Creepy Cases & Spooky Spaces with Cassi O'Peia

Creepy Case: Shadows Over Fallbrook

When an entire family disappears without a trace, theories multiply and questions outnumber answers. Joseph, Summer, and their two young sons vanished from their Southern California home in 2010. With no signs of struggle and only a bowl of popcorn left behind, investigators were left to untangle a web of strange clues, international suspicions, and a trail that went cold… until a shocking discovery in the desert changed everything. What really happened to the McStay family? And why did it take years for the truth to surface? Join me as I uncover one of the most haunting family disappearances in recent history.

Spooky Space: Curtain Call for the Damned

Today, we journey to Tombstone, Arizona - a town frozen in time, where echoes of gunfights, revelry, and whispered secrets still drift down the dusty streets. At the heart of this legendary town lies the Bird Cage Theatre—a place where history and the supernatural intertwine. Equal parts saloon, theatre, gambling hall, and brothel, the Bird Cage Theatre opened its doors on Christmas Day in 1881, and quickly became one of the most infamous spots in the American West.

Creepy Case: Vanished in Berea

On June 22, 2013, a bright, spirited 18-year-old vanished from a house in Berea, Kentucky. In the years since, no arrests have been made, no remains have been found, and no clear answers have surfaced. Her case is cold - but far from forgotten. Who was Brookelyn Farthing? What happened the night she went missing leaving behind a puzzling trail of clues left behind, and her family who continues to fight for justice more than a decade later.

Creepy Case: Successful. Quiet. Gone.

Season eight begins with diving into a case that has baffled investigators, spawned ghost stories, and stirred Cold War conspiracy theories for nearly seventy years. It’s the story of William and Margaret Patterson. A quiet, affluent couple from El Paso, Texas—respected business owners who simply vanished one day in 1957... leaving behind a house full of belongings, a confused community, and a trail of strange letters and shifting stories.

Spooky Space: Morris - Jumel Mansion

Join me as I take you on a fascinating journey through the Morris-Jumel Mansion, Manhattan’s oldest house, as I uncover the mansion’s rich history. From its origins as a grand estate in the 18th century to its role as George Washington’s headquarters during the Revolutionary War. Discover the captivating lives of its past living residents, and its current spirits. Subscribe and listen now for a trip back in time! 🎧✨ Become a Patron for bonus content, a merchandise discount, & More! www.patreon.com/creepycasesspookyspaces