discord.gg/zbR

The Bell Witch | The Legend That Terrorized a Family

The legend of the Bell Witch is one of the most infamous hauntings in American history a spirit said to torment an entire family and leave a lasting mark on a quiet Tennessee farm. But how much of it is grounded in truth? What really happened to the Bell family, and who or what was behind the entity known as the Bell Witch? Was it something supernatural, a case of mass hysteria, or an elaborate story that grew over time? In this episode, we explore the origins of the Bell Witch legend, from the early disturbances experienced by John Bell and his family to the strange voice that claimed intelligence, intent, and even a name. We look at eyewitness accounts, historical documentation, and how the story spread beyond the farm and into American folklore. From chilling encounters to theories that attempt to explain the unexplained, we examine what can be verified, what remains speculation, and how the Bell Witch became one of the most talked about hauntings in history.  ----------------------------------- New Episodes are released every Monday at 3:07am EST.  Have ghost stories of your own? Join our subreddit (r/ParanormalUnsettled [https://www.reddit.com/r/ParanormalUnsettled/]) and share your haunted memories. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the episode, wherever you listen! Follow us on social media, YouTube [https://youtube.com/@johnnyclashxp], Instagram [https://instagram.com/paranormalunsettled], TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@paranormalunsettled] and Facebook. [https://www.facebook.com/people/Paranormal-Unsettled/61586804224057/] Paranormal Unsettled is written and produced by Johnny Clash.  For gaming content, Follow along @JohnnyFNClash [http://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] on Twitch and Social Media [https://linktr.ee/johnnyclash]. Do you believe in ghosts? Wear it with pride! Check out the Paranormal Unsettled Shop. https://shop.paranormalunsettled.comshop.paranormalunsettled.com [http://shop.paranormalunsettled.com]. I’m Johnny Clash. I’m a dad, a gamer, a former pro wrestler and a paranormal enthusiast, and I believe there is something out there, something we don’t fully understand. But I’m not here to prove it, and I’m not here to debunk it. I’m here to observe, to explore, and to look closely at what happens when expectation meets the unknown. This is Paranormal Unsettled. Johnny Clash XP * YouTube.com/@johnnyclashxp * TikTok.com/@paranormalunsettled * Instagram.com/ParanormalUnsettled Johnny FN' Clash Gaming * Twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash * YouTube.com/@johnnyclash * X.com/johnnyfnclash * Instagram.com/johnnyfnclash * TikTok.com/@johnnyfnclash Join the Discord: https://discord.gg/zbR

Moll Dyer | Fact, Folklore, and the Frozen Truth

The story of Moll Dyer is one of Maryland’s most enduring legends a woman accused, cast out, and forever tied to the land she died on. But how much of it is actually true? What do we really know about Moll Dyer and the events that turned her into a figure of fear and folklore? Was she a witch, a victim of hysteria, or something else entirely? In this episode, we break down the origins of the Moll Dyer story, from the harsh winter night that sealed her fate to the lingering presence said to remain in Leonardtown. We examine what was reported at the time, what has been documented, and how the story evolved through local accounts, oral tradition, and modern retellings. From historical records to paranormal claims, we separate fact from legend and explore how one woman’s final moments became one of the most chilling and debated hauntings in American folklore. ----------------------------------- New Episodes are released every Monday at 3:07am EST.  Have ghost stories of your own? Join our subreddit (r/ParanormalUnsettled [https://www.reddit.com/r/ParanormalUnsettled/]) and share your haunted memories. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the episode, wherever you listen! Follow us on social media, YouTube [https://youtube.com/@johnnyclashxp], Instagram [https://instagram.com/paranormalunsettled], TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@paranormalunsettled] and Facebook. [https://www.facebook.com/people/Paranormal-Unsettled/61586804224057/] Paranormal Unsettled is written and produced by Johnny Clash.  For gaming content, Follow along @JohnnyFNClash [http://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] on Twitch and Social Media [https://linktr.ee/johnnyclash]. Do you believe in ghosts? Wear it with pride! Check out the Paranormal Unsettled Shop. https://shop.paranormalunsettled.comshop.paranormalunsettled.com [http://shop.paranormalunsettled.com]. I’m Johnny Clash. I’m a dad, a gamer, a former pro wrestler and a paranormal enthusiast, and I believe there is something out there, something we don’t fully understand. But I’m not here to prove it, and I’m not here to debunk it. I’m here to observe, to explore, and to look closely at what happens when expectation meets the unknown. This is Paranormal Unsettled. Johnny Clash XP * YouTube.com/@johnnyclashxp * TikTok.com/@paranormalunsettled * Instagram.com/ParanormalUnsettled Johnny FN' Clash Gaming * Twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash * YouTube.com/@johnnyclash * X.com/johnnyfnclash * Instagram.com/johnnyfnclash * TikTok.com/@johnnyfnclash Join the Discord: https://discord.gg/zbR

Sarah Winchester | Trapped Inside the Mystery Mansion

The story of Sarah Winchester is one of the most infamous legends in paranormal history a grieving widow, a mansion that never stopped growing, and a belief that construction was the only way to outrun restless spirits. But how much of it is actually true? What do we really know about Sarah Winchester and the reasons behind her endless house? Was she guided by fear, belief, or something else entirely? In this episode, we break down the origins of the Winchester mystery, from the deaths that shaped Sarah’s life to the construction of her sprawling California home. We examine what was reported at the time, what has been documented, and how the story evolved through newspapers, folklore, and modern media. From historical records to paranormal claims, we separate fact from legend and explore how one woman’s life became one of the most enduring haunted stories ever told. ----------------------------------- New Episodes are released every Monday at 3:07am EST.  Have ghost stories of your own? Join our subreddit (r/ParanormalUnsettled [https://www.reddit.com/r/ParanormalUnsettled/]) and share your haunted memories. If you enjoy this podcast, please consider rating and reviewing the episode, wherever you listen! Follow us on social media, YouTube [https://youtube.com/@johnnyclashxp], Instagram [https://instagram.com/paranormalunsettled], TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@paranormalunsettled] and Facebook. [https://www.facebook.com/people/Paranormal-Unsettled/61586804224057/] Paranormal Unsettled is written and produced by Johnny Clash.  For gaming content, Follow along @JohnnyFNClash [http://twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash] on Twitch and Social Media [https://linktr.ee/johnnyclash]. Do you believe in ghosts? Wear it with pride! Check out the Paranormal Unsettled Shop. https://shop.paranormalunsettled.comshop.paranormalunsettled.com [http://shop.paranormalunsettled.com]. I’m Johnny Clash. I’m a dad, a gamer, a former pro wrestler and a paranormal enthusiast, and I believe there is something out there, something we don’t fully understand. But I’m not here to prove it, and I’m not here to debunk it. I’m here to observe, to explore, and to look closely at what happens when expectation meets the unknown. This is Paranormal Unsettled. Johnny Clash XP * YouTube.com/@johnnyclashxp * TikTok.com/@paranormalunsettled * Instagram.com/ParanormalUnsettled Johnny FN' Clash Gaming * Twitch.tv/johnnyfnclash * YouTube.com/@johnnyclash * X.com/johnnyfnclash * Instagram.com/johnnyfnclash * TikTok.com/@johnnyfnclash Join the Discord: https://discord.gg/zbR