Eli + Jonathan Hutcherson on Writing 1,500+ Songs, Faith & Anxiety in Nashville | Ep. 17
Our guests this week are brothers, songwriters, and artists Jonathan and Eli Hutcherson, who grew up eight years apart in a small Kentucky town with almost no music in the family and somehow, serendipitously, they both ended up chasing the dream in Nashville and are each actively crushing it. Since making it to town, Jonathan spent seven years as an artist and writer with Creative Nation (where he's still signed as a songwriter), while Eli is actively stepping into the independent world himself as an artist.
In this conversation, the Hutchersons get honest about what it takes to survive a writer's room: managing ego (and the insecurity hiding underneath it), letting a co-writer ride the wave instead of stepping on it, and why being yourself matters more than being impressive. They break down the real difference between publishing and masters, why streaming has changed who gets paid and how, and what pushed them both toward independence over a label deal. They also open up about faith, anxiety, and a brotherhood that turns competition into collaboration.
Whether you're a songwriter finding your voice, an indie artist weighing your options, or just someone who loves a good sibling story, this one's full of heart, hustle, and hard-won wisdom from two brothers building their own lane in Music City. Enjoy!
00:00 – Welcome & Intro: Eli + Jonathan Hutcherson
01:19 – Growing Up in Kentucky & a Family With Almost No Music
04:02 – Moving to Nashville at 18 & Signing With Creative Nation
05:44 – Finding (and Hiding) a Love for Music Growing Up
09:04 – Skipping College & Learning the Industry by Doing It
12:18 – Writing 1,500+ Songs & the "Water Spigot" Theory of Craft
15:13 – Learning From Luke Laird, Matt Jenkins & Nashville's Best Writers
17:45 – How Ego (and Insecurity) Kills a Writing Room
21:52 – Writing Together as Brothers Without Competing
27:45 – Letting a Co-Writer "Ride the Wave"
29:25 – Writing for an Artist's Voice, Not Your Own
33:21 – Believing in Your Songs Before Anyone Else Does
38:55 – Faith, David & the Psalms as Songwriting Therapy
44:55 – Finding Your Identity & Your Own Creative Stamp
47:00 – Loving Yourself, Loving Others & Where That Comes From
50:11 – Letting Emotions Roll In Instead of Fighting Them
56:03 – Publishing vs. Masters, Explained Simply
59:33 – How Streaming Changed Who Actually Gets Paid
1:00:48 – Why They Chose Independence Over a Label Deal
1:08:24 – Building a Fanbase From Nothing (and Sleeping in a Minivan)
1:09:44 – "Go Fail": The Case for Just Putting Music Out
1:14:12 – Anchors, Storms & Finding What Holds You Steady
1:17:34 – Brotherhood Over Competition
Follow Jonathan Hutcherson:
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/jonhutch/]
TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@jonathanhutcherson]
YouTube [https://www.youtube.com/@JonathanHutchersonMusic]
Facebook [https://www.facebook.com/jonathanhutchersonmusic]
Follow Eli Hutcherson:
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/elihutch_music/]
TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@elihutcherson_music]
YouTube [https://www.youtube.com/@eli.music1]
Follow The Bilby + Ella Show:
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/bilbynella/]
YouTube [https://www.youtube.com/@BilbynElla]
TikTok [https://www.tiktok.com/@bilbynella]
Join Our Community [https://beacons.ai/bilbynella]
Follow Hill:
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/hillelliottmusic/]
Follow Willie:
Instagram [https://www.instagram.com/williegoinham/]